Abstract:This paper studies axioms for nonmonotonic consequences from a semantics-based point of view, focusing on a class of mathematical structures for reasoning about partial information without a predefined syntax/logic. This structure is called a default structure. We study axioms for the nonmonotonic consequence relation derived from extensions as in Reiter's default logic, using skeptical reasoning, but extensions are now used for the construction of possible worlds in a default information structure. In previous work we showed that skeptical reasoning arising from default-extensions obeys a well-behaved set of axioms including the axiom of cautious cut. We show here that, remarkably, the converse is also true: any consequence relation obeying this set of axioms can be represented as one constructed from skeptical reasoning. We provide representation theorems to relate axioms for nonmonotonic consequence relation and properties about extensions, and provide one-to-one correspondence between nonmonotonic systems which satisfies the law of cautious monotony and default structures with unique extensions. Our results give a theoretical justification for a set of basic rules governing the update of nonmonotonic knowledge bases, demonstrating the derivation of them from the more concrete and primitive construction of extensions. It is also striking to note that proofs of the representation theorems show that only shallow extensions are necessary, in the sense that the number of iterations needed to achieve an extension is at most three. All of these developments are made possible by taking a more liberal view of consistency: consistency is a user defined predicate, satisfying some basic properties.

User-Defined Nonmonotonicity in Unification-Based Formalisms

Going Forth and Drawing Back: an Intensional Approach in Nonmonotonic Inference.

New Equations for Neutral Terms: A Sound and Complete Decision Procedure, Formalized

New Logical Perspectives on Monotonicity.

Free Monads, Intrinsic Scoping, and Higher-Order Preunification

Elaborating Intersection and Union Types

A Logic for Non-Monotone Inductive Definitions

Are LLMs classical or nonmonotonic reasoners? Lessons from generics

Axiomatic Aspects of Default Inference

NP Reasoning in the Monotone $μ$-Calculus

A Formalized Extension of the Substitution Lemma in Coq

A logic for default reasoning

Non-monotonic Negation in Probabilistic Deductive Databases

Regular Substitution Sets: A Means of Controlling E-Unification

Modeling Non-Monotonic Properties under Propositional Argumentation

Free Σ-Monoids: A Higher-Order Syntax with Metavariables

Monotonicity in Logic and Language: Second Tsinghua Interdisciplinary Workshop on Logic, Language and Meaning, TLLM 2020, Beijing, China, December 17-20, 2020, Proceedings

Automatic Differentiation for ML-family languages: correctness via logical relations

Nonmonotonic Reasoning, Expectations Orderings, and Conceptual Spaces

Unification in the Description Logic EL

Flexible and Reversible Conversion between Extensible Records and Overloading Constraints for ML