Conditions of contact with otherness and their consequences: a quantitative analysis of contemporary travel writing on Portugal and Spain
Paulo Tiago Bento
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14766825.2017.1400038
2017-11-16
Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change
Abstract:This study looks at correlations between conditions of contact with otherness faced by travel writers and structural dimensions of their writing, adopting a quantitative perspective in order to overcome the methodological flaw of implicit quantification found in studies of texts. The ideal-types of tourist, traveller and migrant underlie such explanatory conditions, along with gender and national culture. The tourist and the traveller are distinguished through their relations with local people and tourist attractions, prompting the concepts of relational attraction, attraction additiveness and attraction system. Structural, dependent variables are the level of generality of images of otherness, the forms these images assume (description, understanding, explanation, assessment and voicing) and their sources (experience, reflexion, informants and indirect information). Overall, conditions do not show up correlated with structure, and there is an unexpected correlation between gender and structure, opposing the notion of feminine writing as an orientation to emotional views. Still, culture explains high use of voicing and a de-romanticized concept of migrant partially accounts for the observations that migrants do not produce relatively more images of otherness and that they do not engage relatively more in voicing. Likewise, the unexpected observation that travellers tend to assess more than tourists is explained.
hospitality, leisure, sport & tourism