Abstract:It has long been assumed that ageing forests cease to accumulate carbon, and become carbon neutral. They are therefore not recognized for 'forest credits' in treaties such as the Kyoto Protocol. Now an extensive literature and database search for forest carbon-flux estimates shows that the net carbon balance of ageing forests is usually positive. The findings suggest that old-growth forests can continue to accumulate carbon, and that they contribute at least 10% of global net ecosystem productivity. Much of this carbon, even soil carbon, will move back to the atmosphere if these forests are disturbed, so it would make sense for carbon accounting rules to give credit for leaving old forests intact. A literature and database search for forest carbon flux estimates finds that in forests between 15 and 800 years of age net ecosystem productivity, the net carbon balance of the forest, is usually positive. These results demonstrate that old forests can continue to accumulate carbon, contrary to the long-standing view that old forests are carbon-neutral. Old-growth forests remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere1,2 at rates that vary with climate and nitrogen deposition3. The sequestered carbon dioxide is stored in live woody tissues and slowly decomposing organic matter in litter and soil4. Old-growth forests therefore serve as a global carbon dioxide sink, but they are not protected by international treaties, because it is generally thought that ageing forests cease to accumulate carbon5,6. Here we report a search of literature and databases for forest carbon-flux estimates. We find that in forests between 15 and 800 years of age, net ecosystem productivity (the net carbon balance of the forest including soils) is usually positive. Our results demonstrate that old-growth forests can continue to accumulate carbon, contrary to the long-standing view that they are carbon neutral. Over 30 per cent of the global forest area is unmanaged primary forest, and this area contains the remaining old-growth forests7. Half of the primary forests (6 × 108 hectares) are located in the boreal and temperate regions of the Northern Hemisphere. On the basis of our analysis, these forests alone sequester about 1.3 ± 0.5 gigatonnes of carbon per year. Thus, our findings suggest that 15 per cent of the global forest area, which is currently not considered when offsetting increasing atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations, provides at least 10 per cent of the global net ecosystem productivity8. Old-growth forests accumulate carbon for centuries and contain large quantities of it. We expect, however, that much of this carbon, even soil carbon9, will move back to the atmosphere if these forests are disturbed.

New ways for (in)validating the forest carbon neutrality hypothesis

Climate policies for carbon neutrality should not rely on the uncertain increase of carbon stocks in existing forests

The Key Role of Forest Disturbance in Reconciling Estimates of the Northern Carbon Sink

Biogeochemistry of a temperate forest nitrogen gradient.

Reversing the European Trend Toward a Declining Land Carbon Sink?

Old-growth Forests As Global Carbon Sinks

A neutral theory of plant carbon allocation

Can models adequately reflect how long-term nitrogen enrichment alters the forest soil carbon cycle?

Carbon Benefits from Forest Transitions Promoting Biomass Expansions and Thickening

CO2 Balance of Boreal, Temperate, and Tropical Forests Derived from a Global Database

Perspectives on the role of terrestrial ecosystems in the ‘carbon neutrality’ strategy

The Physiological Ecology of Carbon Science in Forest Stands

Ecological Perspectives of Carbon Neutrality

Carbon, climate, and natural disturbance: a review of mechanisms, challenges, and tools for understanding forest carbon stability in an uncertain future

Revaluating forest drought experiments according to future precipitation patterns, ecosystem carbon and decomposition rate responses: A meta-analysis

Disturbance-accelerated succession increases the production of a temperate forest

Reconstruction and attribution of the carbon sink of European forests between 1950 and 2000

Trading off nature for nature‐based solutions: The bioeconomics of forest management for wildlife, timber, and carbon

Perspectives on the Role of Terrestrial Ecosystems in The'carbon Neutrality'strategy

Controls of Initial Wood Decomposition on and in Forest Soils Using Standard Material

Fast-decaying plant litter enhances soil carbon in temperate forests but not through microbial physiological traits