Abstract:Purpose Three different pedagogical approaches grounded in three different definitional foundations of entrepreneurship have been compared in relation to their effects on students. They are: (1) “Idea and Artefact-Creation Pedagogy” (IACP), grounded in opportunity identification and creation, (2) “Value-Creation Pedagogy” (VaCP), grounded in value creation and (3) “Venture-Creation Pedagogy” (VeCP), grounded in organisation creation. Design/methodology/approach Data were collected at 35 different sites where education was deemed to be entrepreneurial and experiential. A quantitative, smartphone app-based data collection method was used alongside a qualitative interview approach. 10,953 short-survey responses were received from 1,048 participants. Responses were used to inform respondent selection and discussion topics, in 291 student and teacher interviews. Comparative analysis was then conducted. Findings The three approaches resulted in very different outcomes, both in magnitude and in kind. VaCP had strong effects on entrepreneurial competencies, on student motivation and on knowledge and skills acquisition. VeCP had weaker effects on knowledge and skills acquisition. IACP had weak effects on all outcomes probed for. Differences were attributed to variation in prevalence of certain emotional learning events and to variation in purpose as perceived by students. Research limitations/implications VaCP could serve as an escape from the potential dilemma faced by many teachers in entrepreneurial education, of being caught between two limiting courses of action; a marginal VeCP approach and a fuzzy IACP one. This could prompt policymakers to reconsider established policies. However, further research in other contexts is needed, to corroborate the extent of differences between these three approaches. Originality/value Most impact studies in experiential entrepreneurial education focus only on organisation-creation-based education. This study contributes by investigating entrepreneurial education that is also grounded in two other definitional foundations. Allowance has been made for novel comparative conclusions.

Special Issue Guest Editorial: The Challenges of Experimental Designs in Entrepreneurship Education Research - An Interview With Thomas D. Cook

Marta Peris-Ortiz, Jaime Alonso Gómez, José M. Merigó-Lindahl, Carlos Rueda-Armengot (eds.): Entrepreneurial Universities: Exploring the Academic and Innovative Dimensions of Entrepreneurship in Higher Education

Factors Influencing Entrepreneurial Intentions of Chinese Secondary School Students: an Empirical Study

Comparing the impact of three different experiential approaches to entrepreneurship in education

Entrepreneurship Education Comes of Age on Campus: the Challenges and Rewards of Bringing Entrepreneurship to Higher Education

Learning from success and failure: implications for entrepreneurs, SMEs, and policy

The Impact of Entrepreneurship Education on Entrepreneurial Intention. A Quasi-Experimental Research Design

Making Entrepreneurship Education Available to All: Design Principles for Educational Programs Stimulating an Entrepreneurial Mindset

Personal views on the future of entrepreneurship education

Entrepreneurship education: Time for a change in research direction?

The Impact of Entrepreneurship Education on Entrepreneurial Attitudes and Intention: Hysteresis and Persistence

A systematic literature review of the evolution of pedagogy in entrepreneurial education research

Do entrepreneurship education activities have an impact on entrepreneurial behavior? An application of behavioral entrepreneurial intention

The Emergence of Entrepreneurship Education: Development, Trends, and Challenges

Entrepreneurship and Intrapreneurship in Social, Sustainable, and Economic Development: Opportunities and Challenges for Future Research

What makes entrepreneurship research interesting? Reflections on strategies to overcome the rigour–relevance gap

Entrepreneurial orientation: International, global and cross-cultural research

Digital Affordances, Spatial Affordances, and the Genesis of Entrepreneurial Ecosystems

Entrepreneurial decision-making in a microcosm

An Empiric Experience Implementing a Methodology to Improve the Entrepreneurial Support System: Creating Social Value Through Collaboration and Co-creation

Entrepreneurship Education: A Systematic Literature Review and Identification of an Existing Gap in the Field