Fluctuations in a Spin Glass model with 1RSB

M. E. Ferrero,G. Parisi,P. Ranieri

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/9607186

1996-07-26

Abstract:We discuss Gaussian fluctuations in a spin glass model with one replica symmetry breaking. We show how non-perturbative fluctuations of the break-point parameter can be included in the longitudinal propagator within linear response theory.

Condensed Matter

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

On one-step replica symmetry breaking in the Edwards-Anderson spin glass model

Gino Del Ferraro,Chuang Wang,Hai-Jun Zhou,Erik Aurell

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-5468/2016/07/073305

2016-07-24

Abstract:We consider a one-step replica symmetry breaking description of the Edwards-Anderson spin glass model in 2D. The ingredients of this description are a Kikuchi approximation to the free energy and a second-level statistical model built on the extremal points of the Kikuchi approximation, which are also fixed points of a Generalized Belief Propagation (GBP) scheme. We show that a generalized free energy can be constructed where these extremal points are exponentially weighted by their Kikuchi free energy and a Parisi parameter $y$, and that the Kikuchi approximation of this generalized free energy leads to second-level, one-step replica symmetry breaking (1RSB), GBP equations. We then proceed analogously to Bethe approximation case for tree-like graphs, where it has been shown that 1RSB Belief Propagation equations admit a Survey Propagation solution. We discuss when and how the one-step-replica symmetry breaking GBP equations that we obtain also allow a simpler class of solutions which can be interpreted as a class of Generalized Survey Propagation equations for the single instance graph case.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Mechanics,Computational Physics
Replica Symmetry Breaking in Critical Phenomena in Long-Range Disordered Ferromagnets

XT Wu,CD Gong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0253-6102/31/4/561

1999-01-01

Communications in Theoretical Physics

Abstract:The replica symmetry breaking (RSB) is investigated in -component ferromagnetic spin systems with a long-range disorder, with a correlation function obeying a power law . The Landau–Ginzburg Hamiltonian with an RSB quartic interaction term is studied, with the renormalization-group expansion in and , where is the spatial dimension. It is shown that the long-range disorder fixed point found previously is unstable under the perturbation of RSB for and stable for . The RSB fixed points are calculated and there is no physical stable fixed point for .
Replica Symmetry Broken States of some Glass Models

J. Yeo,M. A. Moore

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.108.054134

2023-11-02

Abstract:We have studied in detail the $M$-$p$ balanced spin glass model, especially the case $p=4$. These types of model have relevance to structural glasses. The models possess two kinds of broken replica states; those with one-step replica symmetry breaking (1RSB) and those with full replica symmetry breaking (FRSB). To determine which arises requires studying the Landau expansion to quintic order. There are 9 quintic order coefficients, and 5 quartic order coefficients, whose values we determine for this model. We show that it is only for $2 \leq M < 2.4714 \cdots$ that the transition at mean-field level is to a state with FRSB, while for larger $M$ values there is either a continuous transition to a state with 1RSB (when $ M \leq 3$) or a discontinuous transition for $M > 3$. The Gardner transition from a 1RSB state at low temperatures to a state with FRSB also requires the Landau expansion to be taken to quintic order. Our result for the form of FRSB in the Gardner phase is similar to that found when $2 \leq M < 2.4714\cdots$, but differs from that given in the early paper of Gross et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 55, 304 (1985)]. Finally we discuss the effects of fluctuations on our mean-field solutions using the scheme of Höller and Read [Phys. Rev. E 101, 042114 (2020)}] and argue that such fluctuations will remove both the continuous 1RSB transition and discontinuous 1RSB transitions when $8 >d \geq 6$ leaving just the FRSB continuous transition. We suggest values for $M$ and $p$ which might be used in simulations to confirm whether fluctuation corrections do indeed remove the 1RSB transitions.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Mechanics
Simultaneous replica-symmetry breaking for vector spin glasses

Hong-Bin Chen,Jean-Christophe Mourrat

2024-11-21

Abstract:We consider mean-field vector spin glasses with possibly non-convex interactions. Up to a small perturbation of the parameters defining the model, the asymptotic behavior of the Gibbs measure is described in terms of a critical point of an explicit functional. In this paper, we study some properties of these critical points. Under modest assumptions ensuring that different types of spins interact, we show that the replica-symmetry-breaking structures of the different types of spins are in one-to-one correspondence with one another. For instance, if some type of spins displays one level of replica-symmetry breaking, then so do all the other types of spins. This extends the recent results of [Electronic Journal of Probability, 27:1-75, 2022] and [Comm. Math. Phys., 394(3):1101-1152, 2022] that were obtained in the case of multi-species spherical spin glasses with convex interactions.

Probability,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks
Replica-symmetry breaking transitions in the large deviations of the ground-state of a spherical spin-glass

Bertrand Lacroix-A-Chez-Toine,Yan V. Fyodorov,Pierre Le Doussal

2023-07-06

Abstract:We derive, within the replica formalism, a generalisation of the Crisanti-Sommers formula to describe the large deviation function (LDF) ${\cal L}(e)$ for the speed-$N$ atypical fluctuations of the intensive ground-state energy $e$ of a generic spherical spin-glass in the presence of a random external magnetic field of variance $\Gamma$. We then analyse our exact formula for the LDF in much detail for the Replica symmetric, single step Replica Symmetry Breaking (1-RSB) and Full Replica Symmetry Breaking (FRSB) situations. Our main qualitative conclusion is that the level of RSB governing the LDF may be different from that for the typical ground state. We find that while the deepest ground-states are always controlled by a LDF of replica symmetric form, beyond a finite threshold $e\geq e_{t}$ a replica-symmetry breaking starts to be operative. These findings resolve the puzzling discrepancy between our earlier replica calculations for the $p=2$ spherical spin-glass and the rigorous results by Dembo and Zeitouni which we are able to reproduce invoking an 1-RSB pattern. Finally at an even larger critical energy $e_{c}\geq e_{t}$, acting as a "wall", the LDF diverges logarithmically, which we interpret as a change in the large deviation speed from $N$ to a faster growth. In addition, we show that in the limit $\Gamma \to 0$ the LDF takes non-trivial scaling forms (i) ${\cal L}(e) \sim G((e-e_c)/\Gamma)$ in the vicinity of the wall (ii) ${\cal L}(e) \sim \Gamma^{\eta \nu} F((e-e_{\rm typ})/\Gamma^{\nu})$ in the vicinity of the typical energy, characterised by two new exponents $\eta\geq 1$ and $\nu$ characterising universality classes. Via matching the latter allows us to formulate several conjectures concerning the regime of {\it typical fluctuations}, identified as $e-e_{\rm typ} \sim N^{-1/\eta}$ and $\Gamma \sim N^{-1/(\eta \nu)}$.

Statistical Mechanics,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Mathematical Physics
Replica Symmetry Breaking and the Renormalization Group Theory of the Weakly Disordered Ferromagnet

Viktor Dotsenko,D.E.Feldman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0305-4470/28/18/010

1995-02-15

Abstract:We study the critical properties of the weakly disordered $p$-component ferromagnet in terms of the renormalization group (RG) theory generalized to take into account the replica symmetry breaking (RSB) effects coming from the multiple local minima solutions of the mean-field equations. It is shown that for $p < 4$ the traditional RG flows at dimensions $D=4-\epsilon$, which are usually considered as describing the disorder-induced universal critical behavior, are unstable with respect to the RSB potentials as found in spin glasses. It is demonstrated that for a general type of the Parisi RSB structures there exists no stable fixed points, and the RG flows lead to the {\it strong coupling regime} at the finite scale $R_{*} \sim \exp(1/u)$, where $u$ is the small parameter describing the disorder. The physical concequences of the obtained RG solutions are discussed. In particular, we argue, that discovered RSB strong coupling phenomena indicate on the onset of a new spin glass type critical behaviour in the temperature interval $\tau < \tau_{*} \sim \exp(-1/u)$ near $T_{c}$. Possible relevance of the considered RSB effects for the Griffith phase is also discussed.

Condensed Matter
Exactly solvable quantum spin-glass model with 1RSB-fullRSB transition

Naoto Shiraishi

2024-10-04

Abstract:We introduce a novel quantum spin-glass model, a Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model with a transverse mean-field type random magnet. We rigorously derive the exact expression of the free energy of this model at the entire parameter region. The obtained exact solution implies the existence of a 1RSB-fullRSB transition at low temperatures. Our technique can be applied to general classical spin models, telling that any solvable classical spin model has its solvable quantum counterpart.

Statistical Mechanics,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Mathematical Physics,Quantum Physics
Quantum Fluctuations of a Nearly Critical Heisenberg Spin Glass

A. Georges,O. Parcollet,S. Sachdev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.63.134406

2000-09-26

Abstract:We describe the interplay of quantum and thermal fluctuations in the infinite-range Heisenberg spin glass. This model is generalized to SU(N) symmetry, and we describe the phase diagram as a function of the spin S and the temperature T. The model is solved in the large N limit and certain universal critical properties are shown to hold to all orders in 1/N. For large S, the ground state is a spin glass, but quantum effects are crucial in determining the low T thermodynamics: we find a specific heat linear in T and a local spectral density of spin excitations linear in frequency for a spin glass state which is marginally stable to fluctuations in the replicon modes. For small S, the spin-glass order is fragile, and a spin-liquid state dominates the properties over a significant range of temperatures and frequencies. We argue that the latter state may be relevant in understanding the properties of strongly-disordered transition metal and rare earth compounds.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks
Spin glass models with ferromagnetically biased couplings on the Bethe lattice: analytic solutions and numerical simulations

Tommaso Castellani,Florent Krzakala,Federico Ricci-Tersenghi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjb/e2005-00293-1

2005-05-07

Abstract:We derive the zero-temperature phase diagram of spin glass models with a generic fraction of ferromagnetic interactions on the Bethe lattice. We use the cavity method at the level of one-step replica symmetry breaking (1RSB) and we find three phases: A replica-symmetric (RS) ferromagnetic one, a magnetized spin glass one (the so-called mixed phase), and an unmagnetized spin glass one. We are able to give analytic expressions for the critical point where the RS phase becomes unstable with respect to 1RSB solutions: we also clarify the mechanism inducing such a phase transition. Finally we compare our analytical results with the outcomes of a numerical algorithm especially designed for finding ground states in an efficient way, stressing weak points in the use of such numerical tools for discovering RSB effects. Some of the analytical results are given for generic connectivity.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Mechanics
Replica symmetry breaking in spin glasses in the replica-free Keldysh formalism

Johannes Lang,Subir Sachdev,Sebastian Diehl

2024-09-11

Abstract:We show that the algebra of Parisi ultrametric matrices is recovered by the real-time, replica-free, Dyson-Keldysh equations of infinite-range quantum spin glasses in the late time glassy limit. This connects to earlier results on classical and quantum systems showing how ultrametricity emerges from the persistent slow aging dynamics of the glass phase. The stationary spin glass state thereby spontaneously breaks thermal symmetry, or the Kubo-Martin-Schwinger relation of a state in global thermal equilibrium. We describe the Keldysh path integral of the infinite-range Ising model in transverse and longitudinal fields, and in the context of the Landau expansion of the action functional, show how the long-time limit connects to the full replica symmetry breaking obtained in the equilibrium formalism. We also illustrate our formalism by applying it to the spherical quantum $p$-spin model, which only exhibits one-step replica symmetry breaking

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Mechanics,Strongly Correlated Electrons,Mathematical Physics,Quantum Physics
Equilibrium dynamics of infinite-range quantum spin glasses in a field

Maria Tikhanovskaya,Subir Sachdev,Rhine Samajdar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PRXQuantum.5.020313

2023-09-07

Abstract:We determine the low-energy spectrum and Parisi replica symmetry breaking function for the spin glass phase of the quantum Ising model with infinite-range random exchange interactions and transverse and longitudinal ($h$) fields. We show that, for all $h$, the spin glass state has full replica symmetry breaking, and the local spin spectrum is gapless with a spectral density which vanishes linearly with frequency. These results are obtained using an action functional$\unicode{x2014}$argued to yield exact results at low frequencies$\unicode{x2014}$that expands in powers of a spin glass order parameter, which is is bilocal in time, and a matrix in replica space. We also present the exact solution of the infinite-range spherical quantum $p$-rotor model at nonzero $h$: here, the spin glass state has one-step replica symmetry breaking, and gaplessness only appears after imposition of an additional marginal stability condition. Possible connections to experiments on random arrays of trapped Rydberg atoms are noted.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Mechanics,Strongly Correlated Electrons,Mathematical Physics,Quantum Physics
Universal fragility of spin-glass ground-states under single bond changes

Mutian Shen,Gerardo Ortiz,Yang-Yu Liu,Martin Weigel,Zohar Nussinov

2024-03-15

Abstract:We consider the effect of perturbing a single bond on ground-states of nearest-neighbor Ising spin-glasses, with a Gaussian distribution of the coupling constants, across various two and three-dimensional lattices and regular random graphs. Our results reveal that the ground-states are strikingly susceptible to such changes. Altering the strength of only a single bond beyond a critical threshold value leads to a new ground-state that differs from the original one by a droplet of flipped spins whose boundary and volume diverge with the system size -- an effect that is reminiscent of the more familiar phenomenon of disorder chaos. These elementary fractal-boundary zero-energy droplets and their composites feature robust characteristics and provide the lowest-energy macroscopic spin-glass excitations. Remarkably, within numerical accuracy, the size of such droplets conforms to a nearly universal power-law distribution with exponents dependent on the spatial dimension of the system. Furthermore, the critical coupling strengths adhere to a stretched Gaussian distribution that is predominantly determined by the local coordination number.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Mechanics
Hypergraph Counting and Mixed $p$-Spin Glass Models under Replica Symmetry

Partha S. Dey,Qiang Wu

2024-07-13

Abstract:We study the fluctuation problems at high temperature in the general mixed $p$-spin glass models under the weak external field assumption: $h= \rho N^{-\alpha}, \rho>0, \alpha \in [1/4,\infty]$. By extending the cluster expansion approach to this generic setting, we convert the fluctuation problem as a hypergraph counting problem and thus obtain a new multiple-transition phenomenon. A by-product of our results is a new critical inverse temperature obtained from optimal second moment estimates. In particular, all our fluctuation results hold up to the threshold. Combining with multivariate Stein's method, we also obtain an explicit convergence rate under proper moment assumptions on the general symmetric disorder. Our results have several further implications. First, our approach works for both even and odd pure $p$-spin models. The leading cluster structures in the odd $p$ case are different and more involved than in the even $p$ case. This combinatorially explains the folklore that odd $p$-spin is more complicated than even $p$. Second, in the mixed $p$-spin setting, the cluster structures differ depending on the relation between the minimum effective even and odd $p$-spins: $p_e$ and $p_o$. As an example, at $h=0$, there are three sub-regimes: $p_e<p_o, p_o<p_e<2p_o, p_e\ge 2p_o$, wherein the first and third ones, the mixed model behaves essentially like a pure $p$-spin model, and only in the second regime, it is more like a mixture. This gives another criterion for classifying mean-field spin glass models compared to the work of Auffinger and Ben Arous (Ann.~Probab.~41 (2013), no.~6, 4214--4247), where the idea is based on complexity computations for spherical models. Third, our framework naturally implies a multi-scale fluctuation phenomenon conjectured in the work of Bovier and Schertzer (Probab. Theory Relat. Fields (2024)).

Probability,Mathematical Physics
Comment on ``Spherical 2 + p spin-glass model: An analytically solvable model with a glass-to-glass transition''

V. Krakoviack

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.76.136401

2007-07-06

Abstract:Guided by old results on simple mode-coupling models displaying glass-glass transitions, we demonstrate, through a crude analysis of the solution with one step of replica symmetry breaking (1RSB) derived by Crisanti and Leuzzi for the spherical $s+p$ mean-field spin glass [Phys. Rev. B 73, 014412 (2006)], that the phase behavior of these systems is not yet fully understood when $s$ and $p$ are well separated. First, there seems to be a possibility of glass-glass transition scenarios in these systems. Second, we find clear indications that the 1RSB solution cannot be correct in the full glassy phase. Therefore, while the proposed analysis is clearly naive and probably inexact, it definitely calls for a reassessment of the physics of these systems, with the promise of potentially interesting new developments in the theory of disordered and complex systems.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks
Multifractality in spin glasses

Janus Collaboration,M. Baity-Jesi,E. Calore,A. Cruz,L.A. Fernandez,J.M. Gil-Narvion,I. Gonzalez-Adalid Pemartin,A. Gordillo-Guerrero,D. Iñiguez,A. Maiorano,E. Marinari,V. Martin-Mayor,J. Moreno-Gordo,A. Muñoz Sudupe,D. Navarro,I. Paga,G. Parisi,S. Perez-Gaviro,F. Ricci-Tersenghi,J.J. Ruiz-Lorenzo,S.F. Schifano,B. Seoane,A. Tarancon,D. Yllanes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2312880120

2024-01-22

Abstract:We unveil the multifractal behavior of Ising spin glasses in their low-temperature phase. Using the Janus II custom-built supercomputer, the spin-glass correlation function is studied locally. Dramatic fluctuations are found when pairs of sites at the same distance are compared. The scaling of these fluctuations, as the spin-glass coherence length grows with time, is characterized through the computation of the singularity spectrum and its corresponding Legendre transform. A comparatively small number of site pairs controls the average correlation that governs the response to a magnetic field. We explain how this scenario of dramatic fluctuations (at length scales smaller than the coherence length) can be reconciled with the smooth, self-averaging behavior that has long been considered to describe spin-glass dynamics.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks
Stochastic equations and dynamics beyond mean-field theory

Tommaso Rizzo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2209.09689

2022-09-20

Abstract:The dynamical transition occurring in spin-glass models with one step of Replica-Symmetry-Breaking is a mean-field artifact that disappears in finite systems and/or in finite dimensions. The critical fluctuations that smooth the transition are described in the $\beta$ regime by dynamical stochastic equations. The quantitative parameters of the dynamical stochastic equations have been computed analytically on the 3-spin Bethe lattice Spin-Glass by means of the (static) cavity method and the equations have been solved numerically. The resulting parameter-free dynamical predictions are shown here to be in excellent agreement with numerical simulation data for the correlation and its fluctuations.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks
Small field chaos in spin glasses: universal predictions from the ultrametric tree and comparison with numerical simulations

Miguel Aguilar-Janita,Silvio Franz,Victor Martin-Mayor,Javier Moreno-Gordo,Giorgio Parisi,Federico Ricci-Tersenghi,Juan J. Ruiz-Lorenzo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2404973121

2024-09-27

Abstract:We study the chaotic behavior of the Gibbs state of spin-glasses under the application of an external magnetic field, in the crossover region where the field intensity scales proportional to $1/\sqrt{N}$, being $N$ the system size. We show that Replica Symmetry Breaking (RSB) theory provides universal predictions for chaotic behavior: they depend only on the zero-field overlap probability function $P(q)$ and are independent of other features of the system. Using solely $P(q)$ as input we can analytically predict quantitatively the statistics of the states in a small field. In the infinite volume limit, each spin-glass sample is characterized by an infinite number of states that have a tree-like structure. We generate the corresponding probability distribution through efficient sampling using a representation based on the Bolthausen-Sznitman coalescent. In this way, we can compute quantitatively properties in the presence of a magnetic field in the crossover region, the overlap probability distribution in the presence of a small field and the degree of decorrelation as the field is increased. To test our computations, we have simulated the Bethe lattice spin glass and the 4D Edwards-Anderson model, finding in both cases excellent agreement with the universal predictions.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks
Slow Nonthermalizing Dynamics in a Quantum Spin Glass

Louk Rademaker,Dmitry A. Abanin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.125.260405

2021-01-13

Abstract:Spin glasses and many-body localization (MBL) are prime examples of ergodicity breaking, yet their physical origin is quite different: the former phase arises due to rugged classical energy landscape, while the latter is a quantum-interference effect. Here we study quantum dynamics of an isolated 1d spin-glass under application of a transverse field. At high energy densities, the system is ergodic, relaxing via resonance avalanche mechanism, that is also responsible for the destruction of MBL in non-glassy systems with power-law interactions. At low energy densities, the interaction-induced fields obtain a power-law soft gap, making the resonance avalanche mechanism inefficient. This leads to the persistence of the spin-glass order, as demonstrated by resonance analysis and by numerical studies. A small fraction of resonant spins forms a thermalizing system with long-range entanglement, making this regime distinct from the conventional MBL. The model considered can be realized in systems of trapped ions, opening the door to investigating slow quantum dynamics induced by glassiness.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Mechanics,Strongly Correlated Electrons,Quantum Physics
Griffiths-type theorems for short-range spin glass models

Chigak Itoi,Hisamitsu Mukaida,Hal Tasaki

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10955-024-03246-3

2024-02-25

Abstract:We establish relations between different characterizations of order in spin glass models. We first prove that the broadening of the replica overlap distribution indicated by a nonzero standard deviation of the replica overlap $R^{1,2}$ implies the non-differentiability of the two-replica free energy with respect to the replica coupling parameter $\lambda$. In $\mathbb Z_2$ invariant models such as the standard Edwards-Anderson model, the non-differentiability is equivalent to the spin glass order characterized by a nonzero Edwards-Anderson order parameter. This generalization of Griffiths' theorem is proved for any short-range spin glass models with classical bounded spins. We also prove that the non-differentiability of the two-replica free energy mentioned above implies replica symmetry breaking in the literal sense, i.e., a spontaneous breakdown of the permutation symmetry in the model with three replicas. This is a general result that applies to a large class of random spin models, including long-range models such as the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model and the random energy model.

Mathematical Physics,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Mechanics,Probability

Fluctuations in a Spin Glass model with 1RSB

On one-step replica symmetry breaking in the Edwards-Anderson spin glass model

Replica Symmetry Breaking in Critical Phenomena in Long-Range Disordered Ferromagnets

Replica Symmetry Broken States of some Glass Models

Simultaneous replica-symmetry breaking for vector spin glasses

Replica-symmetry breaking transitions in the large deviations of the ground-state of a spherical spin-glass

Replica Symmetry Breaking and the Renormalization Group Theory of the Weakly Disordered Ferromagnet

Exactly solvable quantum spin-glass model with 1RSB-fullRSB transition

Quantum Fluctuations of a Nearly Critical Heisenberg Spin Glass

Spin glass models with ferromagnetically biased couplings on the Bethe lattice: analytic solutions and numerical simulations

Replica symmetry breaking in spin glasses in the replica-free Keldysh formalism

Equilibrium dynamics of infinite-range quantum spin glasses in a field

Universal fragility of spin-glass ground-states under single bond changes

Hypergraph Counting and Mixed $p$-Spin Glass Models under Replica Symmetry

Comment on ``Spherical 2 + p spin-glass model: An analytically solvable model with a glass-to-glass transition''

Multifractality in spin glasses

Stochastic equations and dynamics beyond mean-field theory

Small field chaos in spin glasses: universal predictions from the ultrametric tree and comparison with numerical simulations

Slow Nonthermalizing Dynamics in a Quantum Spin Glass

Griffiths-type theorems for short-range spin glass models