Achieving win-win policy outcomes for water resource management and economic development: The experience of Chinese cities
Tongbin Yang,Yingming Zhu,Yujian Li,Bo Zhou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2021.02.006
IF: 8.921
2021-07-01
Sustainable Production and Consumption
Abstract:<p>Water resource management may restrict economic development, and a preference for economic development may weaken the effect of water resource management. The Water Eco-Civilization City (WEC) is a significant pilot policy in China, and is designed to achieve both effective water resource management and economic development. This study assessed possible win-win outcomes of this policy by applying a water eco-efficiency (WEE) perspective. First, a slacks-based measure (SBM) was used to calculate WEE. Then, a difference-in-differences (DID) strategy and mediating effect model were applied to examine whether and how the WEC policies improved WEE and achieved desired policy outcomes in cities. The panel dataset used for the study covered 275 prefecture-level cities from 2008 to 2017. The major findings were as follows: (1) The WEC policies achieved win-win outcomes in pilot cities, meaning it achieved both positive water resource management and economic outcomes; specifically, it contributed 48.63% of the total increase in WEE. (2) Three effective WEC policies realized win-win outcomes: upgrading the industrial structure; scaling up drainage infrastructure; and encouraging centralized wastewater treatment. Upgrading the industrial structure was the most effective policy. (3) WEC policy outcomes were heterogeneous under different city conditions. In cities with more abundant water resources, scaling up drainage infrastructures and encouraging centralized wastewater treatment were more effective. In cities with a larger industrial scale, the WEC policies could not achieve win-win outcomes, because it was not possible to upgrade the industrial structure or encourage centralized wastewater treatment. In cities with more intense wastewater regulations, upgrading the industrial structure and encouraging centralized wastewater treatment were more effective. These findings exemplify the policies that achieve win-win outcomes, and highlight the fact that governments should consider water resource abundance, industrial scale, and the current intensity of wastewater regulations before designing new policies.</p>
environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology