Emotions and behaviours of child and adolescent psychiatric patients during the COVID-19 pandemic
Claudine Laurent-Levinson,Anne-Sophie Pellen,Hugues Pellerin,Cyril Hanin,Juliette Bouzy,Marie Devernay,Vanessa Milhiet,Xavier Benarous,Angèle Consoli,Jianxin Shi,Douglas F. Levinson,David Cohen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1192/bjo.2023.533
2024-02-16
BJPsych Open
Abstract:Background Previous pandemics have had negative effects on mental health, but there are few data on children and adolescents who were receiving ongoing psychiatric treatment. Aims To study changes in emotions and clinical state, and their predictors, during the COVID-19 pandemic in France. Method We administered (by interview) the baseline Youth Self-Report version of the CoRonavIruS Health Impact Survey v0.3 (CRISIS, French translation) to 123 adolescent patients and the Parent/Caregiver version to evaluate 99 child patients before and during the first ‘lockdown’. For 139 of these patients who received ongoing treatment in our centre, treating physicians retrospectively completed longitudinal global ratings for five time periods, masked to CRISIS ratings. Results The main outcome measure was the sum of eight mood state items, which formed a single factor in each age group. Overall, this score improved for each age group during the first lockdown. Clinician ratings modestly supported this result in patients without intellectual disability or autism spectrum disorder. Improvement of mood states was significantly associated with perceived improvement in family relationships in both age groups. Conclusions Consistent with previous studies of clinical cohorts, our patients had diverse responses during the pandemic. Several factors may have contributed to the finding of improvement in some individuals during the first lockdown, including the degree of family support or conflict, stress reduction owing to isolation, limitations of the outcome measures and/or possible selection bias. Ongoing treatment may have had a protective effect. Clinically, during crises additional support may be needed by families who experience increased conflict or who care for children with intellectual disability.
psychiatry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve
This paper aims to study the changes in the emotional and clinical states of children and adolescents receiving psychiatric treatment during the first COVID - 19 lockdown in France and their predictors. Specifically, the researchers hope to understand the following questions:
1. **Emotional changes**: Did the emotional states of children and adolescents change significantly during the lockdown?
2. **Predictors**: Which factors are related to the changes in emotional states? For example, changes in family relationships, concerns about COVID - 19, etc.
3. **Clinical impact**: During the lockdown, did the overall clinical states of these patients improve or deteriorate?
### Research background
- **Previous research**: Previous pandemics have had a negative impact on mental health, but there is less data on children and adolescents receiving ongoing psychiatric treatment.
- **Research motivation**: To fill this gap, the researchers used the CoRonavIruS Health Impact Survey (CRISIS) questionnaire to assess the emotional and behavioral changes of children and adolescents during the pandemic.
### Methods
- **Sample selection**: The study subjects included 123 adolescent patients and 99 child patients. These patients were surveyed before and during the lockdown.
- **Data collection**: Through telephone interviews or face - to - face interviews, the CRISIS questionnaire data at baseline and during the lockdown were collected. In addition, the doctor retrospectively completed the longitudinal global scores at five time points.
- **Primary outcome measure**: The primary outcome measure was the total score of eight emotional state items, which formed a single factor in each age group.
### Results
- **Changes in emotional states**: Overall, the emotional state scores of adolescents and children improved during the lockdown.
- **Predictors**: The improvement in emotional states was significantly related to the improvement in family relationships. Other factors, such as concerns about COVID - 19, were also related to the changes in emotional states.
- **Clinical evaluation**: The results of the doctor's evaluation partially supported the results of the questionnaire survey, especially in patients without intellectual disability or autism spectrum disorder.
### Conclusions
- **Diverse responses**: Consistent with previous studies, patients showed diverse responses during the pandemic.
- **Possible explanations**: The reasons why some individuals' emotional states improved during the lockdown may include the level of family support, the reduction of stress brought by isolation, the limitations of outcome measurement, and possible selection bias.
- **Clinical recommendations**: During the crisis, additional support needs to be provided for families experiencing more family conflicts or taking care of children with intellectual disabilities.
### Keywords
- Children and adolescents; Mental disorders; COVID - 19; Pandemic; Resilience
### Formula display
- **Emotional state score**: $ \text{Mood8} = \sum_{i = 1}^{8} \text{item}_i $
- **Amount of change**: $ \text{Mood8 - Change} = \text{Mood8 - CONF1} - \text{Mood8 - Before} $
Through these methods and analyses, the researchers hope to better understand the mental health changes of children and adolescents receiving psychiatric treatment during the pandemic and provide a basis for future intervention measures.