Variability of the Content and Stock of Soil Organic Matter in Time and Space: An Analytical Review

N. B. Khitrov,D. A. Nikitin,E. A. Ivanova,M. V. Semenov
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1134/s106422932360207x
2023-12-09
Eurasian Soil Science
Abstract:The aim of this analytical review is to systematize information on the quantitative characteristics of variation in the content and stock of organic carbon (C org ) in soils. The review considers the estimates for validity and reproducibility of determined C org values, as well as the spatial variation and heterogeneity of C org at different hierarchical levels of the soil cover composition and their changes in time. The most powerful factor of C org changeability in soils is spatial variation. The absolute standard deviation and coefficient of variation for C org content and stock in soil shows the trend of an increase with the logarithm of the examined plot area. This trend is observed on the background of a wide range of the values of the indicators of spatial C org variation in each narrow range of the plot area, which leads to a high uncertainty of the estimates with an increase in the area coverage. Direct dry combustion is considered the preferable method among the methods used to determine C org content. This method gives valid (i.e., with the least biases) and well reproducible data. The indirect Tyurin and Walkley–Black methods systematically underestimate the C org content and their reproducibility is comparable to the amplitude of seasonal dynamics and minimum spatial variation indices within an elementary soil area. The estimates for the long-term trend of C org content require strict adherence to stringent monitoring conditions over the time intervals longer than 15 years. The spatial variation in C org stock is more pronounced as compared with C org content, which further increases the requirements to monitoring.
soil science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?