How to assess a university campus planning — a case study based on students' spatio-temporal behavior

Weiwei Wang,Feng Zhen,Yang Cao,Yuyao Wang,Yagen Ou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13467581.2024.2358218

IF: 0.904

2024-05-29

Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering

Abstract:The planning of university campus directly impacts students' quality of study and living, and there is a considerable amount of research on campus planning assessment, most of which uses post-occupancy evaluation methods. This paper tries to propose a new comprehensive assessment method for campus planning, which collects spatio-temporal behavioral data of students in their daily life through GPS software, then assesses the actual effect of campus planning comprehensively by analyzing the spatio-temporal behavioral characteristics of students. This paper also verifies the reliability of the student behavior characteristics analysis through questionnaire and explores the possible biases. The results indicate that, in addition to significant advantages in reliability, accuracy, and comprehensive judgment, the proposed method can visually reflect specific issues existing within tangible campus spaces and their impact on student behavior. Therefore, it can provide practical and reliable evidence for the practice of campus planning renewal. This method used in this paper is also applicable to other fixed group living spaces within a certain scale, like communities and neighborhoods.

construction & building technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores a new method for evaluating university campus planning, with the core aim of addressing the issues present in existing campus planning evaluations and proposing a method that can more comprehensively and objectively assess the effectiveness of campus planning.

Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following issues:

1. **Limitations of traditional evaluation methods**: Existing campus planning evaluations mostly rely on static factors such as the built environment, physical space, building performance, and studies on student behavior patterns or sustainability. These methods often rely on Post-Occupancy Evaluation (POE) and similar approaches, which, while capable of reflecting the basic functional integrity of the campus, struggle to capture the actual usage of the campus by students and the dynamic relationship between students and campus planning.

2. **Subjectivity and inaccuracy**: Traditional evaluation methods are prone to subjective influence from the evaluators, lack accuracy in aspects such as behavior frequency and spatial location, and lack effectiveness and reliability.

3. **True reflection of student behavior**: To more accurately assess the effectiveness of campus planning, a method is needed that can objectively record students' actual behavior on campus, thereby reflecting the real impact of the existing built environment on student life.

To address the above issues, the paper proposes a new evaluation framework that comprehensively assesses the actual effectiveness of campus planning by collecting spatiotemporal behavior data of students. This method uses GPS software on smartphones to collect spatiotemporal behavior data of students in their daily campus life, then analyzes the spatiotemporal behavior characteristics of students through GIS software, and combines these with the spatial environment characteristics of the campus to achieve a comprehensive evaluation of the campus planning effectiveness.

Additionally, the paper verifies the effectiveness of the student behavior characteristics analysis through questionnaire surveys and explores potential biases. This method not only intuitively reveals problems in specific locations within the campus space but also provides practical and reliable evidence for improving campus planning. This evaluation method is also applicable to other fixed group living spaces of a certain scale, such as communities and neighborhoods.