The Portion Control Strategies Trial: a Year‐long Randomized Controlled Trial on the Impact of Portion Control on Weight Change

Barbara J. Rolls,Brittany L. James,Christine E. Sanchez,Liane S. Roe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1096/fasebj.30.1_supplement.405.1

2016-04-01

The FASEB Journal

Abstract:Controlling food and beverage portion sizes can help reduce energy intake, but there are few data on the longer‐term effects on body weight. We tested the efficacy of two portion‐control strategies on weight change over one year. In a randomized controlled trial, overweight and obese women were randomly assigned to one of three equally intensive interventions: two focused on portion control and one provided standard weight loss advice. The Portion Selection Group learned to select appropriate portions based on energy density and received tools such as food scales, and the Pre‐portioned Foods Group learned to structure meals around pre‐portioned foods and received vouchers for commercial frozen entrées. The Standard Advice Group learned to manage weight by following the US Dietary Guidelines to eat less and to make nutritious choices. Participants met individually with trained interventionists weekly in Month 1, biweekly in Months 2–5, and monthly in Months 6–12; all groups received the same advice on increasing physical activity and managing behavior change. The participants were 186 women with a mean (±SEM) age of 50±0.8 y and weight of 201±2.1 lb; 19% were overweight and 81% were obese. A total of 151 women (81%) had their weight measured at the end of the trial. Rates of attendance and withdrawal from the trial were similar across groups. Results were analyzed with a statistical model that estimated a weight loss trajectory for all participants regardless of the number of contacts. Participants in all groups lost weight during the first six months (13.0±0.9 lb) and maintained most of this loss during the second six months (11.4±1.2 lb). In the first three months, however, the Pre‐portioned Foods Group lost weight at a greater rate (P<0.01; 11.0±1.1 lb) than the Portion Selection Group (9.1±1.0 lb) and the Standard Advice Group (8.4±1.0 lb), and subsequently regained more weight. At the end of the year, weight loss did not differ significantly across groups; 45% had lost ≥ 5% of body weight and 20% had lost ≥ 10% of body weight. Physical activity (step counts) increased over time but did not differ across groups. Changes in blood pressure over the course of the trial did not differ across groups. In all groups, waist circumference and fasting glucose decreased, HDL cholesterol increased, and LDL cholesterol did not change over the trial. These results show that for all groups, individual instruction on diet and physical activity facilitated weight loss and maintenance of that loss. In addition, limiting exposure to large portions by using pre‐portioned foods enhanced initial weight loss, but this was not sustained in the longer term. Support or Funding Information National Institutes of Health grant DK059853

cell biology,biochemistry & molecular biology,biology