The role of piano improvisation in teaching harmony, using combined materials selected from the baroque period and jazz standard repertoire : towards a comprehensive approach
Mónika Benedek
Abstract:Benedek, Mónika The role of piano improvisation in teaching harmony, using combined materials selected from the Baroque period and jazz standard repertoire: towards a comprehensive approach Jyväskylä: University of Jyväskylä, 2015, 395 p. (Jyväskylä Studies on Humanities ISSN 1459-4323; 249 (nid.), ISSN 1459-4331; 249 (PDF)) ISBN: 978-951-39-6148-0 (nid.) ISBN: 978-951-39-6149-7 (PDF) Harmony teaching traditionally follows separate paths in mainstream classical and jazz tertiary music education, based on the distinctive stylistic features and idioms developed in different eras. Nevertheless, these genres do share a variety of common features, and the goal of this research was to identify and integrate particular elements of musical practice in order to advance combined harmony teaching of baroque and jazz styles. The main aim of the research was to explore the applicability of piano improvisation as a potential pedagogical tool in the combined teaching of baroque and jazz harmony and to investigate in what ways it supports the development of harmony knowledge and various musical skills. Following the action research strategy, the research was conducted in two cycles, and data were collected in two subsequent teaching courses with Finnish university students. Qualitative research methodology was applied to analyse the data from both research cycles. Study One functioned as a pilot study involving seven students and examined what kind of approaches the students and the teacher found the most applicable in combined harmony teaching. Data concerning students’ previous experiences and the progress and challenges to learning harmony during the course were gathered from questionnaires, learning diaries, video recordings, and harmony tests for comparative analysis with the researcher’s observations. Findings showed that the practical approaches i.e. improvisation, composing variations, and aural learning using existing musical examples were particularly successful in such combined teaching of harmony. Study Two investigated the applicability of piano improvisation as a teaching tool in combined harmony teaching, with nine students divided in two groups employing improvisation at different parts of the course. Harmony tests measured the development in students’ harmony knowledge and aural skills. Audio recordings of improvisation tests measured the students’ improvisation skills, with and without peer accompaniment. The observations supported by video recordings of the lessons examined the students’ overall learning progress and development of musical skills. The students also expressed their opinions about learning harmony with and without improvisation via questionnaires. All data were analysed separately in each student’s case and were presented as a chronological narrative of each student’s learning progress, and conclusions were drawn from each case. The results showed that improvisation, especially with peers, positively influenced the students’ theoretical and practical knowledge of both baroque and jazz harmony and their aural skills. However, students’ existing knowledge of harmony in each genre; the starting level of their aural, improvisation, and piano skills; and the timing of the improvisation during the course also influenced the learning progress. Improvisation appeared to be more applicable to learning harmony once a certain amount of theoretical knowledge and aural and piano skills were first established. The students were motivated to learn harmony with improvisation and baroque and jazz harmony com-
Art,Education