Respondents without mental disorders but with a need for treatment HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES LOW INCOME COUNTRIES Respondents with lifetime mental disorders
Ronny Bruffaerts,Jose Posada-Villa,Ali Obaid Al-Hamzawi,Oye Gureje,Yueqin Huang,Chiyi Hu,Evelyn J. Bromet,Maria Carmen Viana,Hristo Ruskov Hinkov,Elie G. Karam,Guilherme Borges,Silvia E. Florescu,David R. Williams,Koen Demyttenaere,Viviane Kovess-Masfety,Herbert Matschinger,Daphna Levinson,Giovanni de Girolamo,Yutaka Ono,Ron de Graaf,Mark Oakley Browne,Brendan Bunting,Miguel Xavier,Josep Maria Haro,Ronald C. Kessler
2015-01-01
Abstract:for both the individual and society. Given the high prevalence of mental disorders globally, it is necessary to triage resources to those who need them most. Although undertreatment receives considerable attention, previous studies suggest that between one-third and half of the patients who are treated for mental disorders do not meet formal criteria for such disorders and that 3–14% of people without a mental disorder receive treatment for problems with emotions or the use of substances in a given year. However, these data are far from conclusive in arguing that a high proportion of treatment going to patients with low need. This is true for several reasons. First, most studies failed to assess other indicators of need for treatment besides diagnoses (for example recent stressors or suicidal behaviours). This is important because mental disorders are not the only indicators of need for treatment. Second, most previous studies did not provide information about the sector in which patients who failed to meet full criteria for a disorder received their treatment. This is important because treatment of such patients in the human services sector (such as spiritual counselling during normal bereavement) or the self-help sector (such as participation in a trauma survivor support group) would not be seen as inappropriate. Third, most of these studies were carried out in a small set of countries (mostly the USA, but also Canada Germany, The Netherlands, Chile and Australia). As far as we are aware, no global data exist that examines the proportion of treatment for problems with emotional issues or substance use received by those patients who fail to meet full criteria for a mental disorder. Such a study is especially timely in an era when governments, policymakers and healthcare planners face competing priorities and economic constraints. Data are reported here on these issues based on an analysis of data collected in the World Health Organization (WHO) World Mental Health (WMH) surveys. The WMH surveys are general population surveys that used structured psychiatric interviews, validated for use worldwide, to measure the presence of mental disorders as well as treatment for problems with emotions or for substance use. The current study builds on earlier WMH studies reporting on the crossnational treatment of mental disorders by investigating treatment of people without mental disorders. The specific aims of the study were to investigate the proportion of patients in treatment for problems with emotions or substance use at anytime in the 12 months before interview who failed to meet criteria for a DSM-IV disorder at any time during that 12-month period, to investigate other indicators of need among these patients, to examine the sectors of treatment as well as the frequency and duration of their use of services, and to examine their self-reported reasons for seeking treatment.