Lucy Todd,Matthew H.W. Chin,Marc-Olivier Coppens
Abstract:3D Voronoi scaffolds are widely applied in the field of additive manufacturing as they are known for their light weight structural resilience and share many topological similarities to various natural (bone, tumours, lymph node) and synthetic environments (foam, functionally gradient porous materials). Unfortunately, the structural design features that promote these topological similarities (such as the number of vertices) are often unpredictable and require the trial and error of varying design features to achieve the desired 3D Voronoi structure. This article provides a toolkit, consisting of equations, based on over 12,000 3D Voronoi structures. These equations allow design features, such as the number of generating points (G), to be efficiently and accurately predicted based on the desired structural parameters (within ±3 G). Based on these equations we are proposing, to the best of our knowledge, two new mathematical conjectures that relate the number of vertices or edges, and the average edge length to G in Voronoi structures. These equations have been validated for a wide range of parameter values and Voronoi network sizes. A design code is provided allowing any of over 12,000 structures to be selected, easily adjusted based on user requirements, and 3D printed. Biomedical case studies relevant to T-cell culturing, bone scaffolds and kidney tumours are presented to illustrate the design code.
materials science, multidisciplinary,nanoscience & nanotechnology,chemistry, physical
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the parameter prediction problem in 3D Voronoi structure design. Specifically, the authors focus on how to predict efficiently and accurately the number of core points (i.e., the number of generating points \(G\)) required to construct a specific 3D Voronoi structure. These structures have wide applications in fields such as biomedicine, architecture, and design. Voronoi structures are favored for their lightweight, customizable characteristics and topological similarity to various natural and synthetic environments. However, when designing 3D Voronoi structures with specific topological features, parameters such as the number of vertices (\(V\)), the number of edges (\(E\)), and the average edge length (\(\varepsilon\)) are often unpredictable, which leads to trial - and - error and inefficiency in the design process.
To solve this problem, based on the data of more than 12,000 3D Voronoi structures, the authors proposed four equations that can accurately predict the required number of generating points \(G\) according to the required structural parameters (such as the number of vertices, the number of edges, the average edge length, and the Euler characteristic \(\chi\)). In addition, the author also proposed two new mathematical conjectures, which are applicable to any Voronoi structure presented and may be general. This means that highly specific 3D Voronoi structures can now be designed within seconds.
### Key Equations
1. **Relationship between the number of vertices and the number of generating points**:
\[
G=\frac{V + 8.53}{5.45}
\]
This equation was tested in the range of \(V = 25-1700\), with an average deviation of ±1.
2. **Relationship between the number of edges and the number of generating points**:
\[
G=\frac{E + 21.10}{10.89}
\]
This equation was tested in the range of \(E = 45-3400\), with an average deviation of ±1.
3. **Relationship between the average edge length and the number of generating points**:
\[
G=\left(\frac{\varepsilon}{L}\right)^{-1/0.45}
\]
This equation was tested in the range of \(\varepsilon = 7-55\), with an average deviation of ±3, where \(L\) is the length of the cube design space.
4. **Relationship between the Euler characteristic and the number of generating points**:
\[
G=\chi - 1
\]
This equation was tested in the range of \(\chi = 6-301\), with an average deviation of ±0.
### Biomedical Application Cases
To verify the validity and accuracy of these equations, the authors conducted research on several biomedical application cases:
1. **T - cell culture structure**:
A 3D T - cell culture structure was designed using equation (4) to simulate the fibroblast reticular cell (FRC) network in lymph nodes. Research shows that there are approximately 65 vertices in a cube with \(L = 100\space\mu m\). Using equation (4), \(G = 13\) was calculated, and then 800 new structures were designed for testing. The results show that 95 structures have exactly 65 vertices, and the number of vertices in other structures is between 61 and 68. This verifies the accuracy of equation (4).
2. **Patient trabecular bone structure**:
A 3D Voronoi structure was designed using equation (5) to simulate the patient's trabecular bone structure in order to study the structural fragility caused by osteoporosis. Based on a fragment of the patient's bone microenvironment, the number of edges calculated was 1388. \(G\) was calculated using equation (5), and the corresponding Voronoi structure was designed. Although more detailed models need to consider anisotropy and inhomogeneity, the preliminary results show that equation (5) can effectively predict the required number of generating points.
Through these studies, the authors not only provided a practical toolkit but also demonstrated the accuracy and effectiveness of these equations in practical applications.