Abstract:Objective: To compare and contrast the duration and content of physician-patient interaction for patients presenting to an emergency department with problems of low acuity in 1990 and 2005 treated by different grades of physician. Methods: Observational study with data collection in May-July 1990 and May-July 2005. Patients identified at nurse triage as presenting with 'primary care' problems were allocated by time of arrival to senior house officers (1990, n=7; 2005, n=10), specialist registrars/staff grades (1990, n=4; 2005, n=7) or sessionally employed general practitioners (1990, n=8; 2005, n=12) randomly rostered to work in a consulting room that had a wall-mounted video camera. A stratified sample of 430 video-taped consultations (180 (42%) from 1990 and 250 (58%) from 2005) was analysed using the Roter Interaction Analysis System. Main outcome measures -- length of consultation; numbers of utterances of physician and patient talk related to building a relationship, data gathering, activating/partnering (i.e. actively encouraging the patient's involvement in decision-making), and patient education/counselling. Results: On average consultation length was 251s (95% CI for difference: 185-316) longer in 2005 than in 1990. The difference was especially marked for senior house officers (mean duration 385s in 1990 and 778s in 2005; 95% CI of difference: 286-518). All groups of physician showed increased communication related to activating and partnering and building a therapeutic relationship with the patient. While senior house officers demonstrated a greatly increased focus on data gathering, only general practitioners substantially increased the amount of talk centred on patient education and counselling; compared to senior house officers, the odds ratio for the number of such utterances included in consultations was 2.8 (95% CI: 1.4, 5.3). Conclusion: Although patient-centredness together with consultation length increased for all three physician groups over the duration of this study, senior house officers and specialist registrars/staff grades continued to place less emphasis on advice-giving and counselling than did general practitioners. The extent to which these observed changes in practice were determined by policy, management and training initiatives, and their impact on patient outcome, needs further study. Practice implications: Video-recording consultations is feasible in an acute hospital setting, and could be used to support training and workforce development. General practitioners can make a distinctive contribution to the workforce of emergency departments. Their consulting style differs from that of hospital physicians and may benefit patient care through a greater focus on patient education and counselling.

Differences in patient-physician communication between the emergency department and other departments in a hospital setting in Taiwan

The Physician-Patient Communication Behaviors Among Medical Specialists in a Hospital Setting

Factors influencing patients' experience of communication with the medical team of the emergency department

Application and main points of doctor-patient communication during clinicalpractice in Intensive Care Unit

Patient-Healthcare Worker Communication in Emergency Departments: Patient Perspectives

Several Problems in the Practice of Emergency Medicine

Emergency nurse practitioners and doctors consulting with patients in an emergency department: a comparison of communication skills and satisfaction

Chinese Minority Perceives the Doctor-Patient Relationship Differently: A Cultural and Economic Interpretation

Effective Healthcare Worker-Patient Communication in Hong Kong Accident and Emergency Departments

Nurse-Patient/Visitor Communication in the Emergency Department

Improving Patients' Experiences Communicating With Nurses and Providers in the Emergency Department

The influencing factors and countermeasures of nurse-patient communication in Emergency Room

Communication skills training from cognitive differences for medical incident between medical graduate students and patients

Improvement of Doctor-patient Communication by Hospital Administration

The patient, the doctor and the emergency department: a cross-sectional study of patient-centredness in 1990 and 2005

Investigation on Influencing Factors of Adverse Emergency Physician-Nurse Cooperation

Application of Progressive Doctor-patient Communication in Emergency ICU

Emergency Medical Staff's Perceptions on Cultural Value Difference-Based Teamwork Issues: A Phenomenological Study in China

Treatment experience about doctor-patient communication skills in dealing with key diseases in clinic of department of infectious diseases

Staying connected in the COVID-19 pandemic: a medical center’s experience to synchronize information across two branches of emergency department to enhance communication

Perceived quality of communication amongst outpatients in western and traditional Chinese medicine clinics in a Chinese population