Empty ethics: the problem with informed consent.

O. Corrigan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1046/J.1467-9566.2003.00369.X
2003-11-01
Abstract:Informed consent is increasingly heralded as an ethical panacea, a tool to counter autocratic and paternalistic medical practices. Debate about the implementation of informed consent is constricted and polarised, centring on the right of individuals to be fully informed and to freely choose versus an autocratic, paternalistic practice that negates individual choice. A bioethical framework, based on a principle-led form of reductive/deductive reasoning, dominates the current model of informed consent. Such a model tends to abstract the process of consent from its clinical and social setting. By fleshing out the social process involved whe patients and healthy volunteer subjects consent to take part in clinical drug trials, this paper attempts to address the problem arising from the current 'empty ethics' model. My arguments are substantiated by qualitative interview data drawn from a study I conducted on the process of consent as experienced by participants in clinical drug trials.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to solve the contradiction between complexity and efficiency in the protein - folding process, especially how to explain that proteins can find their correct three - dimensional structures within a reasonable time. Specifically, the article mainly explores the following issues: 1. **Levinthal's Paradox**: - The conformational space that proteins need to explore during the folding process is extremely large (growing exponentially). If these conformations are randomly searched, the time required is far beyond the biologically relevant time scale. Levinthal's Paradox points out that proteins must accelerate this process through specific paths or mechanisms. 2. **Application of the energy landscape theory**: - By introducing the concept of the statistical energy landscape, the kinetic and thermodynamic behaviors of protein folding are explained. The energy landscape theory regards protein folding as a complex potential energy surface, which contains multiple local minima and a global minimum. 3. **Distinguishing between general and specific folding mechanisms**: - Research whether proteins with different amino acid sequences follow a general folding path during the folding process, or whether each protein has its own unique folding path. This helps to understand which folding characteristics are universal and which are specific to individual proteins. 4. **Explaining experimental phenomena**: - Use the energy landscape theory to explain the phenomena observed in experiments, such as two - state folding, metastable folding intermediates, and the curvature of Arrhenius plots. These phenomena can be explained by different features of the energy landscape, such as smooth and rough energy landscapes. 5. **Predicting and simulating protein structures**: - Explore the application of the energy landscape theory in protein structure prediction, especially in molecular dynamics simulations and computational biology. By understanding the energy landscape, the folding path and final structure of proteins can be better predicted. ### Main contributions - **Unified framework**: This paper provides a unified framework that integrates different protein - folding theories (such as path - dependence, multi - path models, etc.) into a statistical physics framework based on the energy landscape. - **Quantitative analysis**: By quantitatively analyzing computer simulation data and experimental results, the effectiveness of the energy landscape theory is verified, and new insights into the protein - folding process are provided. - **Guiding experimental design**: Provide a theoretical basis for future experimental design and data analysis, helping researchers better understand and explain the complex behavior of protein folding. In summary, this paper solves the complexity problems involved in the protein - folding process by introducing the energy landscape theory, and provides new perspectives and tools for understanding the protein - folding mechanism.