When Agency Fails: An Analysis of the Association Between Hospital Agency Staffing and Quality Outcomes
Bradley Beauvais,Rohit Pradhan,Zo Ramamonjiarivelo,Michael Mileski,Ramalingam Shanmugam
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/rmhp.s459840
2024-05-24
Risk Management and Healthcare Policy
Abstract:Bradley Beauvais, Rohit Pradhan, Zo Ramamonjiarivelo, Michael Mileski, Ramalingam Shanmugam School of Health Administration, Texas State University, San Marcos, TX, USA Correspondence: Rohit Pradhan, Email Introduction: Staffing is critical to hospital quality, but recent years have seen hospitals grappling with severe shortages, forcing them to rely on contract or agency staff for urgent patient care needs. This shift in staffing mix has raised questions about its impact on quality. Consequently, this study investigated whether the increased use of agency staff has affected healthcare quality in hospitals. Given the limited recent research on this topic, practitioners remain uncertain about the effectiveness of their staffing strategies and their potential impact on quality. Methods: Drawing from agency theory, data were obtained from Definitive Healthcare which consolidates information from numerous public access databases pertaining to hospitals such as the American Hospital Association Annual Survey (hospital profile) and the Hospital Value-Based Purchasing Program (quality data). We conducted a cross-sectional study using a multivariable linear regression model (2021– 2022) with appropriate organizational and market- level control variables. Quality was measured across eight variables while the independent variable of interest was agency labor cost ratio operationalized as the percentage of net patient revenue consumed by agency labor expense. Results: Our results suggested that the employment of agency staff was significantly and negatively associated with six of eight quality measures tested, including the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) star rating, Hospital Compare rating, the hospital Total Performance Score (TPS), and three of the four sub-domains that comprise the TPS: clinical domain score, person and community engagement domain score, and the efficiency and cost reduction score. Discussion: Our results indicated that the increased use of agency labor may have a significant negative influence on quality outcomes at the hospital level. Our findings support the premise that interventions that promote full-time staffing may be more supportive of the quality of care delivered as well as patients' perceptions of care. Keywords: hospital, quality, patient safety, contract staffing, agency staffing Healthcare professionals are critical to the performance of healthcare organizations including hospitals. 1 Unfortunately, in recent years, hospitals have been confronted with a severe staffing shortage, a crisis further intensified by the unprecedented challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic. Alarmingly, one in five healthcare professionals chose to resign from their positions amid the pandemic. 2 The staffing deficit is particularly acute for nurses with the United States (US) healthcare system grappling with a projected shortfall of 275,000 registered nurses (RNs) by 2030. 3,4 Multiple factors have contributed to this complex issue including high turnover rates fueled by demanding work environments, limited career advancement opportunities, and inadequate workplace support. 5 Hospitals face competition for hourly employees from non-healthcare organizations, which may have greater wage flexibility and the capacity to transfer increased costs to consumers. 6 To address staffing challenges, healthcare organizations often rely on contract or agency staff, temporary workers employed by third-party agencies, who fill in staffing gaps across various facilities. 7 While seemingly plugging staffing gaps, the dependence on agency staff can have a negative impact on both hospital financial stability as well as its ability to provide high-quality care. 2 The healthcare workforce is inherently expensive, with employee wages and benefits constituting the most significant expense for acute care hospitals. 8 Clinical labor costs rose by almost 40% between 2019 and early 2022 2 as hospitals struggled to recruit and retain staff. A recent examination indicated that the hospital staffing deficiencies imposed an additional financial burden of $24 billion on hospitals. The increased utilization of agency staff is an important reason for the dramatic escalation in staffing costs. 9 The agency staff is significantly more expensive than regular full-time equivalent (FTE) staff--- typically adding 50% or more to an employee's hourly rate. 10 The use of agency staff may have adverse quality implications due to various factors such as their temporary nature that can result in a lack of crucial institutional knowledge. The increased financial strain of employing agency nurses may also stretch h -Abstract Truncated-
health care sciences & services,health policy & services