Abstract:Purpose: Civic education in the United States has received renewed attention in state-level policy making. Yet defining what citizenship education entails has been long-contested terrain. This study explores the extent to which recently adopted civic education state policies are consistent in policy messaging around desired civic outcomes and civic debt. Research Methods/Approach: This study utilized political discourse analysis to analyze all civic education state policies enacted between 2017 and 2020, which included 45 laws from 29 states, through an iterative process of open and focused coding. Findings: The vast majority of policies espoused civic republican goals, with varying degrees to which they addressed civic debt. Liberal citizenship discourses were found in less than one-fourth of policies, and critical discourses were entirely absent. Patterns emerged in civic discourses by state political identity, geographic location, and whether civic debt was addressed. Implications: Findings suggest congruence across state law in stating that the rising generation of citizens should learn about the foundations and function of government, yet a continued disconnect between marginalized youths' lived experiences of disenfranchisement and exclusion from the dominant narrative. The flood of state bills in 2021 seeking to limit the teaching of structural racism and the roots of inequalities seems to push back against "critical" policies that these findings show are not widespread. This calls for future research that examines whether these state-level trends continue amid ongoing battles over the teaching of civics and history in K–12 schools and how state-level civic discourses manifest in civics education policy classroom implementation.

Policy for Civic Reasoning

Refocusing Civic Education: Developing the Skills Young People Need to Engage in Democracy

Civic Education in a Time of Democratic Crisis

Civic Preparation of American Youth: Reflective Patriotism and Our Constitutional Democracy

Politics by Other Means: Civic Education in a Time of Controversy

Toward a Cohesive Union? Currents and Cleavages in State Civic Education Policy Discourses

“I Really Want to Do Something”: How Civic Education Activities Promote Thinking Toward Civic Purpose Among Early Adolescents

What Social Scientists Have Learned About Civic Education: A Review of the Literature

Can Civic and Moral Education Be Distinguished?

What kind of global citizen? A framework for best practices in world history civic education

Should Government Agencies Be Trusted? Developing Students’ Civic Narrative Competence Through Social Science Education

Civic education as an antidote to inequalities in political participation? New evidence from English secondary education

The Dilemmas of Americanism: Civic Education in the United States

The Changing Landscape: The Role of Civic Education on Political Efficacy Among Latina/os and Asian Americans

Ethics education in the study of public administration: Anchoring to civility, civics, social justice, and understanding government in democracy

Civic Thought and Leadership: A Higher Civics to Sustain American Constitutional Democracy

Preparing kindergarten students for future active citizens

Cultivating sprouts of benevolence: a foundational principle for curriculum in civic and multicultural education

Political learning by social engagement? Chances and risks for citizenship education

Civic action on social media: fostering digital media literacy and epistemic cognition in the classroom

A Systematic Review of the Last Decade of Civic Education Research in the United States