Socialization practices of parents, teachers, and peers in Israel: The kibbutz versus the city

Edward C Devereux, Ron Shouval, Urie Bronfenbrenner, Robert R Rodgers, Sophie Kav-Venaki, Elizabeth Kiely, Esther Karson
1974-06-01
Abstract:About 600 Israeli preadolescents, half from 29 kibbutzim and half from 9 classrooms in the city of Tel Aviv, were asked to describe the frequency of certain socializing behaviors of their mothers, fathers, teachers, peers, and, in the kibbutz, care givers as well. Kibbutz and city parents were seen as equally supportive, but the latter were much more salient as disciplinarians. Even more striking was the finding that the role of the kibbutz teacher more closely resembled that of the parent, particularly as a provider of emotional security. Contrary to expectations, neither the peer group nor the metapelet emerged as supportive figures, but both were salient as agents of discipline and disapproval. The implications of these patterns for personality development are discussed.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?