Hungry or Not: How Stellar-Mass Black Holes Grow (or Don’t) in Dark Matter Mini-Haloes at High-Resolution

Simone T Gordon,Britton D Smith,Sadegh Khochfar,John Anthony Regan,Simone Gordon,Britton Smith,John Regan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stae566

IF: 4.8

2024-02-22

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

Abstract:Abstract We compare the performance of the popular Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton (BHL) accretion scheme with a simple mass-flux scheme applied to stellar-mass black holes (BHs) across six levels of increasing spatial resolution. Simulating the formation of black holes within cosmological mini-haloes at z ∼ 20, we investigate scenarios both with and without supernova events, which result in BHs of initial mass 10.8 M⊙ and 270 M⊙ respectively. Our explicit focus on the stellar-mass range pushes the maximum resolution down to sub-10−3 pc regimes, where more complicated gas dynamics are resolved. We observe efficient growth and rotationally supported, ∼10−1 pc-scale discs around all 270 M⊙ BHs independent of resolution and accretion scheme, though clumps, bars, and spiral arm structures impact stability at high resolution. We analyse the effect of these instabilities on the accretion cycle. In contrast, all bar one of the 10.8 M⊙ BHs fail to attract a disc and experience modest growth, even when characteristic scales of accretion and dynamical friction are reasonably resolved. While the two accretion schemes somewhat converge in mass growth for the 270 M⊙ case over 1 Myr, the greater degree of gas fragmentation induces more randomness in the evolution of the 10.8 M⊙ BHs. We conclude that early universe black holes of MBH ∼ 101 M⊙ struggle to grow even in gas-rich environments without feedback in comparison to seeds of MBH ∼ 102 M⊙, and the latter exhibit convergent growth histories across accretion schemes below a resolution of dx = 1 × 10−3pc.

astronomy & astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how (or whether) stellar - mass black holes grow in dark matter mini - halos at high resolution. Specifically, the author compares the performance of two accretion schemes - the popular Bondi - Hoyle - Lyttleton (BHL) accretion scheme and the simple mass - flow scheme - at different spatial resolutions. The focus of the study is to simulate stellar - mass black holes formed at redshift \(z\sim20\), especially black holes with initial masses of \(10.8 \, M_\odot\) and \(270 \, M_\odot\) formed before and after supernova events respectively. Through these simulations, the author hopes to explore the influence of different accretion schemes and resolutions on black hole growth, especially whether these black holes can grow effectively in gas - rich environments.

### Main research questions:
1. **Performance comparison of accretion schemes**: Compare the performance of the BHL accretion scheme and the simple mass - flow scheme at different resolutions.
2. **Influence of resolution**: Explore the influence of different resolutions on the black hole accretion process, especially on the sub - \(10^{-3}\) parsec scale.
3. **Black hole growth mechanism**: Analyze the growth of black holes with initial masses of \(10.8 \, M_\odot\) and \(270 \, M_\odot\) under different conditions.
4. **Role of gas dynamics and instability**: Study the influence of instabilities in gas dynamics (such as spiral arm structures, bar - like structures, etc.) on the accretion cycle.

### Formula presentation:
- **BHL accretion rate**:
\[
\dot{M}_{\text{BHL}}=\alpha\frac{4\pi G^{2}M_\bullet^{2}\rho_\infty}{(c_s^{2}+v_\infty^{2})^{3/2}}
\]
where \(\alpha\) is a dimensionless factor, \(G\) is the gravitational constant, \(M_\bullet\) is the mass of the accretor, \(\rho_\infty\) is the gas density at infinity, \(c_s\) is the speed of sound at infinity, and \(v_\infty\) is the velocity of the gas relative to the accretor.

- **Bondi radius**:
\[
R_{\text{Bondi}}=\frac{2GM_\bullet}{c_s^{2}}
\]
when \(c_s^{2}>v_\infty^{2}\).

- **Hoyle - Lyttleton radius**:
\[
R_{\text{HL}}=\frac{2GM_\bullet}{v_\infty^{2}}
\]
when \(c_s^{2}<v_\infty^{2}\).

### Research background:
The existence of super - massive black holes (SMBHs) in the early universe challenges traditional black hole evolution theories. These huge black holes may emerge through different formation channels, such as direct - collapse black holes, star - cluster mergers, and primordial black holes, etc. To understand the origin of these black holes, numerical simulations become important tools. However, due to limitations in computational resources, these simulations usually need to use sub - grid models to approximate small - scale processes, such as accretion and feedback.

### Research method:
The author uses the ENZO code for simulations. This code is a cosmology simulation code based on adaptive mesh refinement (AMR). By adjusting the resolution and accretion scheme, the author studies in detail the growth process of stellar - mass black holes in dark matter mini - halos.

### Conclusions:
- Black holes with an initial mass of \(270 \, M_\odot\) can form rotation - supported disks at all resolutions and accretion schemes and show effective growth.
- Black holes with an initial mass of \(10.8 \, M_\odot\) have difficulty attracting disks and have limited growth.
- High - resolution simulations show that instabilities in gas dynamics have a significant impact on the accretion cycle.
- At high resolution, the two accretion schemes show convergence in the growth history of \(270 \, M_\odot\) black holes, while...