Abstract:Axisymmetric magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) can be invoked for describing astrophysical magnetized flows and formulated to model stellar magnetospheres including main-sequence stars (e.g. the Sun), compact stellar objects [e.g. magnetic white dwarfs (MWDs), radio pulsars, anomalous X-ray pulsars, magnetars, isolated neutron stars, etc.] and planets as a major step forward towards a full three-dimensional model construction. Using powerful and reliable numerical solvers based on two distinct finite-difference method and finite-element method schemes of algorithm, we examine axisymmetric steady-state or stationary MHD models in Throumoulopoulos & Tasso, finding that their separable semi-analytic non-linear solutions are actually not unique given their specific selection of several free functionals and chosen boundary conditions. Similar situations of multiple non-linear solutions with the same boundary conditions actually also happen to force-free magnetic field models of Low & Lou. The multiplicity of non-linear steady MHD solutions gives rise to differences in the total energies contained in the magnetic fields and flow velocity fields as well as in the asymptotic behaviours approaching infinity, which may in turn explain why numerical solvers tend to converge to a non-linear solution with a lower energy than the corresponding separable semi-analytic one. By properly adjusting model parameters, we invoke semi-analytic and numerical solutions to describe different kinds of scenarios, including nearly parallel case and the situation in which the misalignment between the plasma flow and magnetic field is considerable. We propose that these MHD models are capable of describing the magnetospheres of MWDs as examples of applications with moderate conditions (including magnetic field) where the typical values of several important parameters are consistent with observations. Physical parameters can also be estimated based on such MHD models directly. We discuss the challenges of developing numerical extrapolation MHD codes in view of the non-linear degeneracy.

On energy and magnetic helicity equality in the electron magnetohydrodynamic equations

A note on energy and cross‐helicity conservation in the ideal magnetohydrodynamic equations

On the conservation of helicity by weak solutions of the 3D Euler and inviscid MHD equations

Energy and cross-helicity conservation for the three-dimensional ideal MHD equations in bounded domain

Numerical method for the magnetic vector potential in incompressible magnetohydrodynamic flows and the conservation properties of magnetic helicity

Four-thirds law of energy and magnetic helicity in electron and Hall magnetohydrodynamic fluids

On the energy and helicity conservation of the incompressible Euler equations

Steady-state Axisymmetric Nonlinear Magnetohydrodynamic Solutions with Various Boundary Conditions

Energy balance of the very weak solution in incompressible non-resistive MHD equations

On the energy method for the global solutions to the three dimensional incompressible non-resistive MHD near equilibrium

Four-fifths laws in electron and Hall magnetohydrodynamic fluids: Energy, Magnetic helicity and Generalized helicity

Sharp Non-Uniqueness of Weak Solutions to 3D Magnetohydrodynamic Equations: Beyond the Lions Exponent

Well-posedness, magnetic helicity conservation, inviscid limit and asymptotic stability for the generalized Navier-Stokes-Maxwell equations with the Hall effect

Remarks on uniqueness and energy conservation for electron-MHD system

Energy equality of the weak solutions to the non-Newtonian fluids equations

Three dimensional stationary solutions of the Electron MHD equations

Magnetic Helicity Estimations in Models and Observations of the Solar Magnetic Field. Part I: Finite Volume Methods

Energy equality of weak solutions of the Navier–Stokes–Fourier equations allowing vacuum

Nonnegative Magnetoresistance in Hydrodynamic Regime of Electron Fluid Transport in Two-Dimensional Materials

Residual Energy and Broken Symmetry in Reduced Magnetohydrodynamics

Spatial Scales and Locality of Magnetic Helicity: Part 1