Abstract:India is a global hotspot for irrigation-induced groundwater withdrawal, leading to widespread lowering of water levels, in turn resulting in disproportionate access to irrigation supplies among farming communities. Efforts to mitigate the situation, however, have fallen short, largely due to technocentric vision (e.g. microirrigation adoption) of the regulatory authorities (RAs), which does little to integrate the vast groundwater-dependent socioecologies with the decision making system. In view of that, we invite the RAs to deliberate upon a cap-and-trade mechanism that proposes to mobilize the farmers at every aspect of planning and execution, while to tackling multiple challenges simultaneously: (a) restrict groundwater pumping to a pre-defined safe level (cap), (b) creating a shared space/quotas for all to pump (allocation); and (c) making provisions for trade of allocations. The latter further augments farmers' access to groundwater (and irrigation). Using a systematic bibliometric analysis of relevant world literature and contextual appraisal of groundwater-irrigation landscape in India, we develop a conceptual framework of cap-and-trade in three parts. In the first Pre-implementation stage, we emphasize a reality check study to assess ground conditions, if favorable for a cap-and-trade approach (existing social, economic, institutional circumstances). Next, in the Implementation stage, (1) we recommend an integrated hydrogeological-hydrometeorological modeling to determine flexible capping arrangements, with the possibility of delineating certain priority regions (coastal ecosystems); (2) for allocations, a reasonable fraction of the cap over a defined period; we envision a thoroughly participatory arrangement, centering on four action areas: identifying, informing, consulting, and involving the farmers, alongside all stakeholders engaged in the groundwater-irrigation decision making; (3) for trade, we urge the RAs to create win-win situations for both the sellers and buyers; develop the transaction protocols on certain foundational principles (e.g. simplicity, transparency and consistency); strengthening of local institutions, and development of targeted financial support schemes. We consider the third part of the narrative, Post-implementation stage, as a real game changer, comprising of a monitoring, auditing (performance benchmarking) component coupled with multitiered outreach-mentoring drives that demonstrate to the farmers the benefits of becoming part of the cap-and-trade program. Overall, a main motivation to present this research is to shatter the age-old socio-cognitive beliefs/taboos around groundwater pumping (My land, My Water), breaking the hegemony of the water sellers (rich/wealthy large landholder clans), to potentially, create a social norm whereby the farmers realize the value of restricting groundwater pumping and sharing for mutual prosperity.

Regulatory Instruments and Demand Management of Water: Potential and Prospects

Water scarcity and climatic change in India: the need for water demand and supply management

Water Demand Management: Review of Literature and Comparison in South-East Asia

An Overview of Policies Impacting Water Quality and Governance in India

A taxonomy of demand management strategies for sustainable water consumption in urban households

Reframing water demand management: a new co-governance framework coupling supply-side and demand-side solutions toward sustainability

The Impacts of Water Demand and Its Implications for Future Surface Water Resource Management: the Case of Tanzania's Wami Ruvu Basin (WRB)

Institutional impediments to conservation of freshwater dependent ecosystems

Can Cap-and-Trade Be a Regulatory Option to Address Groundwater Depletion and Irrigation Crises in India? Reflections, Issues & Options

Demand management in irrigation districts

Wastewater Discharge Standards in the Evolving Context of Urban Sustainability–The Case of India

Social practice theory and household water demand: A review of literature and research evidence

A review of residential water conservation tool performance and influences on implementation effectiveness

Groundwater Markets in South Asia: A Bibliometric Assessment of Challenges and Opportunities for Sustainable Irrigation Development

Delivering sustainable urban water management: a review of the hurdles we face

Prospective Models for Water Service Demand and Price Analyses

Assessing the feasibility of integrating ecosystem-based with engineered water resource governance and management for water security in semi-arid landscapes: A case study in the Banas catchment, Rajasthan, India

Optimizing equity in intermittent water supply systems: A volume-driven demand and flow control approach

Water Law Reforms in Central Asian Countries: Recent Trends and Developments

Pricing Policies in Managing Water Resources in Agriculture: An Application of Contract Theory to Unmetered Water

Community-based water demand management: socio-technical strategies for improving water security in Australian Indigenous communities