Abstract:Predictive modeling often ignores interaction effects among predictors in high-dimensional data because of analytical and computational challenges. Research in interaction selection has been galvanized along with methodological and computational advances. In this study, we aim to investigate the performance of two types of predictive algorithms that can perform interaction selection. Specifically, we compare the predictive performance and interaction selection accuracy of both penalty-based and tree-based predictive algorithms. Penalty-based algorithms included in our comparative study are the regularization path algorithm under the marginality principle (RAMP), the least absolute shrinkage selector operator (LASSO), the smoothed clipped absolute deviance (SCAD), and the minimax concave penalty (MCP). The tree-based algorithms considered are random forest (RF) and iterative random forest (iRF). We evaluate the effectiveness of these algorithms under various regression and classification models with varying structures and dimensions. We assess predictive performance using the mean squared error for regression and accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, balanced accuracy, and F1 score for classification. We use interaction coverage to judge the algorithm’s efficacy for interaction selection. Our findings reveal that the effectiveness of the selected algorithms varies depending on the number of predictors (data dimension) and the structure of the data-generating model, i.e., linear or nonlinear, hierarchical or non-hierarchical. There were at least one or more scenarios that favored each of the algorithms included in this study. However, from the general pattern, we are able to recommend one or more specific algorithm(s) for some specific scenarios. Our analysis helps clarify each algorithm’s strengths and limitations, offering guidance to researchers and data analysts in choosing an appropriate algorithm for their predictive modeling task based on their data structure.

Partial Least Squares Regression Trees for Multivariate Response Data With Multicollinear Predictors

Sparse Variable Selection on High Dimensional Heterogeneous Data With Tree Structured Responses

Analyze Additive and Interaction Effects via Collaborative Trees

A Regression Tree Method for Longitudinal and Clustered Data with Multivariate Responses

Regression Trees for Longitudinal Data

Semiparametric Mixed-Scale Models Using Shared Bayesian Forests

Sequential scaled sparse factor regression

Interaction Selection and Prediction Performance in High-Dimensional Data: A Comparative Study of Statistical and Tree-Based Methods

A Random-effects Approach to Regression Involving Many Categorical Predictors and Their Interactions

A Fused Latent and Graphical Model for Multivariate Binary Data

Predicting Multivariate Responses in Multiple Linear Regression

Convergence Rates of Oblique Regression Trees for Flexible Function Libraries

Modeling Multivariate Mixed-Response Functional Data

FREEtree: A Tree-based Approach for High Dimensional Longitudinal Data With Correlated Features

An ensemble approach to improved prediction from multitype data

Optimal Sparse Regression Trees

Bayesian latent factor regression for multivariate functional data with variable selection

Evaluation of Tree Based Regression over Multiple Linear Regression for Non-normally Distributed Data in Battery Performance

Prediction of multivariate responses with a select number of principal components

Large Scale Prediction with Decision Trees

Multiple-response logistic regression modeling with application to an analysis of cirrhosis liver disease data