Abstract:In this paper, we examine the materiality of ESG on country creditworthiness from a credit risk and fundamental analysis viewpoint. We first determine the ESG indicators that are most relevant when it comes to explaining the sovereign bond yield, after controlling the effects of traditional fundamental variables such as economic strength and credit rating. We also emphasize the major themes that are directly useful for investors when assessing the country risk premium. At the global level, we notice that these themes mainly belong to the E and G pillars. Those results confirm that extra-financial criteria are integrated into bond pricing. However, we also identify a clear difference between high-and middle-income countries. Indeed, whereas the S pillar is lagging for the highest income countries, it is nearly as important as the G pillar for the middle-income ones. Second, we determine which ESG metrics are indirectly valuable for assessing a country's solvency. More precisely, we attempt to infer credit rating solely from extra-financial criteria, that is the ESG indicators that are priced in by credit rating agencies. We find that there is no overlap between the set of indicators that predict credit ratings and those that directly explain sovereign bond yields. The results also highlight the importance of the G and S pillars when predicting credit ratings. The E pillar is lagging, suggesting that credit rating agencies are undermining the impact of climate change and environmental topics on country creditworthiness. This is consistent with the traditional view that social and governance issues are the main drivers of the sovereign risk, because they are more specific and less global than environmental issues. Finally, taking these different results together, this research shows that opposing extra-financial and fundamental analysis does not make a lot of sense.

ESG scores and debt costs: Exploring indebtedness, agency costs, and financial system impact

ESG performance, heterogeneous creditors, and bond financing costs: Firm-level evidence

ESG and the Cost of Debt: Role of Media Coverage

The ESG effect on the cost of debt financing: A sharp RD analysis

ESG-Based Sustainability Performance and its Impact on Cost of Capital: International Evidence from the Energy Sector

The Impact of Corporate ESG Performance on Debt Financing Costs

How do ESG controversies moderate the nexus between ESG performance and cost of capital? Evidence from European listed companies

Are ESG scores driven by financial information? Evidence from European banks

The implied risks caused by ESG rating divergence: a test based on the cost of equity capital

Cost of debt financing, stock returns, and corporate strategic ESG disclosure: Evidence from China

Sustainable Innovation and Economic Resilience: Deciphering ESG Ratings' Role in Lowering Debt Financing Costs

ESG and systemic risk

Embedding sustainability in risk management: The impact of environmental, social, and governance ratings on corporate financial risk

Bank's funding costs: Do ESG factors really matter?

ESG and Sovereign Risk: What is Priced in by the Bond Market and Credit Rating Agencies?

ESG criteria and the credit risk of corporate bond portfolios

Do ESG scores affect financial systemic risk? Evidence from European banks and insurers

The Impact of a Firm’s ESG Score on Its Cost of Capital: Can a High ESG Score Serve as a Substitute for a Weaker Legal Environment?

The Effect of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Performance and Disclosure on Cost of Debt: The Mediating Effect of Corporate Reputation

New ESG rating drivers in the cross‐section of European stock returns

Sustainable investing with ESG rating uncertainty