Abstract:Research has shown that serious games, digital game-based learning, and educational video games can be powerful learning instruments. However, experimental and meta-research have revealed that several moderators and variables influence the resulting learning outcomes. Advances in the areas of learning and game analytics potentially allow for controlling and improving the underlying learning processes of games by adapting their mechanics to the individual needs of the learner, to properties of the learning material, and/or to environmental factors. However, the field is young and no clear-cut guidelines are yet available. To shed more light on this topic and to identify common ground for further research, we conducted a systematic and pre-registered analysis of the literature. Particular attention was paid to different modes of adaptivity, different adaptive mechanisms in various learning domains and populations, differing theoretical frameworks, research methods, and measured concepts, as well as divergent underlying measures and analytics. Only 10 relevant papers were identified through the systematic literature search, which confirms that the field is still in its very early phases. The studies on which these papers were based, however, show promise in terms of the efficacy of adaptive educational games. Moreover, we identified an increased interest in the field of adaptive educational games and in the use of analytics. Nevertheless, we also identified a clear lack of common theoretical foundations as well as the application of rather heterogenous methods for investigating the effects of adaptivity. Most problematic was the lack of sufficient information (e.g., descriptions of used games, adaptive mechanisms), which often made it difficult to draw clear conclusions. Future studies should therefore focus on strong theory building and adhere to reporting standards across disciplines. Researchers from different disciplines must act in concert to advance the current state of the field in order to maximize its potential.

Adaptive learning concept selection: a bibliometric review of scholarly literature from 2011 to 2019

The Trends in Adaptive Learning Research: A Bibliometric Analysis Study

AI‐driven adaptive learning for sustainable educational transformation

Adaptive Water Governance Research in Social Sciences Journals: a Bibliometric Analysis

Past, present, and future of smart learning: a topic-based bibliometric analysis

AI-enabled adaptive learning systems: A systematic mapping of the literature

Evolution of topics in education research: a systematic review using bibliometric analysis

Trends in artificial intelligence-supported e-learning: a systematic review and co-citation network analysis (1998–2019)

Adaptive Learning Using Artificial Intelligence in e-Learning: A Literature Review

A systematic literature review on adaptive content recommenders in personalized learning environments from 2015 to 2020

Mapping Artificial Intelligence in Education Research: a Network‐based Keyword Analysis

Cross-Cultural Learning: A Visualized Bibliometric Analysis Based on Bibliometrix from 2002 to 2021

Adaptive game-based learning in education: a systematic review

Bibliometric Analysis of Cooperative Learning (1974–2023)

A Bibliometric Study on E-Learning Software Engineering Education

Investigating the active learning research landscape through a bibliometric analysis of an influential meta-analysis on active learning

A Systematic Literature Review of Analytics for Adaptivity Within Educational Video Games

Trends and Developments in Engineering Education: A Bibliometric Analysis of Students' Competencies Research (2015-2024)

Research Landscape of Artificial Intelligence and e-Learning: A Bibliometric Research

A Bibliometric Analysis of the Scientific Production of e-Learning in Higher Education (1998-2020)

Social Media as Learning Tools: A Bibliometric Study of Educational Applications