Abstract:Feedback plays a crucial role in the writing processes. However, in the literature on foreign language (FL) writing, there is a dearth of studies that compare the effects of teacher feedback and automated feedback on both cognitive and psychological aspects of FL writing. To fill this gap, the current study compared the effects of teacher feedback and automated feedback on both revision quality and writing proficiency development (i.e., the cognitive aspects), and perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use of the feedback (i.e., the psychological aspects) in English writing among English learners as an FL (EFLs) in China. It also investigated students' perceptions of the strengths and weaknesses of the two types of feedback. The study adopted a mixed-methods design. The quantitative method collected the data through (1) a pre-test and a post-test, which measured the participants' English writing proficiency development; (2) a writing task, which received either teacher feedback or automated feedback; and (3) a close-ended questionnaire, which examined students' perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use of the feedback. The qualitative method collected the data through an open-ended questionnaire, which examined the participants' perceptions of the strengths and weaknesses of teacher feedback or automated feedback depending on the type of feedback they received. Chinese university EFLs in two English classes ( n = 35 in each class) taught by the same English teacher participated in the study: one class received teacher feedback while the other received automated feedback using Pigaiwang. While the students in the two classes did not differ significantly on the pre-test of students' writing proficiency, students who received teacher feedback scored significantly higher on revision than those who received automated feedback. Students in the teacher feedback class also had significantly higher ratings on perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use of the feedback than those in the automated feedback class. However, students in the automated feedback class obtained significantly higher scores on the post-test of the writing proficiency. The qualitative results identified three themes of strengths and two themes of weaknesses for the teacher feedback and the automated feedback, respectively. The results suggest that while teacher feedback has a more positive effect on the psychological aspect of FL writing, automated feedback may be more effective in developing FL writing proficiency in the long run.

Exploring the Effects of Teachers' Feed up and Feed Forward on Chinese Senior High Students' English Writing Self-efficacy and Writing Motivation

Comparative Study about the Impacts of Chinese Automated Writing Evaluation (AWE) Feedback and Teacher Feedback on Middle School Students’ Writing Practice

Self-efficacy, Task Values and Growth Mindset: What Has the Most Predictive Power for Primary School Students’ Self-Regulated Learning in English Writing and Writing Competence in an Asian Confucian Cultural Context?

Investigating What Feedback Practices Contribute to Students’ Writing Motivation and Engagement in Chinese EFL Context: A Large Scale Study

The Impact of Peer Feedback on Chinese EFL Junior High School Students’ Writing Performance

The Influence of Written Corrective Feedback on Students’ Learning Engagement in Writing: A Longitudinal Comparative Study of Middle and High School EFL Students in China

Secondary Students’ L2 Writing Motivation and Engagement: the Impact of Teachers’ Instructional Approaches and Feedback Practices

The Effects of Positive Self-evaluation on Senior High School Students’ English Writing Performance and Writing Self-efficacy

The English Learning Motivation of Chinese Secondary School Students: Cross-grade Survey Analysis

Examining the effects of self-regulated learning-based teacher feedback on English-as-a-foreign-language learners’ self-regulated writing strategies and writing performance

The Effects of Teacher Feedback and Automated Feedback on Cognitive and Psychological Aspects of Foreign Language Writing: A Mixed-Methods Research

Text quality and changing perceptions of teacher feedback and affective-motivational variables: a study with secondary EFL students

Individual Differences in L2 Writing Feedback-Seeking Behaviors: the Predictive Roles of Various Motivational Constructs

Meta-cognitive Strategies, Automated Writing Evaluation Feedback and English Writing Performance of Chinese EFL College Students

The Effects of Writing Anxiety and Motivation on EFL College Students' Self-Evaluative Judgments of Corrective Feedback

Exploring teachers' attitudes and self-efficacy beliefs for implementing student self-assessment of English as a foreign language writing

Exploring Hong Kong primary students’ English writing motivation: relationships between writing self-efficacy and task value

The Role of Self-Efficacy, Task Value, and Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivations in Students’ Feedback Engagement in English Learning

Effects of EFL Learners’ L2 Writing Self-efficacy on Engagement with Written Corrective Feedback

A Case Study of the Impact of Teacher Written Feedback on Chinese EFL University Students

A Study on the Application of Reading-to-Write Approach in Senior High English Writing Classes