Abstract:Consent permeates both our law and our lives — especially in the digital context. Consent is the foundation of the relationships we have with search engines, social networks, commercial web sites, and any one of the dozens of other digitally mediated businesses we interact with regularly. We are frequently asked to consent to terms of service, privacy notices, the use of cookies, and so many other commercial practices. Consent is important, but it’s possible to have too much of a good thing. As a number of scholars have documented, while consent models permeate the digital consumer landscape, the practical conditions of these agreements fall far short of the gold standard of knowing and voluntary consent. Yet as scholars, advocates, and consumers, we lack a common vocabulary for talking about the different ways in which digital consents can be flawed. This article offers four contributions to improve our understanding of consent in the digital world. First, we offer a conceptual vocabulary of “the pathologies of consent” — a framework for talking about different kinds of defects that consent models can suffer, such as unwitting consent, coerced consent, and incapacitated consent. Second, we offer three conditions for when consent will be most valid in the digital context: when choice is infrequent, when the potential harms resulting from that choice are vivid and easy to imagine, and where we have the correct incentives choose consciously and seriously. The further we fall from these conditions, the more a particular consent will be pathological and thus suspect. Third, we argue that out theory of consent pathologies sheds light on the so-called “privacy paradox” — the notion that there is a gap between what consumers say about wanting privacy and what they actually do in practice. Understanding the “privacy paradox” in terms of consent pathologies shows how consumers are not hypocrites who say one thing but do another. On the contrary, the pathologies of consent reveal how consumers can be nudged and manipulated by powerful companies against their actual interests, and that this process is easier when consumer protection law falls far from the gold standard. In light of these findings, we offer a fourth contribution — the theory of consumer trust we have suggested in prior work and which we further elaborate here as an alternative to our over-reliance on consent and its many pathologies.

A broader view of sexual consent: Prerequisites that make consent more meaningful.

Consent as Cross-Cultural Communication: Navigating Consent in a Multicultural World

Sexual consent: Exploring the perceptions of heterosexual and non-heterosexual men

Contributions From Psychology to Effectively Use, and Achieving Sexual Consent

Sexual Consent Norms in a Sexually Diverse Sample

Sexual Incentive Motivation and Sexual Behavior: The Role of Consent

Sexual Precedent’s Effect on Sexual Consent Communication

Yes, No, Maybe So: The Effects of Relationship Status on Perceptions of Inferred Consent

Exploring the Influence of Romantic Relationship Communication on Adolescents' Self-Efficacy to Ask for Sexual Consent

Sexism, risk perception, and beliefs about sexual consent

Perceived Sex Education and Its Association with Consent Attitudes, Intentions, and Communication

College Students' Sexual Consent Communication And Perceptions of Sexual Double Standards: A Qualitative Investigation

"I Don't Care if it Would Kill the Mood. I'm Going to Use My Words": Perceptions and Use of Explicit Verbal Sexual Consent in Neurodiverse Undergraduate Students

Sex and consent in contemporary youth sexual culture: the ‘ideals’ and the ‘realities’

Adults' Understandings and Experiences of the Capacity to Consent to Substance-Involved Sexual Activity

When “Yes Means Yes”: Short-Term Effects of an Educational Video on Acceptance of Ideals Related to Affirmative Sexual Consent Among Young Adults

Intimate Partner Sexual Violence in Emerging Adulthood: Exploring Sexual Consent Attitudes as a Target for Sexual Coercion Prevention

"I Wouldn't Believe Her at First"-A Qualitative Study of Young People's Sexual Consent Perceptions and Negotiation in Nairobi Informal Settlements

The Role of Consent in the Context of BDSM

The Pathologies of Digital Consent

Do Individuals Interpret Sexting as an Indicator of Sexual Intent and Sexual Consent?