Abstract:Abstract In the United States, enrollments in preschool center-based programs have leveled off at about 75 percent of four-year-olds and 50 percent of three year olds. Nearly all government programs restrict eligibility to children in low-income families, and these families have substantially increased preschool participation rates as a result. However, in the last decade little progress was made toward increasing enrollments, despite increases in government spending, and less than half of children in poverty attend public programs even at age four. The average educational quality of private programs is quite low, and public programs are only modestly better. As a result, the educational effectiveness of preschool programs in the United States tends to be much weaker than that of the well-known programs research has shown be cost-effective. This paper considers whether publicly funded preschool education for all children would alleviate these problems. Universal public preschool education would reach many more children in poor and low-income families. For means-tested programs constantly changing incomes present a moving target, while the stigma associated with programs for the poor also limits participation. Program effectiveness would be at least as good in a universal program as in targeted program, and effectiveness might actually improve. One source of increased effectiveness is peer effects on learning. In addition, parents from higher-income families may be better advocates for quality, and political support for quality may be higher. Children from middle- and higher-income families also will benefit from high-quality publicly-subsidized preschool programs. A universal approach will cost more than current targeted programs, but moving from targeted to universal public preschool education is likely to produce benefits that far exceed the additional cost.

Privatization of preschool education: The implications for educational inequalities in cross-national perspective

Inequality in Preschool Education and School Readiness

Inequalities in Resources for Preschool-Age Children by Parental Education: Evidence from Six Advanced Industrialized Countries

(Un)equal from the start? A quantitative analysis of preschool children’s participation in organised activities in Germany

Does private education pay off?

Impact Analysis of Chinese Government Leadership in the Construction of a Public Service System of Preschool Education

Statistically Based Assessment and Decision-Making in Preschool Education

Inequality in Preschool Quality? Community-Level Disparities in Access to High-Quality Learning Environments

Persistent association between family socioeconomic status and primary school performance in Britain over 95 years

Universal and Targeted Approaches to Preschool Education in the United States

Early Childhood Education Participation: A Mixed-Methods Study of Parent and Provider Perceived Barriers and Facilitators

Does Preschool Education Experience Help Disadvantaged Students Become Academically Resilient? Empirical Evidence from CEPS Data

Socioeconomic and attitudinal differences between service users of private and public early childhood education and care in the Finnish context

Assessment of Preschool’s Inclusive Participation in Social Responsibility Program Under Institutional Pressure: Evidence From China

Assessment of Preschool's Inclusive Participation in Social Responsibility Program Under Institutional Pressure: Evidence From China

Inequalities in Early Childhood Education and Care in Argentina and the United Kingdom (2010-2020)

Parent education as a mandatory component of preschool: Effects on middle-class, educationally advantaged parents and children

Explaining patterns of inequality in childcare service use across 31 developed economies: A welfare state perspective

The educational and labor market returns to preschool attendance in Austria

The amplifier of intergenerational inequalities: parental education, quality of preschool education and early childhood development in China

Inefficient urban-rural resource allocation and reduced tuition benefits for preschool education: an example from a Chinese county