Preferences for Health Care and Its Determinants Among Mentally Ill Patients of the West Shoa Zone Community, Oromia, Ethiopia
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/PPA.S393903
2023-03-08
Patient Preference and Adherence
Abstract:Getachew Adela Kasa, 1 Mirgissa Kaba 2 1 School of Public Health, St. Paul's Hospital Millennium Medical College, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia; 2 Department of Preventive Medicine, School of Public Health, College of Health Science, Addis Ababa University, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia Correspondence: Getachew Adela Kasa, School of Public Health, St. Paul's Hospital Millennium Medical College, PO Box 1271, Gulele Sub-City, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, Tel +251919292590 ; +2514793932709, Fax +251112-78-85-92, Email Background: Over 9 million people die from mental diseases each year, making them the second highest cause of mortality and the primary cause of disability worldwide. Objective: To explore the preferences for health care and its determinants among mentally ill patients in the West Shoa Zone Community in Oromia, Ethiopia, from July 11–September 20, 2022. Methods: The preference for health care and its determinants among mentally ill patients in the West Shoa Zone community were explored using an ethnographical study. Purposefully, a total of 16 FGD participants and 10 unstructured interview subjects, who had pertinent experiences and perspectives, were carefully selected from the urban and district levels. Data was collected utilizing two approaches in a triangulated manner and then coded, findings were contextualized, and a thematic plot was developed for thematic analysis. Results: In this study, in response to the questions, three main findings were thematized according to the causes, and six sub-themes were framed under the themes according to the preferences for treatment among mentally ill patients. The themes that emerged from the data were; 1. Supernatural causes, 2. Traditional non-spiritual beliefs and practices; and 3. Medico-surgical problems. The majority of the participants responded that residents preferred religious spiritualists the most (46%), followed by traditional counselors (Wabeka) (19%), traditional spiritualists (15%), institutional care (12%), herbalists (4%), and psychologists (4%). Conclusions and Recommendations: In this study, the most commonly perceived causes of mental illnesses were bad spirits, devilish activity, and engaging in actions that violated social norms and regulations. Religious spiritualists were the study's first choice for mental health care. This study advises collaboration and a shared strategy between health care professionals and traditional and religious stakeholders. Keywords: mental illness, traditional healer, cultures, preferences Over 276 million years of life with a disability-adjusted life expectancy and over 9 million deaths per year are accounted for by mental diseases, which are also the second biggest cause of mortality globally. 1 They are present in 10% of adult populations worldwide at any given time. Young adults, who are the most productive age group in the population, are most affected by mental health issues. 2 We use the term "mental illnesses" to refer to all diagnosable mental diseases that are characterized by changes in cognition, emotion, or behavior (or some combination of these), as well as distress and/or diminished functioning. 3 People with mental illnesses are typically viewed as lazy, worthless, stupid, dangerous to be around, violent, always in need of supervision, under the control of demons, suffering from divine punishment, unpredictable, unreliable, irresponsible, without consciousness, unfit for marriage and childrearing, unable to work, and getting sicker and sicker as they age. 2 According to a study conducted in India, the frequency of mental diseases varies across the nation from 10 to 370 per 1000 people, with females experiencing rates that are roughly 20–25% higher. 2 According to reports, 15% of children and 18% of adults in Ethiopia suffer from mental diseases. Only in the rural regions of Ethiopia do mental illnesses account for 11% of all disorders. 4 There are various myths regarding the causes of mental illness. 5 The stigma associated with mental illness makes many individuals feel guilty and discourages them from getting care. This is exacerbated by myths and misconceptions about the condition. 2 Non-Western countries, like Ethiopia, typically adhere to traditional and religious perspectives to explain the etiology of mental illness, while Western cultures typically follow the biological paradigm of disease conceptualization and treatment. 4 The most frequently cited causes of mental illness were stress, genetics, and bad childhood experiences. 6 Bad parenting, air pollution, loss of semen, poor diet, past sin, the curse of God, and the evil eye are also some of the impor -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal