Abstract:Purpose The continued evolution of influencer marketing has created a need to better understand influencer marketing effectiveness. With brands increasingly partnering with influencers, research is yet to provide an integrated perspective examining the critical role of both parties. This study aims to draw on the source credibility model and signaling theory to explain the mechanisms that matter in influencer marketing effectiveness. Design/methodology/approach The proposed model of influencer marketing effectiveness is analyzed using partial least squares with data from 281 followers of social media influencers. Findings The authors establish influencer characteristics of popularity and attractiveness as heuristic cues that inform judgments of influencer efficacy. Further, category involvement and altruistic motives for collaboration are shown to moderate followers' reliance on these heuristic cues. Then, a sequential mediating effect demonstrates the critical roles of the influencer and partner brand in three desired outcomes: enhanced perception of brand authenticity, enhanced brand engagement and positive attitudes toward influencer posts. Research limitations/implications Future research should consider other heuristic cues that could inform influencer efficacy judgments and switch the focus toward the partner brand's impact on such judgments. Practical implications A step-by-step visual framework is presented to help marketers and influencers translate these findings into key responsibilities for developing more effective and collaborative partnerships. Originality/value Besides presenting an integrated perspective, signaling theory provides an original lens for explaining influencer marketing effectiveness, addressing the need to expand the theoretical boundaries of influencer marketing research.

Influencer marketing effectiveness: giving competence, receiving credibility

Influencer marketing: explaining the effects of influencer self-presentation strategies on brand responses through source credibility

Social media influencer popularity and authenticity perception in the travel industry

Unveiling influence: influencer's sensitive self-disclosure and its persuasive impact

The effects of social media influencers’ self-disclosure on behavioral intentions: The role of source credibility, parasocial relationships, and brand trust

Credibility of social media influencers: Impact on purchase intention

Influencer marketing effectiveness: the mechanisms that matter

Influencer marketing on Instagram: How sponsorship disclosure, influencer credibility, and brand credibility impact the effectiveness of Instagram promotional post

The role of engagement in travel influencer marketing: the perspectives of dual process theory and the source credibility model

Beyond Influencer Credibility: The Power of Content and Parasocial Relationship on Processing Social Media Influencer Destination Marketing Campaigns

Influencers' intimate self-disclosure and its impact on consumers' self-brand connections: scale development, validation, and application

Are they humans or are they robots? The effect of virtual influencer disclosure on brand trust

Influencer Marketing: Role of Influencer Credibility and Congruence on Brand Attitude and eWOM

Influencer marketing in the promotion of tourist destinations: mega, macro and micro-influencers

Influencer Marketing Effectiveness

Social Media Influencers’ Traits and Purchase Intention: A Moderated Mediation Effect of Attitude Towards Brand Credibility and Brand Familiarity

Celebrity vs. Influencer endorsements in advertising: the role of identification, credibility, and Product-Endorser fit

Ethics of Authenticity: Social Media Influencers and the Production of Sponsored Content

How and when social media influencers' intimate self-disclosure fosters purchase intentions: the roles of congruency and parasocial relationships

Disclosure, content cues, emotions and behavioural engagement in social media influencer marketing: an exploratory multi-stakeholder perspective