Abstract:Body size is undoubtedly one of the most useful measures of sexual dimorphism and, by proxy, sexual selection. Here, I examine large, published datasets of average sexual size dimorphism (SSD) in four clades of amniotes: birds, mammals, squamates, and turtles. Most sexual variation is of subtle magnitude; attempts to discretely categorize species as monomorphic may overlook genuine and common sexual variations of small magnitude (e.g., <10–20% difference). Mammals, squamates, and turtles have unimodal SSD distributions centered close to zero that vary in skew. Mammals skew towards a preponderance of taxa with larger males than females, and mammals with the most extreme SSD have larger males than females. Turtles, however, skew strongly towards a preponderance of taxa with larger females than males, and turtles with the most extreme SSD have larger females than males. Squamates are intermediate to these two clades. Birds are unique in that they 1) are noticeably deficient in taxa near monomorphism, 2) have a bimodal distribution with peaks closely and roughly equidistantly straddling either side of monomorphism, and 3) have a high preponderance of taxa with larger males than females. This suggests stronger disruptive selection or constraints against monomorphism in birds compared to other amniotes. Bird data from yields bimodality, while other datasets do not, possibly due to data artefacts/errors. Although Rensch’s rule (RR) is difficult to apply to broad clades, scaling patterns were nevertheless examined here. While turtles and squamates show full adherence to RR, mammals show weaker adherence. Mammal scaling is comparatively less male-biased with increased size than scaling in squamates and turtles, and sex-role reversed mammals instead approach isometry between male and female size. Although bird taxa with larger males than females follow RR, sex-role reversed birds show the converse RR pattern. In birds, increasing size leads to increased dimorphism magnitude regardless of the direction of dimorphism, even though regression of the entire clade deceptively suggests they scale isometrically. This paradoxical scaling explains their unusual bimodal SSD distribution, as shown here through simulation. Equidistant bimodality from monomorphism might suggest disruptive selection where both mating systems have mirrored sexual selection dynamics of comparable effect. Scaling patterns between dimorphism magnitude and overall taxon size in non-reversed and reversed systems might not be readily apparent when examining the whole clade. Large mammals have disproportionately male-biased and more extreme SSD magnitudes. In comparison, large birds have relatively numerous sex-role reversed taxa as well as more extreme SSD magnitudes. These results deserve further testing with tighter phylogenetic controls and comparison of data sources. Additional ecological, physiological, and behavioral variables should also be examined in relation to SSD (e.g., altriciality vs. precociality, oviparity vs. viviparity, clutch size, neonate mass).

Fossil evidence sheds light on sexual selection during the early evolution of birds

HIGH RATES OF EVOLUTION PRECEDED THE ORIGIN OF BIRDS

Insight Into Body Size Evolution in Aves: Based on Some Body Size–Related Genes

Phylogeny, transposable element and sex chromosome evolution of the basal lineage of birds

Decoupling the skull and skeleton in a Cretaceous bird with unique appendicular morphologies

Correlated Evolution of Sternal Keel Length and Ilium Length in Birds

The patterns and modes of the evolution of disparity in Mesozoic birds

A new basal bird from China with implications for morphological diversity in early birds

Recognizing sexual dimorphism in the fossil record: lessons from nonavian dinosaurs

Diversity and Evolution of the Confuciusornithidae: Evidence from a New 131-Million-year-old Specimen from the Huajiying Formation in NE China

An Early Cretaceous Enantiornithine Bird with a Pintail.

An integrative approach to understanding bird origins AVIAN EVOLUTION

A bony-crested Jurassic dinosaur with evidence of iridescent plumage highlights complexity in early paravian evolution

Diversification in an Early Cretaceous Avian Genus: Evidence from a New Species of Confuciusornis from China

Adult Sex Ratio, Sexual Dimorphism and Sexual Selection in A Mesozoic Reptile

Hind Wings in Basal Birds and the Evolution of Leg Feathers

A New Sapeornithid Bird from China and Its Implication for Early Avian Evolution

The macroevolution of sexual size dimorphism in birds

Intraskeletal histovariability, allometric growth patterns, and their functional implications in bird-like dinosaurs

DO BIRDS SHOW UNIQUE MACROEVOLUTIONARY PATTERNS OF SEXUAL SIZE DIMORPHISM COMPARED TO OTHER AMNIOTES?

An integrative approach to understanding bird origins