Abstract:This study was designed to evaluate healing following treatment of periodontal defects using 2 collagen barrier membranes with different degrees of cross-linking, and to compare the results to those following use of an expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) membrane. Horizontal, circumferential defects were created in mandibular premolar teeth of 6 beagle dogs, followed by placement of membranes and wound closure. Postoperative healing was monitored clinically for 6 months, at which time the animals were sacrificed and specimens were taken for histological examination. Clinical observations indicated that the highly cross-linked, slow-resorbing collagen membrane did not integrate with the tissues the way the less crosslinked, rapid-resorbing collagen did. Membrane exposure was typical for the slow-resorbing membrane in contrast to the rapid-resorbing membrane which remained covered. The inferiority of the slow-resorbing membrane was evident by the extensive clinical recession and the attachment level measurements taken at 6 months, and it was decided to omit this membrane from histometric analysis. Histological examination of root surfaces treated with rapid-resorbing collagen or ePTFE membranes revealed substantial reparative healing. The connective tissue repair amounted to 84% of the treated root surface height for the rapid-resorbing collagen and 53% for the ePTFE membrane (difference not statistically significant). However, the connective tissue repair to the rapid-resorbing collagen group root surfaces was often associated with a layer of ankylosis (44%, versus 8% of the ePTFE group). It appeared that much of the ankylotic response was initiated from the furcation area and extended around to the buccal and lingual surfaces. In addition, this study provided histological evidence that granulation tissue forming under clinically exposed and plaque contaminated ePTFE membranes can still result in connective tissue repair. It was concluded that the rapid-resorbing collagen membranes and the ePTFE membranes seem capable of stimulating periodontal connective tissue repair, whereas the slow-resorbing collagen membranes were unsuccessful in this effort, as seen in this dog model.

Healing potential of osteotomies of the nasal sinus in the dog

Maxillary Sinus Floor Elevation Without Bone Grafting Using An Animal Model

Sequential Fluorescent Labeling Observation of Maxillary Sinus Augmentation by a Tissue-engineered Bone Complex in Canine Model

Systematic Evaluation of A Tissue-Engineered Bone for Maxillary Sinus Augmentation in Large Animal Canine Model

A Comparative Study Of The Effect Of Bio-Oss((R)) In Combination With Concentrated Growth Factors Or Bone Marrow-Derived Mesenchymal Stem Cells In Canine Sinus Grafting

Role of Periosteum in Alveolar Bone Regeneration Comparing with Collagen Membrane in a Buccal Dehiscence Model of Dogs

Mechanical Tension-Stress in Alveolar Cleft Repaired With Autogenous Bone in Canine Models

Repair following treatment of circumferential periodontal defects in dogs with collagen and expanded polytetrafluoroethylene barrier membranes

Endo-sinus Bone Formation after Transalveolar Sinus Floor Elevation Without Grafting with Simultaneous Implant Placement: Histological and Histomorphometric Assessment in a Dog Model

Effects of the bilayer nano-hydroxyapatite/mineralized collagen-guided bone regeneration membrane on site preservation in dogs.

Comparison of Tissue-Engineered Bone from Different Stem Cell Sources for Maxillary Sinus Floor Augmentation: a Study in a Canine Model.

Ossification and Bone Regeneration in a Canine GBR Model, Part 1: Thick vs Thin Glycated Cross-Linked Collagen Devices

Guided tissue regeneration combined with osseous grafting in suprabony periodontal lesions. An experimental study in the dog

Effect of a collagen membrane enriched with fibronectin on guided tissue regeneration in dogs

Ridge Alterations following Socket Preservation Using a Collagen Membrane in Dogs

Ridge preservation of compromised extraction sockets applying a soft cortical membrane: A canine proof-of-principle evaluation

Alveolar Ridge Regeneration With Open Versus Closed Healing in Damaged Extraction Sockets: A Preclinical In Vivo Study

Systematic modification and evaluation of a canine model for elevation of the floor of the maxillary sinus.

Systematic Evaluation Of An Animal Model For Maxillary Sinus Floor Elevation With Immediate Implant

Comparative Histopathological Analysis of Nasal Osteotomy Techniques in a Rabbit Model

Bone Regeneration with Bilayer Bone Augmentation Technique for the Treatment of Dehiscence-Type Defects Around Implants: A Preliminary Study in Dogs