Elementary pre-service teachers' ambivalent views on the introduction of artificial intelligence education: photovoice analysis

Daeyoung Moon,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.24062/kpae.2023.36.3.51

2023-09-30

The Korean Association of Practical Arts Education

Abstract:This study aimed to investigate the ambivalent views held by pre-service elementary school teachers regarding the introduction of artificial intelligence education using photovoice. The analysis was conducted on a total of 116 photographs and accompanying descriptions, which were carefully selected and contextualized by four of the 29 research participants. The findings can be summarized as follows. First, supportive views regarding the introduction of AI education were derived from seven themes: 1) The familiarity of students with the digital environment, 2) The responsibility of the school education system to prepare students for future society, 3) Opportunities to overcome the limitations of existing teaching methods, 4) The potential of AI as an effective learning tool, 5) The potential for customization of classes and feedback, 6) The potential of AI to spark interest in learning by integrating with the digital learning environment, and 7) The role of AI in providing teaching support and assistance to teachers. Second, opposing views on the introduction of AI education were derived from the following eight themes: 1) Concerns about AI's appropriateness for the development stage of elementary school students, 2) Unpredictable risks and potential side effects, 3) AI’s limitations in fostering a complete learning process, 4) Limitations of the value of direct experience, 5) Emphasis on the importance of teaching value judgment and critical thinking skills prior to AI integration, 6) Fears of losing human relationships, communication skills, empathy, and community spirit, 7) Belief that AI cannot replace professional expertise and assistance provided by teachers, and 8) Reduced thinking skills due to dependency on AI. Third, the study delved into the ambivalent views surrounding the introduction of AI education by interpreting the pros and cons perceived by pre-service elementary school teachers. These ambivalent perspectives were analyzed from the standpoint of their implications for students, teachers, the teaching and learning process, and society at large.