Coordination of tradable carbon emission permits market and renewable electricity certificates market in China

Ge Wang,Qi Zhang,Bin Su,Bo Shen,Yan Li,Zhengjun Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2020.105038

IF: 12.8

2021-01-01

Energy Economics

Abstract:<p>In order to assist the low-carbon transformation of power sector, China is planning to establish the national Tradable carbon emission permits (TEPs) market and Renewable Electricity Certificates (RECs) market under mandatory carbon caps and Renewable Portfolio Standards (RPS) targets simultaneously. How to coordinate the two markets and what the coordination effects are become key issues. In the present study, a multi-region multi-market equilibrium model considering both mechanisms was developed and applied to China as the case study. The model established the effective coordination interval between RPS targets and carbon caps in which the two markets can operate jointly. Then the coordinated markets were proved to be more economically efficient so long as the government pursues the dual goal of reducing carbon emission and promoting renewable energy in sync. Finally, the theoretical and practical advantages of market coordination compared with uncoupled operation of these markets, such as diversifying markets risk, keeping TEP/REC price at lower level, and reducing consumers' electricity purchase cost, were discussed.</p>

economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how China can coordinate the relationship between the two markets in the case of simultaneously implementing the Tradable carbon emission permits (TEPs) and the Renewable Portfolio Standards (RPS) to achieve the goal of low - carbon transformation. Specifically, the paper explores the following points:

1. **Necessity of market coordination**: Since the goals of the TEPs market and the RECs market overlap (i.e., promoting carbon dioxide emission reduction), effective coordination between the two markets is required to avoid policy redundancy and an increase in social costs.

2. **Effective coordination interval**: By establishing a multi - region and multi - market equilibrium model, the paper determines the effective coordination interval between the RPS target and the carbon emission cap, enabling the two markets to operate in synergy and jointly promote low - carbon technologies and reduce carbon dioxide emissions.

3. **Coordination effect**: The research proves that as long as the government pursues the dual goals of reducing carbon emissions and promoting the development of renewable energy at the same time, the coordinated market will be more economically efficient.

4. **Theoretical and practical advantages**: The paper discusses the theoretical and practical advantages of market coordination compared to independently operating markets, such as dispersing market risks, keeping TEP/REC prices at a lower level, and reducing consumers' electricity purchase costs.

In summary, the main purpose of this paper is to provide effective market coordination strategies for China through model analysis while implementing the TEPs market and the RECs market, in order to achieve the dual goals of low - carbon transformation.