Indistinguishable particles and hidden variables

Adonai S. Sant'Anna,Decio Krause

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02764019

1996-07-19

Abstract:An axiomatics for indistinguishability of elementary particles in terms of hidden variables is presented in a manner which depart from the standard approaches usually given to hidden variables. Quantum distribution functions are also discussed and some related lines of work are suggested.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Hidden variable theory for non-relativistic QED: the critical role of selection rules

H. Ishikawa

2024-10-24

Abstract:Quantum theory, despite its remarkable success, struggles to represent certain experimental data, particularly those involving integer functions and deterministic relations between quantum jumps. We address this limitation by proposing a hidden variable theory compatible with non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics (QED). Our approach introduces logical variables to describe propositions about the occupation of stationary states, based on three key assumptions: (i) the probabilities of propositions are predictable by quantum theory, (ii) the truth values of propositions conform to Boolean logic, and (iii) propositions satisfy a novel selection rule: ${\rm{Tr}}[\hat{K}(t)\hat{\rho}\hat{K}^{\dagger}(t)]={\rm{Tr}}[({\mathcal{P}}\hat{K}(t)) \hat{\rho}({\mathcal{P}}\hat{K}(t))^{\dagger}]$. Here, $\hat{K}(t)$ is the product of projection operators for the given propositions, and ${\mathcal{P}}\hat{K}(t)$ denotes $\hat{K}(t)$ rearranged arbitrarily. This selection rule extends the consistency condition in the Consistent Histories approach, relaxing constraints imposed by no-go theorems on logical variable representation, joint probability existence, and measurement contextuality. Consequently, our theory successfully describes the essential properties of individual trials, including the discreteness of quantum jumps, the continuity of classical trajectories, and deterministic relations between entangled subsystems. It achieves this without conflicting with quantum equations of motion, canonical commutation relations, or the operator ordering in quantum coherence functions. The direct description of individual trials made possible by this approach sheds new light on the discrete nature of quantum phenomena and the essence of reality.

Quantum Physics
Ontological indistinguishability as a central tenet of quantum theory

J A de Barros,F Holik

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2022.0100

2023-09-18

Abstract:Quantum indistinguishability directly relates to the philosophical debate on the notions of identity and individuality. They are crucial for our understanding of multipartite quantum systems. Furthermore, the correct interpretation of this feature of quantum theory has implications that transcend fundamental science and philosophy, given that quantum indistinguishability is a resource in quantum information theory. Most of the conceptual analysis of quantum indistinguishability is restricted to studying the permutational invariance of quantum states, the concomitant quantum statistics and their entanglement. Here, we analyse the role of indistinguishability and non-individuality in other areas of quantum theory. We start by analysing how a very peculiar use of indistinguishability underlies Feynman's rules for summing amplitudes in interference phenomena. Next, we study how quantum indistinguishability is underestimated in several topics of debate in the quantum physics literature, such as the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen argument, Bell's inequalities and the Bell-Kochen-Specker theorem. Finally, we argue that an ontology of truly indistinguishable entities can serve as a basis for a quantum ontology that can give interesting answers to the interpretational problems of quantum mechanics. We claim that, in addition to superposition, contextuality and entanglement, indistinguishability (understood in a robust ontological sense) is one of the central features of quantum physics. This article is part of the theme issue 'Identity, individuality and indistinguishability in physics and mathematics'.
Identical Particles in Quantum Mechanics

Andrea Lubberdink

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0910.4642

2010-01-09

Abstract:If, in a system of identical particles, the one particle state is defined by the partial trace to one of the component spaces of the total Hilbert space, then all one particle states are identical. The particles are indistinguishable. This is often thought to be a typical quantum mechanical phenomenon. I will show however that an analogous procedure to define particle states exists in classical mechanics, which results in classical indistinguishable identical particles. From this analogy it follows that the indistinguishability of identical particles depends on how we define particle states. It is not an inevitable result of the symmetry postulate. Indeed, if particles are defined by partial traces, consistent use of the symmetry postulate leads to the conclusion that all identical particles in the universe are indistinguishable, so that particles can never be pointed at, not even in the classical limit. This does not correspond to the way the term particle is actually used in practice. I will argue that a particle should be defined in such a way that in the classical limit the quantum particle state becomes the state of a classical particle. This will lead us to a definition of particles which is in line with the way the term particle is actually used by physicists.

General Physics,Quantum Physics
Indistinguishability in general probabilistic theories

John H. Selby,Victoria J. Wright,Máté Farkas,Marcin Karczewski,Ana Belén Sainz

2024-12-30

Abstract:The existence of indistinguishable quantum particles provides an explanation for various physical phenomena we observe in nature. We lay out a path for the study of indistinguishable particles in general probabilistic theories (GPTs) via two frameworks: the traditional GPT framework and the diagrammatic framework of process theories. In the first approach we define different types of indistinguishable particle by the orbits of symmetric states under transformations. In the diagrammatic approach, we find a decomposition of the symmetrised state space using two key constructions from category theory: the biproduct completion and the Karoubi envelope. In both cases for pairs of indistinguishable particles in quantum theory we recover bosons and fermions.

Quantum Physics
A hidden variables model for non-relativistic quantum mechanics in terms of probabilities of particle paths

Emilio Santos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1603.02215

2016-05-02

Abstract:It is proved that in non-relativistic quantum mechanics (without spin) the transition probability may be described in terms of particle paths, every path having a (positive) probability. This leads to a stochastic hidden variables theory providing an intuitive picture of particle motion. The change of velocity at every time has a probability that depends on the potential over a large region, at a difference with the local action of classical dynamics. Thus the hidden variables theory is non-local like Bohm's, but not deterministic.

Quantum Physics
A Suggested Interpretation of the Quantum Theory in Terms of "Hidden" Variables. II

David Bohm

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrev.85.180

1952-01-15

Physical Review

Abstract:In this paper, we shall show how the theory of measurements is to be understood from the point of view of a physical interpretation of the quantum theory in terms of "hidden" variables, developed in a previous paper. We find that in principle, these "hidden" variables determine the precise results of each individual measurement process. In practice, however, in measurements that we now know how to carry out, the observing apparatus disturbs the observed system in an unpredictable and uncontrollable way, so that the uncertainty principle is obtained as a practical limitation on the possible precision of measurements. This limitation is not, however, inherent in the conceptual structure of our interpretation. We shall see, for example, that simultaneous measurements of position and momentum having unlimited precision would in principle be possible if, as suggested in the previous paper, the mathematical formulation of the quantum theory needs to be modified at very short distances in certain ways that are consistent with our interpretation but not with the usual interpretation. We give a simple explanation of the origin of quantum-mechanical correlations of distant objects in the hypothetical experiment of Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen, which was suggested by these authors as a criticism of the usual interpretation. Finally, we show that von Neumann's proof that quantum theory is not consistent with hidden variables does not apply to our interpretation, because the hidden variables contemplated here depend both on the state of the measuring apparatus and the observed system and therefore go beyond certain of von Neumann's assumptions. In two appendixes, we treat the problem of the electromagnetic field in our interpretation and answer certain additional objections which have arisen in the attempt to give a precise description for an individual system at the quantum level.

English Else
Particle Exchange in Post-Quantum Theories

Oscar C. O. Dahlsten,Andrew J. P. Garner,Jayne Thompson,Mile Gu,Vlatko Vedral

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arxiv.1307.2529

2013-01-01

Abstract:In quantum theory, particles in three spatial dimensions come in two different types: bosons or fermions, which exhibit sharply contrasting behaviours due to their different exchange statistics. Could more general forms of probabilistic theories admit more exotic types of particles? Here, we propose a thought experiment to identify more exotic particles in general post-quantum theories. We consider how in quantum theory the phase introduced by swapping indistinguishable particles can be measured. We generalise this to post-quantum scenarios whilst imposing indistinguishability and locality principles. We show that our ability to witness exotic particle exchange statistics depends on which symmetries are admitted within a theory. These exotic particles can manifest unusual behaviour, such as non-abelianicity even in topologically simple three-dimensional space.
Quantum Logical Structures For Identical Particles

Federico Holik,Decio Krause,Ignacio Gómez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1305.5242

2013-05-23

Abstract:In this work we discuss logical structures related to indistinguishable particles. Most of the framework used to develop these structures was presented in [17, 28] and in [20, 14, 15, 16]. We use these structures and constructions to discuss possible ontologies for identical parti-cles. In other words, we use these structures in order to characterize the logical structure of quantum systems for the case of indistinguishable particles, and draw possible philosoph-ical implications. We also review some proposals available in the literature which may be considered within the framework of the quantum logical tradition regarding the problem of indistinguishability. Besides these discussions and constructions, we advance novel technical results, namely, a lattice theoretical structure for identical particles for the finite dimensional case. This kind of approach was not present in the scarcely literature of quantum logic and indistinguishable particles.

Quantum Physics
The Logic of Identity: Distinguishability and Indistinguishability in Classical and Quantum Physics

Dennis Dieks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-014-9814-0

2014-05-14

Abstract:The suggestion that particles of the same kind may be indistinguishable in a fundamental sense, even so that challenges to traditional notions of individuality and identity may arise, has first come up in the context of classical statistical mechanics. In particular, the Gibbs paradox has sometimes been interpreted as a sign of the untenability of the classical concept of a particle and as a premonition that quantum theory is needed. This idea of a quantum connection stubbornly persists in the literature, even though it has also been criticized frequently. Here we shall argue that although this criticism is justified, the proposed alternative solutions have often been wrong and have not put the paradox in its right perspective. In fact, the Gibbs paradox is unrelated to fundamental issues of particle identity; only distinguishability in a pragmatic sense plays a role (in this we develop ideas of van Kampen [10]), and in principle the paradox always is there as long as the concept of a particle applies at all. In line with this we show that the paradox survives even in quantum mechanics, in spite of the quantum mechanical (anti-)symmetrization postulates.

Quantum Physics
Hidden Variables for Pauli Measurements

Leon Bankston

2023-11-15

Abstract:The Pauli measurements (the measurements that can be performed with Clifford operators followed by measurement in the computational basis) are a fundamental object in quantum information. It is well-known that there is no assignment of outcomes to all Pauli measurements that is both complete and consistent. We define two classes of hidden variable assignments based on relaxing either condition. Partial hidden variable assignments retain the consistency condition, but forfeit completeness. Contextual hidden variable assignments retain completeness but forfeit consistency. We use techniques from spectral graph theory to characterize the incompleteness and inconsistency of the respective hidden variable assignments. As an application, we interpret our incompleteness result as a statement of contextuality and our inconsistency result as a statement of nonlocality. Our results show that we can obtain large amounts of contextuality and nonlocality using Clifford gates and measurements.

Quantum Physics
On identity, indiscernibility and (non-)individuality in the quantum domain

Décio Krause

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2022.0096

2023-09-18

Abstract:The topics of identity, individuality and indiscernibility had already entered the domain of the philosophy of physics, mainly in what respects the philosophy of quantum theories. In this paper, I present the main ideas of an underlying metaphysics that considers the basic entities of quantum physics as non-individuals, that is, as entities to which the standard theory of identity of classical logic and standard mathematics (set theory) does not apply. Two things must be emphasized: the first is that we pursue Erwin Schrödinger's ideas that the notion of identity (or sameness) does not apply to quantum things; the second is to follow Heinz Post's claim that the non-individuality of quantum entities 'must be introduced right at the start' and not by taking individuals and making them pretend to be non-individuals 'by hand', say by confining them to non-rigid structures. Thus, this paper should be regarded as an attempt to justify the metaphysics of non-individuals and the logical systems that cope with them, although these systems are here only referred to. We also answer some criticisms that have been directed to such a view. The paper is directed to an audience of both physicists interested in foundations and philosophers of physics. This article is part of the theme issue 'Identity, individuality and indistinguishability in physics and mathematics'.
Solipsistic hidden variables

H. Nikolic

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1112.2034

2013-01-07

Abstract:We argue that it is logically possible to have a sort of both reality and locality in quantum mechanics. To demonstrate this, we construct a new quantitative model of hidden variables (HV's), dubbed solipsistic HV's, that interpolates between the orthodox no-HV interpretation and nonlocal Bohmian interpretation. In this model, the deterministic point-particle trajectories are associated only with the essential degrees of freedom of the observer, and not with the observed objects. In contrast with Bohmian HV's, nonlocality in solipsistic HV's can be substantially reduced down to microscopic distances inside the observer. Even if such HV's may look philosophically unappealing to many, the mere fact that they are logically possible deserves attention.

Quantum Physics,High Energy Physics - Theory,History and Philosophy of Physics
Discovery of Quantum Hidden Variable

Huai-yang Cui

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0711.1247

2016-09-27

Abstract:The first clue, in the theory of relativity, the 4-vector force acting on a particle is orthogonal to the 4-vector velocity of the particle, this orthogonality means that there is some difference between the orthogonality and the usual statement: the Coulomb's force (or gravitational force) acts along the line joining a couple of particles (in usual 3D space), so the direction of 4-vector Coulomb's force is carefully investigated, it is found that Maxwell's equations can be derived from classical Coulomb's force and the orthogonality. The second clue, a 4-vector force has 4 components, because of the orthogonality of 4-vector force and 4-vector velocity, the number of independent components of the 4-vector force reduces to 3, however we prove that 4-vector Coulomb's force can merely provide 2 independent components, this situation means that there is an undefined component accompanying the 4-vector Coulomb's force, hinting that this missing undefined component is a hidden variable. The third clue, the best way to study the hidden variable is to establish a new concept: Z-space, in which the undefined component of 4-vector Coulomb's force can be clearly defined as the hidden variable for the quantum mechanics. At the last, the undefined component is regarded as a fluctuating source that contributes to Lorentz force, so that the quantum wave equation can be derived out in the ensemble space of particle motion from the relativistic Newton's second law.

General Physics
Non-local Hidden Variable Theories and Bell's Inequality

Jeffrey Bub,Vandana Shiva

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/psaprocbienmeetp.1978.1.192624

1978-01-01

Abstract:The conceptually puzzling features of quantum mechanics as a statistical theory all have their source in the impossibility of relating the probability assignments defined by the quantum state to distributions over determinate values of the physical magnitudes. While some interpretations of quantum mechanics, as well as “hidden variable” modifications of the theory, have proposed several constructions for assigning values to magnitudes (beyond the value assignments defined by the quantum state alone), a variety of theorems exist which impose severe restrictions on such theoretical constructions. This note will deal with Bell's proof (in [2]), that any hidden variable theory satisfying a physically reasonable locality condition is characterized by an inequality which is inconsistent with the quantum statistics. Bell's result has initiated a series of experiments designed to refute the entire class of local hidden variable theories. We show that Bell's inequality actually characterizes a feature of hidden variable theories which is much weaker than locality in the sense considered physically motivated.
Postselective quantum interference of distinguishable particles

Peter S. Turner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1608.05720

2016-08-20

Abstract:We show that it is possible for completely distinguishable particles to interfere postselectively without operating on, or indeed having any knowledge of, the distinguishing degree of freedom. In particular, we find a family of three-mode spatial interferometers that, upon inputting, say, a red photon in port 1 and a green photon in port 2, produce a state such that when vacuum is detected at one output, the two photons in the other two outputs will pass a HOM test, despite their frequency degree of freedom remaining untouched. In doing so we develop a general approach to distinguishability based on the Schmidt decomposition between particles' "System" and "Label" degrees of freedom, corresponding to what has been called unitary-unitary duality in many-body physics. This also gives insight into the relationship between the first and second quantized pictures, which is useful in bringing other quantum information concepts across from the former to the latter.

Quantum Physics
The Case of the Disappearing (and Re-Appearing) Particle

Yakir Aharonov,Eliahu Cohen,Ariel Landau,Avshalom C Elitzur

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-00274-w

2017-04-03

Abstract:A novel prediction is derived by the Two-State-Vector-Formalism (TSVF) for a particle superposed over three boxes. Under appropriate pre- and post-selections, and with tunneling enabled between two of the boxes, it is possible to derive not only one, but three predictions for three different times within the intermediate interval. These predictions are moreover contradictory. The particle (when looked for using a projective measurement) seems to disappear from the first box where it would have been previously found with certainty, appearing instead within the third box, to which no tunneling is possible, and later re-appearing within the second. It turns out that local measurement (i.e. opening one of the boxes) fails to indicate the particle's presence, but subtler measurements performed on the two boxes together reveal the particle's nonlocal modular momentum spatially separated from its mass. Another advance of this setting is that, unlike other predictions of the TSVF that rely on weak and/or counterfactual measurements, the present one uses actual projective measurements. This outcome is then corroborated by adding weak measurements and the Aharonov-Bohm effect. The results strengthen the recently suggested time-symmetric Heisenberg ontology based on nonlocal deterministic operators. They can be also tested using the newly developed quantum router.
A Grasp of Identity

Pere Seglar,Enric Pérez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0143-0807/36/3/035016

2014-11-06

Abstract:We revisit the treatment of identical particles in quantum mechanics. Two kinds of solutions of Schrödinger equation are found and analyzed. First, the known symmetrized and antisymmetrized eigenfunctions. We examine how the very concept of particle is blurred whithin this approach. Second, we propose another kind of solution with no symmetries that we identify with Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics. In it, particles do preserve their individuality, as they are provided with individual energy and momenta. However, these properties cannot be univocally ascribed; moreover, particles do not possess distinctive positions. Finally, we explore how these results affect the calculation of canonical partition function, and we show that extensivity arises as a consequence of identity.

Quantum Physics
Quantum determinism and completeness restored by indistinguishability and long-time particle detection

Patrick Navez,Henni Ouerdane

2024-09-23

Abstract:We argue that measurement data in quantum physics can be rigorously interpreted only as a result of a statistical, macroscopic process, taking into account the indistinguishable character of identical particles. Quantum determinism is in principle possible on the condition that a fully-fledged quantum model is used to describe the measurement device in interaction with the studied object as one system. In contrast, any approach that relies on Born's rule discriminates the dynamics of a quantum system from that of the detector with which it interacts during measurement. In this work, we critically analyze the validity of this measurement postulate applied to single-event signals. In fact, the concept of ``individual'' particle becomes inadequate once both indistinguishability and a scattering approach allowing an unlimited interaction time for an effective detection, are considered as they should be, hence preventing the separability of two successive measurement events. In this context, measurement data should therefore be understood only as a result of statistics over many events. Accounting for the intrinsic noise of the sources and the detectors, we also show with the illustrative cases of the Schrödinger cat and the Bell experiment that once the Born rule is abandoned on the level of a single particle, realism, locality and causality are restored. We conclude that indiscernibility and long-time detection process make quantum physics not fundamentally probabilistic.

General Physics,Quantum Physics
Ephemeral properties and the illusion of microscopic particles

Massimiliano Sassoli de Bianchi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10699-011-9227-x

2011-02-21

Abstract:Founding our analysis on the Geneva-Brussels approach to quantum mechanics, we use conventional macroscopic objects as guiding examples to clarify the content of two important results of the beginning of twentieth century: Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen's reality criterion and Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. We then use them in combination to show that our widespread belief in the existence of microscopic particles is only the result of a cognitive illusion, as microscopic particles are not particles, but are instead the ephemeral spatial and local manifestations of non-spatial and non-local entities.

General Physics,Quantum Physics
The Hidden Ontological Variable in Quantum Harmonic Oscillators

Gerard t Hooft

2024-10-29

Abstract:The standard quantum mechanical harmonic oscillator has an exact, dual relationship with a completely classical system: a classical particle running along a circle. Duality here means that there is a one-to-one relation between all observables in one model, and the observables of the other model. Thus the duality we find, appears to be in conflict with the usual assertion that classical theories can never reproduce quantum effects as observed in many quantum models. We suggest that there must be more of such relationships, but we study only this one as a prototype. It reveals how classical "hidden variables" may work. The classical states can form the basis of Hilbert space that can be adopted in describing the quantum model. Wave functions in the quantum system generate probability distributions in the classical one. One finds that, where the classical system always obeys the rule "probability in = probability out", the same probabilities are quantum probabilities in the quantum system. It is shown how the quantum x and p operators in a quantum oscillator can be given a classical meaning. It is explained how an apparent clash with quantum logic can be explained away.

Quantum Physics

Indistinguishable particles and hidden variables

Hidden variable theory for non-relativistic QED: the critical role of selection rules

Ontological indistinguishability as a central tenet of quantum theory

Identical Particles in Quantum Mechanics

Indistinguishability in general probabilistic theories

A hidden variables model for non-relativistic quantum mechanics in terms of probabilities of particle paths

A Suggested Interpretation of the Quantum Theory in Terms of "Hidden" Variables. II

Particle Exchange in Post-Quantum Theories

Quantum Logical Structures For Identical Particles

The Logic of Identity: Distinguishability and Indistinguishability in Classical and Quantum Physics

Hidden Variables for Pauli Measurements

On identity, indiscernibility and (non-)individuality in the quantum domain

Solipsistic hidden variables

Discovery of Quantum Hidden Variable

Non-local Hidden Variable Theories and Bell's Inequality

Postselective quantum interference of distinguishable particles

The Case of the Disappearing (and Re-Appearing) Particle

A Grasp of Identity

Quantum determinism and completeness restored by indistinguishability and long-time particle detection

Ephemeral properties and the illusion of microscopic particles

The Hidden Ontological Variable in Quantum Harmonic Oscillators