Abstract:Introduction: Do externalities work and matter differently in a world of scarcity vs. a world of abundance? In this article, we critically examine the economic phenomena of externalities. The concept of externality, an important idea in economics and law, is useful in exploring the complex and dynamic relationships between resource supply and human flourishing within various sociotechnical systems. Methods: First, we define the basic concept and explain why it is fundamental to economic analysis of complex social environments Second, we briefly survey the intellectual history of externalities with the goal of tying together a few different strands of economic theory and providing a roadmap for a general theory of externalities. This discussion highlights a latent conflict between those who pursue and those who resist perfectibility (optimization) of social systems by internalizing externalities. Third, we compare externalities in worlds of scarcity and abundance. Results: This article develops the theoretical framework, including a brief intellectual history and notes toward the development of a general theory of externalities. As a conceptual tool, externalities enable one to identify and examine social interdependencies and to map their causes and consequences. Externalities provide evidence of social demand for governance institutions. This descriptive utility can and should inform normative analysis, the design of governance institutions, and comparative institutional analysis. We also raise a series of (mostly empirical) questions that should frame comparative institutional analysis and evaluation of different externalities in the digital networked world. Discussion: We focus on the scarcity and abundance of knowledge resources and the (technological) means for participating in the production, dissemination, and modification of such resources. In the real, necessarily imperfect world where abundance and scarcity vary across resources, people, and contexts, externalities persist, indicate social demand for governance, and inform comparative analysis and design of governance institutions. Jel classification: D62, B52, D02.

Extending Social Resource Exchange to Events of Abundance and Sufficiency

Externalities, scarcity, and abundance

Consuming Less as a Rational Choice: A Review of Applied Social Exchange Theory in Topical Research on Sustainable Consumption

Social Exchange Theory: An Interdisciplinary Review

An Initial Model of Scarcity

Why scarcity can both increase and decrease prosocial behaviour: A review and theoretical framework for the complex relationship between scarcity and prosociality

Rationality and the exploitation of natural resources: a psychobiological conceptual model for sustainability

Utility and Happiness in a Prosperous Society

Social exchange theory: Systematic review and future directions

Poverty and economic decision making: a review of scarcity theory

An integrative theory of resource discrepancies

Restrained by Resources: the Effect of Scarcity Cues and Childhood Socioeconomic Status (SES) on Consumer Preference for Feasibility

The Effect of Scarcity on Individuals' Psychology and Behavior:An Explanation from a More Integrated Perspective

Social Exchange Theory on Romantic Relationships

Efficiency and equity in a socially-embedded economy

Social Exchange in Work Settings: Content, Process, and Mixed Models

Twenty-five years of random asset exchange modeling

On the Theoretical Foundations of Data Exchange Economies

On the Efficiency of Sharing Economy Networks

Relief and stimulus in a cross-sector multi-product scarce resource supply chain network