Assortative mating, marital stability and the role of business cycles in the United States from 1968 to 2011

Nikita Jacob,Nikita JacobCentre for Health Economics,University of York,Heslington,UKNikita Jacob is based at the Centre for Health Economics,University of York. She received a Doctorate in Economics from the University of Essex. Her research interests are primarily in applied micro-econometrics,health,family,education and development economics.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15140326.2024.2327909

2024-03-25

Journal of Applied Economics

Abstract:The strong negative correlation between divorce and a wide range of outcomes in terms of well-being, health, education and labour market performance has been well documented in the literature. Economic conditions have been found to affect marital stability. Shared gains from marriage also depend on spouses' characteristics such as age, education, ethnicity and religious beliefs. This paper examines the relationship between these spousal characteristics and the probability of dissolution while taking into account business cycle fluctuations. Using data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics 1968–2011 for the United States and employing a duration modelling strategy, findings reveal that differences in educational attainment and ethnicity between spouses increase the hazard of marital dissolution. However similarity in religious beliefs and ethnicity reduce the risk of divorce. A period of economic growth improves marital stability. However, ethnic differences are a significant predictor of marital division, even in times of economic prosperity.

economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to explore the relationship between spousal characteristics and marital stability, with particular attention to the impact of the economic cycle on this relationship. Specifically, the study aims to analyze how the similarities and differences between spouses in terms of age, educational level, religious belief, and ethnic background affect the probability of marital dissolution in the United States from 1968 to 2011, while taking into account the impact of economic cycle fluctuations.

### Main research questions
1. **The relationship between spousal characteristics and marital dissolution**:
- How do the similarities and differences between spouses in age, educational level, religious belief, and ethnic background affect the risk of marital dissolution?
- Does similarity enhance marital stability, while difference increase the likelihood of marital dissolution?

2. **The impact of the economic cycle on marital stability**:
- What are the different impacts of economic growth and recession periods on marital stability?
- Are the impacts of spousal characteristics on marital dissolution different in different economic cycles?

### Research background
- **Negative impacts of divorce**: Previous studies have shown that divorce has significant negative impacts on individuals' well - being, health, education, and labor market performance. Especially for children in the family, the impact of divorce is more far - reaching, including lower educational achievement, reduced income, early marriage, high divorce rate, and increased suicide risk.
- **The influence of economic conditions**: Economic conditions are also considered to affect marital stability. For example, factors such as unemployment rate, inflation, and consumer confidence may all affect couples' marriage decisions.
- **Theoretical basis of spousal matching**: Research by economists and sociologists has shown that spousal matching in the marriage market is usually based on similar characteristics, such as educational level, wealth, and attractiveness. This matching can be divided into positive matching (similar spouses) and negative matching (dissimilar spouses).

### Research methods
- **Data sources**: The study uses data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics (PSID) in the United States from 1968 to 2011.
- **Model selection**: A discrete time duration model is adopted to analyze the probability of marital dissolution. This model can handle time - varying covariates and adjust various factors that affect the probability of marital dissolution.
- **Control variables**: These include the year of marriage, state fixed effects, the passage of unilateral divorce laws, and the number of children.

### Research hypotheses
- **The impact of spousal characteristics on marital dissolution**: It is expected that differences between spouses in educational level and ethnic background will increase the risk of marital dissolution, while sharing the same religious belief and ethnic background will reduce the risk of divorce.
- **The role of the economic cycle**: It is expected that the economic growth period will improve marital stability, while the economic recession period may increase the risk of marital dissolution, although due to the increase in divorce costs, couples may choose to temporarily maintain their marriage.

### Research contributions
- **Comprehensive analysis**: This study combines factors of spousal characteristics and economic cycle, providing a more comprehensive perspective to understand marital stability.
- **Empirical evidence**: Using longitudinal data spanning four decades, it provides empirical evidence on the impact of spousal characteristics and economic cycle on marital dissolution.

Through these analyses, the study aims to provide new insights into understanding the multi - dimensional factors affecting marital stability and provide valuable references for policy makers.