Including mental health as part of climate change impacts and adaptation assessment: A critical advance in IPCC AR6
Sherilee L. Harper,Ashlee Cunsolo,Susan Clayton
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pclm.0000033
2022-05-17
PLOS Climate
Abstract:AR6 states with very high confidence that climate change has already negatively impacted mental health globally, and is expected to worsen with future climate change [1]. Adverse mental health outcomes assessed in AR6 included diagnosable mental disorders as well as subclinical outcomes that disrupt or impair normal functioning through impacts on mood, thinking, or behaviour [3]. Importantly, 15 out of 17 chapters in AR6 consider mental health, presenting evidence that clearly links climate change to increased suicide, suicide ideation, generalized anxiety, depression, acute traumatic stress, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), strong emotional reactions (e.g. stress, anger, hopelessness, grief, anxiety), drug and alcohol use and abuse, family stress, domestic violence, and sleep problems. These mental health risks are often driven and/or exacerbated by inequity, injustice, and colonialism. Those identified at higher risk included rural populations [4]; children, youth, and elderly [3, 5–7]; women [3]; Indigenous Peoples [6, 7]; low and middle income countries [3]; as well as people with pre-existing physical and mental health conditions [7], living in highly exposed areas, reliant on climate for livelihoods (e.g. farmers) [6], or in occupations responding to climate change (e.g. first responders) [3]. Globally, complex, compound, and cascading mental health risks have emerged from weather and climate extremes (e.g. heatwaves, droughts, floods, storms, fires) [1, 3]. Illustrative examples can be found around the world. For example, in Africa, extreme heat has increased negative mental health outcomes and suicide and other weather extremes have increased anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder, and depression [8]; in Asia, storms, floods, hurricanes, and cyclones have increased PTSD and depressive disorders [9]; in Australasia, wildfires have led to mental health challenges [4]; in Europe, flooding has negatively impacted mental health outcomes [5]. In addition to events like these, drought and desertification can also impair mental health [10]. These mental health outcomes are rooted in the economic, social, infrastructure, health, and food system disruptions caused by the weather and climate extremes. Evacuation during extreme events negatively impacts mental health during the event and for months after the event due to displacement, employment loss, disruption to social networks, death of friends and family, and navigating unfamiliar labour markets [11]. For example, in 2017, Tropical Cyclone Debbie displaced 31,000 people and 6 months after the event, adverse mental health outcomes were more common among those who experienced health and social care disruptions [4]. In another example, after a flooding event, people in the UK experienced PTSD, anxiety, and depression not only due to the flooding event itself, but also from subsequent disputes with insurance and construction companies [5]. Slow-onset climate changes, including warming temperatures, sea-level rise, coastal erosion, and sea-ice decline, have increased mental health challenges. For example, higher ambient temperatures are associated with increasing suicide, anxiety, depression, acute stress, and increased hospital admissions and emergency room visits for mental health conditions in Asia, Europe, and North America [3, 5–7, 9]. Slow onset climate changes, including sea level rise, coastal erosion, loss of sea ice, wildfires, permafrost thaw, and coral reef survival, impact landscapes, cultural practices and identity, and cultural heritage sites, and can lead to feelings of ecological grief, solastalgia, and 'reef grief', including for Indigenous Peoples globally and those who rely on or are deeply connected to particularly places and landscapes, such as farmers, fishers, and researchers [3, 4, 6, 7, 12]. Adverse mental health outcomes can emerge, even if someone has not personally or directly experienced climate change impacts. For example, people have experienced mental health challenges from vicariously experiencing climate change by witnessing climate change impacts on the environment and people on the news, or seeing friends and family experience climate change [3, 4, 6]. Furthermore, even learning about climate change itself can affect mental health [3]. The perceived threat of climate change can also lead to climate anxiety and to anticipatory loss and grief related to climate change. For example, in the Arctic, Honduras, Tuvalu, Fiji, Solomon Islands, and other Pacific Islands, Indigenous Peoples' fears of future cultural loss and ocean changes have led to worry, anxiety, sadness, and grief [3, 12–14].