Abstract:Understanding the biodiversity‐productivity relationships is a focal topic in ecology, but unravelling their reciprocal nature remains challenging. The authors demonstrate that higher‐resolution longitudinal data along with methods to control for a broader suite of confounding variables can be used to resolve reciprocal relationships. The authors highlight future data needs and methods that can help us to resolve biodiversity‐productivity relationships, crucial for reconciling a long‐running debate in ecology and ultimately, to understand how biodiversity and ecosystem functioning respond to global change. Relationships between plant biodiversity and productivity are highly variable across studies in managed grasslands, partly because of the challenge of accounting for confounding's and reciprocal relationships between biodiversity and productivity in observational data collected at a single point in time. Identifying causal effects in the presence of these challenges requires new analytical approaches and repeated observations to determine the temporal ordering of effects. Though rarely available, data collected at multiple time points within a growing season can help to disentangle the effects of biodiversity on productivity and vice versa. Here we advance this understanding using seasonal grassland surveys from 150 managed grassland sites repeated over 2 years, along with statistical methods that are relatively new in ecology, that aim to infer causal relationships from observational data. We compare our approach to common methods used in ecology, that is, mixed‐effect models, and to analyses that use observations from only one point in time within the growing seasons. We find that mixed models overestimated the effect of biodiversity on productivity by two standard errors as compared to our main models, which find no evidence for a strong positive effect. For the effect of productivity on biodiversity we found a negative effect using mixed models which was highly sensitive to the time at which the data was collected within the growing season. In contrast, our main models found no evidence for an effect. Conventional models overestimated the effects between biodiversity and productivity, likely due to confounding variables. Synthesis. Understanding the biodiversity‐productivity relationships is a focal topic in ecology, but unravelling their reciprocal nature remains challenging. We demonstrate that higher‐resolution longitudinal data along with methods to control for a broader suite of confounding variables can be used to resolve reciprocal relationships. We highlight future data needs and methods that can help us to resolve biodiversity‐productivity relationships, crucial for reconciling a long‐running debate in ecology and ultimately, to understand how biodiversity and ecosystem functioning respond to global change.

Productivity and sustainability influenced by biodiversity in grassland ecosystems

Linking plant diversity–productivity relationships to plant functional traits of dominant species and changes in soil properties in 15‐year‐old experimental grasslands

Biodiversity and ecosystem stability in a decade-long grassland experiment

Effects of plant diversity on productivity strengthen over time due to trait-dependent shifts in species overyielding

PLANT DIVERSITY, SOIL MICROBIAL COMMUNITIES, AND ECOSYSTEM FUNCTION: ARE THERE ANY LINKS?

Weak reciprocal relationships between productivity and plant biodiversity in managed grasslands

Clarifying the effect of biodiversity on productivity in natural ecosystems with longitudinal data and methods for causal inference

Relationships between species richness and biomass production are context dependent in grasslands differing in land-use and seed addition

Biodiversity Explains Maximum Variation in Productivity under Experimental Warming, Nitrogen Addition, and Grazing in Mountain Grasslands.

Environmental heterogeneity modulates the effect of plant diversity on the spatial variability of grassland biomass

Plant history and soil history jointly influence the selection environment for plant species in a long-term grassland biodiversity experiment

Species pool distributions along functional trade-offs shape plant productivity–diversity relationships

Plant Diversity Surpasses Plant Functional Groups and Plant Productivity as Driver of Soil Biota in the Long Term

The productivity-biodiversity relationship varies across diversity dimensions

BIODIVERSITY AND ECOSYSTEM PRODUCTIVITY:WHY IS THERE A DISCREPANCY IN THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN EXPERIMENTAL AND NATURAL ECOSYSTEMS?

Positive biodiversity-productivity relationship predominant in global forests

Cumulative nitrogen enrichment alters the drivers of grassland overyielding

Multiple facets of diversity effects on plant productivity: Species richness, functional diversity, species identity and intraspecific competition

Worldwide evidence of a unimodal relationship between productivity and plant species richness

Impacts of species richness on productivity in a large-scale subtropical forest experiment

Complementary effects of species and genetic diversity on productivity and stability of sown grasslands