Student perceptions of inclusive pedagogy in undergraduate STEM classrooms

Caley J. Valdez,Nicole C. Kelp,Caley J. ValdezNicole C. Kelp1Department of Microbiology,Immunology,and Pathology,Colorado State University,Fort Collins,Colorado,USA,Sarah Fankhauser

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1128/jmbe.00097-23

2023-10-25

Journal of Microbiology and Biology Education

Abstract:Journal of Microbiology &Biology Education, Ahead of Print.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Using Student Narratives to Characterize Inclusive Pedagogy and Inclusive Classrooms in Higher Education

Christina Shane-Simpson,Rita Obeid,Jacklin Chang,Dave Ki,Emma Arlt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/00986283241269434

2024-09-22

Teaching of Psychology

Abstract:Teaching of Psychology, Ahead of Print. BackgroundInclusive teaching practices have become essential to support student success in our diverse college classrooms. Given the variations in how inclusivity is translated into teaching behavior, it is important for us to examine how our students define and perceive inclusivity.ObjectiveThe main goal of this qualitative study is to define and characterize inclusive classroom communities and inclusive pedagogy practices through the voices of current college students.MethodParticipants included 365 undergraduate students from a public and a private university. Students responded to open-ended questions about inclusive teaching practices, characteristics of an inclusive classroom, inclusive teaching behaviors, and inclusive behaviors of classmates.ResultsParticipants highlighted that inclusive teaching impacts all students while noting that teaching practice may differentially impact specific student populations, including students with disabilities and students of color. Students also identified specific instructor and classmate characteristics and behaviors that contribute to an inclusive (or non-inclusive) classroom community.ConclusionThis study highlights students' views on what characterizes inclusive teaching. Participants underscored the importance of respectful and welcoming environments both from faculty and peers.Teaching ImplicationsFindings offer practical implications for instructors as they create and support an inclusive classroom, particularly as it pertains to teacher and student characteristics and behaviors.

psychology, multidisciplinary,education & educational research
An Exploratory Mixed-Methods Analysis of Factors Contributing to Students' Perceptions of Inclusion in Introductory STEM Courses

Alessandra M York,Kathryn G Miller,Michael J Cahill,Mindy A Bernstein,Ashton M Barber,Hannah E Blomgren,Regina F Frey

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.23-04-0055

Abstract:In this exploratory mixed-methods analysis of students' perceptions of inclusion in introductory STEM courses for STEM majors, we asked students to rate inclusion in their class and to provide an open-text explanation of their rating. Analyzing 1930 qualitative responses resulted in a codebook containing academic, identity, and nonspecific categories. The majority of responses (>80%) cited academic factors such as interactions between students and instructors or course elements and policies. Most academic responses aligned with evidence-based teaching practices fostering inclusion, describing a range of strategies and policies instructors can implement to increase students' perceptions of inclusion. A small number of student responses indicated that their perception of the required knowledge background for the course impacted course inclusivity. Few differences in frequency distributions were found between subgroups examined (gender, race and ethnicity, self-reported inclusion score, and discipline). Additionally, tracking a subset of students (135) across three courses revealed that most (80%) cited different factors influencing their perception of inclusion in each course. This suggests students' perceptions of inclusive practices are complex, and most students recognize multiple factors that influence their inclusion. Overall, our findings suggest instructors can significantly influence students' perceptions of inclusion by using multiple inclusive teaching strategies and course policies.
Undergraduates' lived experience of project-/problem-based learning in introductory biology

Audrey Webster,Alana Metcalf,Lauren Kelly,Ave Bisesi,Miranda Marnik-Said,Carol Colbeck,Robert Marine,Marcelo Vinces,Amy Campbell,Taylor Allen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1152/advan.00042.2021

2022-03-01

Abstract:Recommendations for enhancing scientific literacy, inclusivity, and the ecosystem for innovation call for transitioning from teacher-centered to learner-centered science classrooms, particularly at the introductory undergraduate level. Yet little is documented about the challenges that undergraduates perceive in such classrooms and the students' ways of navigating them. Via mixed methods, we studied undergraduates' lived experience in one form of learner-centered teaching, hybrid project-/problem-based learning (PBL), in introductory organismal biology at a baccalaureate institution. Prominent in qualitative analyses of student interviews and written reflections were undergraduates' initial expectation of and longing for an emphasis on facts and transmission of them. The prominence diminished from semester's middle to end, as students came to value developing ideas, solving problems collaboratively, and engaging in deep ways of learning. Collaboration and personal resources such as belief in self emerged as supports for these shifts. Quantitative analyses corroborated that PBL students transformed as learners, moving toward informed views on the nature of science, advancing in multivariable causal reasoning, and more frequently adopting deep approaches for learning than students in lecture-based sections. The qualitative and quantitative findings portray the PBL classroom as an intercultural experience in which culture shock yields over time to acceptance in a way supported by students' internal resources and peer collaboration. The findings have value to those seeking to implement PBL and other complex-learning approaches in a manner responsive to the lived experience of the learner.
Incorporating Sex-Diverse and Gender-Inclusive Perspectives in Higher Education Biology Courses

Breanna N Harris,A Kelsey Lewis,Sam L Sharpe,Teri J Orr,Christopher T Martine,Chloe C Josefson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/icb/icae054

2024-06-03

Abstract:Inclusive teaching is teaching in a way that reaches all students in the classroom; this is beneficial for everyone and particularly for those with minoritized identities. Instructors play a critical role in scaffolding how students are exposed to and learn science content in the classroom. In this manuscript we discuss how biology instructors can make their classrooms more inclusive with regard to sex and gender diversity content. Many topics in biology are based on androcentric, heteronormative, and oppressive framing, even though those lenses are more reflective of our own history and culture than they are of the diversity we see in nature. Here, we summarize information presented in the SICB 2024 workshop titled "Incorporating sex diversity and gender inclusivity in biology undergraduate classrooms" and provide instructors with a) rationale for why inclusive teaching matters, b) guidance on how to challenge unscientific views and make their curricula more sex-diverse and gender inclusive, and c) practical and easy-to-implement strategies for discussing "contentious" topics in the classroom. Incorporation of this material will be beneficial for students, for science and medicine, and for accurately representing the diversity found across the tree of life.
Despite Similar Perceptions and Attitudes, Postbaccalaureate Students Outperform in Introductory Biology and Chemistry Courses

Erin E. Shortlidge,Liz Rain-Griffith,Chloe Shelby,Gwendolyn P. Shusterman,Jack Barbera

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.17-12-0289

2019-03-01

CBE—Life Sciences Education

Abstract:Embedding active learning is a common mechanism for meeting science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) education reform goals. Researchers have identified student benefits from such strategies, yet these benefits may not be universal for all students. We sought to identify how students at a nontraditional university perceive introductory biology and chemistry courses, and whether perceptions relate to course type, performance, or student status. We surveyed students ( n = 601) using open-ended prompts regarding their perceptions of factors that impact their learning and interest, and about specific learning strategies. Generally, students did not differ in what influenced their learning or interest in course content, and students mostly perceived active learning positively. Attitudes toward active learning did not correlate to final course scores. Despite similar perceptions and attitudes, performance differed significantly among student groups—postbaccalaureates outperformed all others, and traditional-age students outperformed non-traditional-age students. We found that, even with active learning, underrepresented minority students underperformed compared to their peers, yet differentially benefited from nonsummative course factors. Although students generally perceive classroom environments similarly, undetected factors are influencing performance among student groups. Gaining a better understanding of how classroom efforts impact all of our students will be key to moving beyond supposing that active learning simply “works.”
Pedagogical knowledge for active-learning instruction in large undergraduate biology courses: a large-scale qualitative investigation of instructor thinking

Anna Jo J. Auerbach,Tessa C. Andrews

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40594-018-0112-9

IF: 5.789

2018-04-12

International Journal of STEM Education

Abstract:BackgroundThough active-learning instruction has the potential to positively impact the preparation and diversity of STEM graduates, not all instructors are able to achieve this potential. One important factor is the teacher knowledge that instructors possess, including their pedagogical knowledge. Pedagogical knowledge is the knowledge about teaching and learning that is not topic-specific, such as knowledge of learning theory, classroom management, and student motivation. We investigated the pedagogical knowledge that 77 instructors who report implementing active-learning instruction used as they analyzed video clips of lessons in large active-learning biology courses. We used qualitative content analysis, and drew on cognitive and sociocultural perspectives of learning, to identify and characterize the pedagogical knowledge instructors employed. We used the collective thinking of these instructors to generate a framework of pedagogical knowledge for active-learning instruction in large undergraduate biology courses.ResultsWe identified seven distinct components of pedagogical knowledge, as well as connections among these components. At the core of their thinking, participants evaluated whether instruction provided opportunities for students to generate ideas beyond what was presented to them and to engage in scientific practices. They also commonly considered student motivation to engage in this work and how instruction maximized equity among students. Participants noticed whether instructors monitored and responded to student thinking in real-time, how instruction prompted metacognition, and how links were built between learning tasks. Participants also thought carefully about managing the logistics of active-learning lessons.ConclusionsInstructors who report using active-learning instruction displayed knowledge of principles of how people learn, practical knowledge of teaching strategies and behaviors, and knowledge related to classroom management. Their deep knowledge of pedagogy suggests that active-learning instruction requires much more than content knowledge built through training in the discipline, yet many college STEM instructors have little or no training in teaching. Further research should test this framework of pedagogical knowledge in different instruction contexts, including different STEM disciplines. Additional research is needed to understand what teacher knowledge is critical to effective active-learning instruction and how the development of this knowledge is best facilitated. Achieving widespread improvement in undergraduate STEM education will likely require transforming our approach to preparing and supporting undergraduate instructors.

education & educational research,education, scientific disciplines
“Treat me like a person, rather than another number”: university student perceptions of inclusive classroom practices

Sandra L. Faulkner,Wendy K. Watson,Madison A. Pollino,Jaclyn R. Shetterly

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03634523.2020.1812680

2020-09-07

Communication Education

Abstract:Using Feminist Participatory Action Research, graduate and undergraduate students at a midsized, midwestern public university collaborated with investigators on welcoming and inclusive practices in the classroom through focus-group discussions. The research team conducted six focus-group sessions with 39 students from marginalized communities about how instructors can include and center marginalized and intersecting identities based on age, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, nationality, ability, and socioeconomic status in face-to-face and online classrooms. Discussions centered around instructor behavior and characteristics, what instructors did before and during class interactions, and the teaching materials they created that led to feelings of being welcomed and included. The relationship between students and instructors was paramount, and instructors who used more immediate and supportive communication behaviors were seen as more welcoming and inclusive. A welcoming and inclusive classroom means centering student experiences, identities, and concerns, being a reflexive and responsive instructor, and focusing on the interpersonal relationship between instructor and students. We discuss our findings and suggest best practices for inclusive pedagogy.
Pedagogical tools designed to promote engagement and active learning in the biomedical sciences and allied health disciplines

Mark F. O'Brien

Abstract:Perceiving students, science students especially, as mere consumers of facts and information belies the importance of a need to engage them with the principles underlying those facts and is counter-intuitive to the facilitation of knowledge and understanding. Traditional didactic lecture approaches need a re-think if student classroom engagement and active learning are to be valued over fact memorisation and fact recall. In our undergraduate biomedical science programs across Years 1, 2 and 3 in the Faculty of Health at QUT, we have developed an authentic learning model with an embedded suite of pedagogical strategies that foster classroom engagement and allow for active learning in the sub-discipline area of medical bacteriology. The suite of pedagogical tools we have developed have been designed to enable their translation, with appropriate fine-tuning, to most biomedical and allied health discipline teaching and learning contexts. Indeed, aspects of the pedagogy have been successfully translated to the nursing microbiology study stream at QUT. The aims underpinning the pedagogy are for our students to: (1) Connect scientific theory with scientific practice in a more direct and authentic way, (2) Construct factual knowledge and facilitate a deeper understanding, and (3) Develop and refine their higher order flexible thinking and problem solving skills, both semi-independently and independently. The mindset and role of the teaching staff is critical to this approach since for the strategy to be successful tertiary teachers need to abandon traditional instructional modalities based on one-way information delivery. Face-to-face classroom interactions between students and lecturer enable realisation of pedagogical aims (1), (2) and (3). The strategy we have adopted encourages teachers to view themselves more as expert guides in what is very much a student-focused process of scientific exploration and learning. Specific pedagogical strategies embedded in the authentic learning model we have developed include: (i) interactive lecture-tutorial hybrids or lectorials featuring teacher role-plays as well as class-level question-and-answer sessions, (ii) inclusion of “dry” laboratory activities during lectorials to prepare students for the wet laboratory to follow, (iii) real-world problem-solving exercises conducted during both lectorials and wet laboratory sessions, and (iv) designing class activities and formative assessments that probe a student’s higher order flexible thinking skills. Flexible thinking in this context encompasses analytical, critical, deductive, scientific and professional thinking modes. The strategic approach outlined above is designed to provide multiple opportunities for students to apply principles flexibly according to a given situation or context, to adapt methods of inquiry strategically, to go beyond mechanical application of formulaic approaches, and to as much as possible self-appraise their own thinking and problem solving. The pedagogical tools have been developed within both workplace (real world) and theoretical frameworks. The philosophical core of the pedagogy is a coherent pathway of teaching and learning which we, and many of our students, believe is more conducive to student engagement and active learning in the classroom. Qualitative and quantitative data derived from online and hardcopy evaluations, solicited and unsolicited student and graduate feedback, anecdotal evidence as well as peer review indicate that: (i) our students are engaging with the pedagogy, (ii) a constructivist, authentic-learning approach promotes active learning, and (iii) students are better prepared for workplace transition.

Medicine,Biology,Education,Computer Science,Psychology
Practice-Based Teacher Education Benefits Graduate Trainees and Their Students Through Inclusive and Active Teaching Methods

Shelley Stromholt,Benjamin Wiggins,Bailey Von der Mehden

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41979-023-00109-6

2023-10-16

Journal for STEM Education Research

Abstract:Abstract The next generations of science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) workers are being trained in college and university classrooms by a workforce of instructors who learn pedagogical practice largely on the job. While inclusive instructional practices and their impacts are increasingly well-studied, this training is difficult to instill within the professional development that most STEM professors receive before teaching their students. The Science Teaching Experience Program for Upcoming PhDs (STEP-UP) at the University of Washington was built to prepare future professors for inclusive excellence by guiding them through the literature in education research and providing them a space to practice active and inclusive teaching techniques. This study of STEP-UP uses a design-based approach to understand graduate trainee and undergraduate perceptions of the most salient aspects and outcomes of the program. Our study found that trainees used opportunities to practice inclusive teaching methods with a cohort of their peers, and crucially that these methods were evident in trainee-taught courses through multiple lines of evidence. STEP-UP-trained instructors used inclusive teaching strategies that helped students to feel socioemotionally supported. This study offers a model program that fosters inclusion and equity in undergraduate STEM classrooms through improving teaching professional development for graduate students.
Teachers’ roles and identities in student-centered classrooms

Leslie S. Keiler

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40594-018-0131-6

IF: 5.789

2018-09-14

International Journal of STEM Education

Abstract:BackgroundStudents and teachers in twenty-first century STEM classrooms face significant challenges in preparing for post-secondary education, career, and citizenship. Educators have advocated for student-centered instruction as a way to face these challenges, with multiple programs emerging to shape and define such contexts. However, the ways to support teachers as they transition into non-traditional teaching must be developed. The purpose of this study is to explore the impacts on educators of teaching in student-centered, peer-mediated STEM classrooms and preparing student peer leaders for their roles in these classes. Research questions examined how teachers think about themselves as they implement student-centered pedagogy, the difficulties they face as their roles and identities shift, and the ways they grow or resist growth. Qualitative research conducted at two urban secondary schools documents the diverse experiences and responses of teachers in an innovative, student-centered STEM instructional program. The experiences and perceptions of 13 STEM teachers illuminate the possibilities and challenges for teachers in student-centered classrooms.ResultsAll participating teachers described multiple benefits of teaching in a student-centered classroom and differences from traditional classrooms. Their transitions to this type of teaching fell into three major categories based upon past identities and current beliefs. Some teachers found the pedagogy consistent with preexisting identities and embraced it without radical change to their concepts of teaching. They described ways in which the model helped them become the teachers they had always wanted to be. Other teachers, who initially identified as deliverers of STEM content, had more difficult experiences adjusting to student-centered instruction. In one case, a teacher resisted change and exited the program, maintaining her identity and deciding not to become student-centered. Other participating teachers made dramatic shifts in their identities in order to implement the program. These teachers described significant learning curves as they shared responsibility for student learning with student leaders.ConclusionsThis study suggests that radically changing the learning environment can affect teachers’ identities and their approaches to teaching in predictable ways that can inform teacher education and professional development programs for STEM teachers, maximizing the success of teachers as they implement student-centered pedagogy.
Instructional Behaviors Affecting Student Attitudes Towards Science

Hope M. Sasway,Angela M. Kelly

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10668926.2020.1719937

2020-01-30

Community College Journal of Research and Practice

Abstract:Community colleges are viewed as essential in the preparation of skilled science professionals in the U.S., and research regarding instructor impacts on student attitudes toward science are timely and relevant. This study explored specific instructor characteristics and pedagogical behaviors and their influence student engagement, confidence, and motivation to study science. A phenomenological approach was employed with elements of grounded theory. Data were collected from 12 community college students through semi-structured interviews. An explanatory framework for instructor characteristics that affected students' academic attitudes focused upon engagement and confidence. Students' impressions of instructors' behaviors and attitudes reinforced the complexity of factors that affected their motivation. Instructors played a crucial role in building confidence, making disciplinary relevance explicit, and maintaining interest in science. Students valued instructors who were knowledgeable, caring, accessible, encouraging, and democratic. Students appreciated those who promoted a growth mind-set and autonomy, yet were still available as a supportive individuals. Future interventions should be implemented to address issues with the science course interest of community college students, and impacts on confidence and persistence. Informing instructors and policy makers that improvements in community college teaching techniques and support structures can enhance science attitudes is essential in students persisting in the pipeline, joining the STEM workforce, or transferring to four-year colleges. Understanding community college student characteristics can lead to customization of methods, objectives, and supportive policies to meet student needs, which may provide a well-equipped talent resource for participation in STEM careers.
Analysis of Interdisciplinary STEM Lessons Generated by Pre-Service and Inservice Teachers in the United States

Mónica Arnal-Palacián,Janelle M. Johnson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5430/jct.v12n6p1

2023-10-06

Journal of Curriculum and Teaching

Abstract:This study views STEM as a space with the potential to dismantle the narrow disciplinary silos that have led to inequitable gaps in achievement. Responding to the latest recommendations for teachers from NCTM and NSTA, this study aims to examine the instructional design of secondary mathematics and science pre-service teachers in an interdisciplinary STEM lesson about a pandemic. Starting with two images, teachers are asked to design the associated activities that they would implement in the classroom. Researchers utilized a qualitative methodology based on the categories of the 5E Model: Engage, Explore, Explain, Elaborate and Evaluate. The findings highlight responses to each of the 5E factors are very mixed. Teaching strategies consisting of posing questions predominate, promoting the Engage factor; while the Explore factor is barely considered, which could hinder the incorporation of group skills and critical thinking. This study offers a pathway on how to assess the professional learning of novice teachers following the 5E model through a contextualized activity with bacterial growth.
Increasing Awareness of Inclusive STEM Education through a College-Level Student Research Group

Sami Kahn,Tiffany Agyarko,Grace Lanouette,Sean Lee,Courteney Wiredu,,,,,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.14448/jsesd.13.0014

2021-12-15

Abstract:The under representation of persons with disabilities in STEM reflects not only a moral failing in society’s commitment to equity but also a practical dilemma as science benefits from the contributions of people with diverse perspectives. While teacher education programs attempt to address equity at the K-12 level, societal biases and misconceptions about who is “able” in science present persistent barriers for people with disabilities throughout the STEM pipeline, in higher education, employment, and beyond. How can we ensure that students with disabilities will encounter professors, employers, coworkers, and peers who are supportive of their efforts in STEM? To address this question, this article describes the experience of a college administrator and four students who collaboratively conducted a literature review on inclusive STEM education during the summer of 2020. While the goal of this project was to provide meaningful summer learning opportunities and employment for students during COVID-19 while simultaneously providing research support for the administrator, project outcomes suggest that the college students, none of whom were education majors, gained understanding and appreciation of the issues surrounding inclusive STEM education while also developing expertise in the literature review process. We suggest that this project represents a successful teaching technique that can be used in higher education, including teacher education programs, to contribute to the development of future leaders, educators, and citizens who are aware of, engaged with, and supportive of quality inclusive STEM education and opportunities for all.

English Else
Inquiry-Based Teaching in the College Classroom: The Nontraditional Student

Daniel A. Kiernan,Christine Lotter

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1525/abt.2019.81.7.479

2019-09-01

The American Biology Teacher

Abstract:Science departments in higher education have been adjusting their curricula to include more inquiry-based instruction, and research on inquiry-based teaching at the collegiate level has been increasing. However, more data are needed regarding the effectiveness of inquiry-based pedagogy in improving students' conceptual understanding and attitudes toward science. The investigation described here was focused on nontraditional students taking non-science-major science courses. The goal was to compare students' attitudes toward science before and after taking an inquiry-based or a traditional science course. The hypothesis that the inquiry-based course would significantly generate a more positive attitude toward science was supported. Nontraditional students' perceptions of an effective science curriculum were also explored. Students' perceptions were very positive regarding inquiry-based learning; however, those who had not been previously taught through inquiry-based methods had reserved perceptions of this teaching approach. Regardless of the course they were enrolled in, students agreed overall that an effective science curriculum includes three common themes: connection, interaction, and application.
Multimedia Characteristics, Student Relationships, and Teaching Behaviors Predict Perceptions of an Inclusive Classroom Across Course Delivery Format

Christina Shane-Simpson,Rita Obeid,Manna Prescher

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/00986283221117621

2022-11-10

Teaching of Psychology

Abstract:Teaching of Psychology, Ahead of Print. Background: Student perceptions of inclusion have been predicted by rapport, and belongingness in face-to-face courses, although these relationships have not been studied across course delivery formats. Objective: This study clarified relationships among course multimedia characteristics, student–professor rapport, instructor and student presence, classroom climate, quality of teaching behaviors, and perceptions of an inclusive classroom in varied course delivery formats. Method: A total of 479 students from two universities completed an online survey assessing their course delivery format, multimedia characteristics, rapport, instructor and student presence, classroom climate, teaching behaviors, and perceptions of an inclusive classroom. Results: Students' perceptions of inclusion were predicted by course multimedia characteristics (e.g., videos), student–professor rapport, instructor presence, course structure, course clarity, student connectedness, and the quality of teaching behaviors. Conclusion: Inclusive classrooms reflect a myriad of instructor-, student-, and classroom-level characteristics and behaviors. However, the predictive value of these characteristics can change based on the course delivery format. Teaching Implications: Faculty professional development opportunities for inclusive pedagogy should include skill development for course design (multimedia characteristics, structure), professor–student rapport-building and classroom community building, and high-quality teaching behaviors that align with specific course delivery formats.

psychology, multidisciplinary,education & educational research
An Undergraduate Introduction to Physiology Course as an Opportunity to Address Diversity, Equity and Inclusion in Biomedical Science

Erin Rhinehart

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1096/fasebj.2022.36.s1.r4938

2022-05-01

The FASEB Journal

Abstract:If you asked someone to conjure an image in their mind of a scientist, most people envision someone who roughly resembles Albert Einstein. This is largely because we are constantly bombarded with consistent, stereotyped images about what type of person “does science”. In most science courses and textbooks, the people given credit for major scientific advancements are typically white males. In fact, if you search the internet for lists of the most influential or famous scientists, the top ones listed are almost exclusively white males. Whether or not this lack of diverse representations of scientists registers consciously, the impact of this messaging about the types of people who work in science is clear and consistent. Therefore, it is important that STEM faculty recognize the impact of this messaging and develop mechanisms to combat it, especially considering the increasingly diverse array of postsecondary students interested in STEM majors. The first opportunity to combat this dominant narrative should occur on the first day of class by focusing on diversity and inclusion statements included in the syllabus in conjunction with the collaborative development of agreed upon social norms and expectations. In addition, assignments that allow students to connect with and recognize the contributions of non‐stereotypical scientists help to provide concrete examples that are likely to be effective at countering the dominant narrative that the quintessential scientist is a white male. Therefore, I added a Physiologist biography assignment to my undergraduate Introduction to Physiology course with the objective of providing multiple examples throughout the course of the semester that counter scientist stereotypes. For the assignment, students selected a scientist to research from a curated list that included only women and minority physiologists. The assignment required that they write a paper and give an oral presentation to the class about the scientist’s personal life, career trajectory and scientific contributions along with a discussion about how the student related to the scientist personally. To assess the impact of the assignment on student notions of scientist stereotypes and overall scientist relatability, we conducted a pre‐ and post‐course survey, which indicated a significant shift in student biases of scientists being predominantly white and male. Focus group assessment revealed themes indicating that the assignment also improved student identification with people in science‐related careers. Therefore, this pedagogical intervention appears to be beneficial as a step toward creating a more inclusive STEM educational environment.

cell biology,biochemistry & molecular biology,biology
Facilitating Preservice Elementary Science Teachers’ Shift from Learner to Teacher of Engineering Design-Based Science Teaching

Brenda M. Capobianco,Jeffrey Radloff,Jenna Clingerman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10763-021-10193-y

2021-06-28

International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education

Abstract:The role of engineering in science and mathematics education continues to emerge as a contributing factor to improving STEM education. Efforts across different countries include the integration of engineering in K-12 curriculum, after school programs, and inservice teacher professional development. Only recently have science teacher educators begun to introduce engineering in science teacher preparation programs. By incorporating novel curriculum and design-related experiences, we can begin to explore how preservice teachers not only learn about engineering, but more importantly, learn how to teach science using engineering design. In this study, we explore different ways 45 elementary preservice science teachers characterize and construct new understandings about engineering design-based science teaching. Data were gathered via self-interviews and reflective narratives. Data analysis entailed systematic and consistent open coding across transcripts. Document analysis served as a means of triangulation, reinforcing and reaffirming claims corroborated through the analysis of interview data. Using the teacher as learner framework, we contend that preservice teachers, when engaged in an engineering design-based methods course, demonstrate positive shifts from being learners to teachers of science by embodying the participatory, performative, and experiential nature of engineering design. To support preservice teacher development, we propose that teacher education programs incorporate engineering design-based learning experiences throughout teacher preparation rather than in a single semester or year. This means integrating more and earlier opportunities for preservice teachers to develop and apply their understandings of engineering design and design teaching, potentially leading to earlier shifts and increased design-based pedagogical understandings.

education & educational research
Teaching the way I wish I was taught: Design and implementation of a class on historically excluded and underrepresented scientists

Kathryn C. A. Milligan‐McClellan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/jcp.31352

2024-06-29

Journal of Cellular Physiology

Abstract:As the first Inupiaq person to earn a PhD in microbiology, I learned the hard way that groups of people have been excluded from science, technology, engineering and mathematics in the United States since the first University was built by Black and Indigenous slaves. Students from historically excluded and underrepresented (HEU) backgrounds typically do not see themselves in textbooks, conferences, or classrooms, especially in science, technology, engineering, mathematics and medicine (STEMM) fields. Similarly, students from these backgrounds and non‐excluded backgrounds typically do not understand the history or consequences of exclusion. Here I describe the development and implementation of a class that teaches undergraduate students about the current state of diversity in STEMM jobs in the US, the history of exclusion that resulted in a deficit of people from various backgrounds, the consequences of excluding these people from research specifically, current leaders in research from HEU backgrounds, and how to implement changes. The students are taught how to communicate their findings in oral and written communication to various audiences. Based on decades of experiences, discussions, readings, and more, I teach students the reasons there are so few people from HEU backgrounds in academia and in STEMM specifically, and what can be done at the University level to ensure that people from all backgrounds are represented in STEMM. In this way, I teach students what I wish I had been taught decades ago.

cell biology,physiology
Perspectives on Active Learning: Challenges for Equitable Active Learning Implementation

Jocelyn Elizabeth Nardo,Natalie C. Chapman,Eli Yuan Shi,Carl Wieman,Shima Salehi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jchemed.1c01233

IF: 3.208

2022-03-02

Journal of Chemical Education

Abstract:Studies suggest that active learning positively impacts the student learning experience. However, the supporting data are mostly aggregated across different demographic groups, and hence little is known about equity in active learning implementation and how it may vary across diverse populations and different instructional components. This perspectives article offers ideas for how introductory chemistry instructors can foster both equitable and active learning implementation for all students. Semistructured interviews with students from diverse backgrounds have revealed barriers to equity in the different components of an active learning chemistry course: outside-classroom preparation, inside-classroom activities, and feedback and assessment. Recommendations for addressing these barriers are also provided based on the student interviews and from the literature. The findings are likely applicable to all science disciplines.

chemistry, multidisciplinary,education, scientific disciplines
An exploration of the relationship between active learning and student motivation in STEM: a mixed methods study

Vicki Stieha,Brittnee Earl,Harrisen Hagens,Meagan Haynes,Amy Ulappa,Laura Bond,Julia Thom Oxford

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1152/advan.00247.2022

2024-09-01

Abstract:Much of the research on science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) students' motivation measures the relationship between student motivation and academic outcomes, focusing on the student's mindset. Our mixed-methods research takes a different approach and considers the relationship between student motivation and instructional practices. Teaching practices and student motivation were analyzed simultaneously in undergraduate Biology classes using a self-determination theory-based survey to measure students' motivation during courses that were observed using the Classroom Observation Protocol for Undergraduate STEM (COPUS), and observation notes were collected to document instructor and student behaviors. Quantitative data were used to differentiate students' motivational levels, and qualitative data were collected to describe how instructors use specific teaching practices. The results provide a lens into how students' intrinsic motivation varies alongside the instructional practices and interactions in these classes. We found a correlation between higher levels of student motivation in interactive lectures and student-centered teaching profiles. This study highlights how the same practice can be implemented by multiple instructors with varying student motivation scores, pointing out the importance of fidelity to evidence-based instructional practice methods. The results of this study are discussed in the context of published empirical studies examining evidence-based instructional practices that are conceptually supportive of autonomy, competence, and relatedness. Active learning practices observed in this study correlated to positive learning outcomes are discussed and may serve as a guide for instructors interested in implementing specific active learning practices. Recommendations for instructors and departments that are interested in flexible methods to monitor progress toward active learning practices in biology and other STEM disciplines by combining the COPUS and self-determination survey results are presented.NEW & NOTEWORTHY This study uses a novel combination of instruments to describe students' intrinsic motivation in response to teaching practices. Findings demonstrate that active learning methods may support higher student motivation. Recommendations drawn from the study include using a variety of active learning methods, using evidence-based instructional methods with fidelity, and monitoring the students' affective response to those methods. Alignment of active learning practices to the components of self-determination may result in higher quality student motivation in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) courses.

Student perceptions of inclusive pedagogy in undergraduate STEM classrooms

Using Student Narratives to Characterize Inclusive Pedagogy and Inclusive Classrooms in Higher Education

An Exploratory Mixed-Methods Analysis of Factors Contributing to Students' Perceptions of Inclusion in Introductory STEM Courses

Undergraduates' lived experience of project-/problem-based learning in introductory biology

Incorporating Sex-Diverse and Gender-Inclusive Perspectives in Higher Education Biology Courses

Despite Similar Perceptions and Attitudes, Postbaccalaureate Students Outperform in Introductory Biology and Chemistry Courses

Pedagogical knowledge for active-learning instruction in large undergraduate biology courses: a large-scale qualitative investigation of instructor thinking

“Treat me like a person, rather than another number”: university student perceptions of inclusive classroom practices

Pedagogical tools designed to promote engagement and active learning in the biomedical sciences and allied health disciplines

Practice-Based Teacher Education Benefits Graduate Trainees and Their Students Through Inclusive and Active Teaching Methods

Teachers’ roles and identities in student-centered classrooms

Instructional Behaviors Affecting Student Attitudes Towards Science

Analysis of Interdisciplinary STEM Lessons Generated by Pre-Service and Inservice Teachers in the United States

Increasing Awareness of Inclusive STEM Education through a College-Level Student Research Group

Inquiry-Based Teaching in the College Classroom: The Nontraditional Student

Multimedia Characteristics, Student Relationships, and Teaching Behaviors Predict Perceptions of an Inclusive Classroom Across Course Delivery Format

An Undergraduate Introduction to Physiology Course as an Opportunity to Address Diversity, Equity and Inclusion in Biomedical Science

Facilitating Preservice Elementary Science Teachers’ Shift from Learner to Teacher of Engineering Design-Based Science Teaching

Teaching the way I wish I was taught: Design and implementation of a class on historically excluded and underrepresented scientists

Perspectives on Active Learning: Challenges for Equitable Active Learning Implementation

An exploration of the relationship between active learning and student motivation in STEM: a mixed methods study