Abstract:Men generally have an inherent performance advantage over women due to their average greater height and muscle mass and power, as the result of correspondingly different exposures to androgens. Therefore, it is considered fair that in sports men and women compete in separate categories. The question now emerging is whether reassigned transsexuals can compete in fairness with others of their new sex. The pertinent question is how far the previous effects of testosterone in male-to-female transsexuals (M-F) are reversible upon androgen deprivation so that M-F have no advantage over women, and, vice versa, what the effects are of androgen exposure in female-to-male transsexuals (F-M) on variables relevant to competition in sports. Before puberty, boys and girls do not differ in height, muscle and bone mass. Recent information shows convincingly that actual levels of circulating testosterone determine largely muscle mass and strength, though with considerable interindividual diversity. This study analyzed the effects of androgen deprivation in 19 M-F and of androgen administration to 17 F-M on muscle mass, hemoglobin (Hb) and insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1). Before cross-sex hormone administration, there was a considerable overlap in muscle mass between M-F and F-M. In both M-F and F-M, height was a strong predictor of muscle mass. Androgen deprivation of M-F decreased muscle mass, increasing the overlap with untreated F-M, but mean muscle mass remained significantly higher in M-F than in F-M. Androgen administration to F-M increased muscle mass without inducing an advantage over nontreated M-F. The conclusion is that androgen deprivation in M-F increases the overlap in muscle mass with women but does not reverse it, statistically. The question of whether reassigned M-F can fairly compete with women depends on what degree of arbitrariness one wishes to accept, keeping in mind, for instance, that similar blood testosterone levels in men have profoundly different biologic effects on muscle properties, rendering competition in sports intrinsically a matter of how nature endows individuals for this competition.

Dilemma of Competitive Equality: Transgender vs Cisgender Athletes in Women's International Sports Competition

Equity in Play: Analyzing Legal and Ethical Views on Transgender Participation in Sports

Analyzing the intricacies of transgender athletes’ representation in competitive sports

Equality, Equity and Inclusion: Transgender Athletes' Participation in Competitive Sports - a New Era

‘Gender Verification Issues in Women’s Competitive Sports: An Ethical Critique of the IAAF DSD Regulation’

Contradiction or Cohesion? Tracing Questions of Protection and Fairness in Scientifically Driven Elite Sport Policies

Sport and Transgender People: A Systematic Review of the Literature Relating to Sport Participation and Competitive Sport Policies

Female Olympians’ voices: Female sports categories and International Olympic Committee Transgender guidelines

Intersexuality and Transgender Identity as a "Problem" of Participation in Sports Competitions

The gender gap in sport performance: equity influences equality.

Transgender Women in the Female Category of Sport: Perspectives on Testosterone Suppression and Performance Advantage

A Scoping Review of Transgender Policies in the 15 Most Commonly Played UK Professional Sports

The perspective of current and retired world class, elite and national athletes on the inclusion and eligibility of transgender athletes in elite sport

The International Olympic Committee framework on fairness, inclusion and nondiscrimination on the basis of gender identity and sex variations does not protect fairness for female athletes

Equality DanceSport doing transgender inclusivity in the United Kingdom: Cultural cisgenderism and transgender experiences

Transsexuals and competitive sports

Public Attitudes about Transgender Participation in Sports: The Roles of Gender, Gender Identity Conformity, and Sports Fandom

Gender Equality and Gender Difference in Team Coverage – Lessons From the Ice Hockey Rink

The End of Compulsory Gender Verification: Is It Progress for Inclusion of Women in Sports?

Gender Identity, Sports, and Affirmative Action: What’s Title IX Got To Do With It?

Integrating transwomen athletes into elite competition: The case of elite archery and shooting