The fog of war: development, conflict narratives, and civilian victimisation in Colombia
Clara VoyvodicSchool of Sociology,Politics,and International Studies,University of Bristol,Bristol,UKDr Clara Voyvodic Casabó is Senior Research Fellow at the University of Bristol in the School of Sociology,Politics,and International Studies (SPAIS),as well as the Chair of the Peace,Conflict,and Violence Research Group at the School. She holds a PhD in International Relations from the University of Oxford,a Masters in Criminology from the University of Glasgow – for which she was a Carnegie Scholar – as well as a first-class MA in International Relations from the University of St Andrews. She has professional experience in the international humanitarian and security sector,including human rights protection,anti-corruption monitoring,and fugitive investigation. Her research focuses on the impact of armed conflict,organised crime,and development on local order and civilian victimisation. She also researchers qualitative methods and ethics in fieldwork in conflict and contentious areas.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01436597.2024.2324969
2024-03-23
Third World Quarterly
Abstract:Conflict generates uncertainty and a supply of violent actors willing to contract their services to third parties that makes identifying motivation for civilian victimisation difficult. In this paper, I examine how elites not only have opportunities to capitalise on violence during war for developmental interests, but also take advantage of the fog of war to lump all cases of victimisation under a clear overarching narrative of political contestation rather than repression for economic interests. I build on the literature of developmental violence in conflict to assess two cases of dam construction by the Public Enterprises of Medellin (EPM) in Antioquia, Colombia between 1995 and 2018: Hidroituango and Porce II. I argue that civilians opposing the dams were associated with one of the armed groups in the territory and elites dismissed their victimisation as a product of competition between insurgents and counterinsurgents. This conflict narrative obscures other potential realities and precludes deeper investigation into the ambiguous motivations behind attacks, even as the victims themselves may challenge and present counternarratives of developmental violence.
development studies