Abstract:Despite the widespread availability of artificial intelligence (AI) products and services, consumer evaluations and adoption intentions have not met expectations. Existing research mainly focuses on AI's instrumental attributes from the consumer perspective, along with negative impacts of AI failures on evaluations and willingness to use. However, research is lacking on AI as a collaborative agent, investigating the impact of human-AI collaboration on AI acceptance under different outcome expectations. This study examines the interactive effects of human-AI collaboration types (AI-dominant vs. AI-assisted) and outcome expectations (positive vs. negative) on AI product evaluations and usage willingness, along with the underlying mechanisms, from a human-AI relationship perspective. It also investigates the moderating role of algorithm transparency in these effects. Using three online experiments with analysis of variance and bootstrap methods, the study validates these interactive mechanisms, revealing the mediating role of attribution and moderating role of algorithm transparency. Experiment 1 confirms the interactive effects of human-AI collaboration types and outcome expectations on consumer evaluations and usage willingness. Under positive outcome expectations, consumers evaluate and express willingness to use AI-dominant intelligent vehicles with autonomous driving capabilities higher than those with emergency evasion capabilities (AI-assisted). However, under negative outcome expectations, consumers rate autonomous driving capabilities lower compared to emergency evasion capabilities. Experiment 2 examines the mediating role of attribution through ChatGPT's dominant or assisting role under different outcome expectations. Experiment 3 uses a clinical decision-making system to study algorithm transparency's moderating role, showing higher transparency improves evaluations and willingness to use AI products and services under negative outcome expectations. Theoretically, this study advances consumer behavior research by exploring the human-AI relationship within artificial intelligence, enhancing understanding of consumer acceptance variations. Practically, it offers insights for better integrating AI products and services into the market.

To be precise (imprecise) in utilitarian (hedonic) contexts: Examining the influence of numerical precision on consumer reactions to artificial intelligence‐based recommendations

The Role of Recommendation Sources and Attribute Framing in Online Product Recommendations

Impact of Cultural Tightness on Consumers' Preference for Anthropomorphic AI Services

Effects of the Conversation and Recommendation Mechanism on Chatbots' Recommendation Effectiveness

Artificial Intelligence or Human: when and Why Consumers Prefer AI Recommendations

Precision Makes Tightness Better: the Interactive Effect of Interstitial Space and Number Precision on Purchase Intention

The Searching Artificial Intelligence: Consumers Show Less Aversion to Algorithm‐recommended Search Product

Me and my AI: Exploring the effects of consumer self‐construal and AI‐based experience on avoiding similarity and willingness to pay

How to Talk to AI: the Role of Preset Prompt Language Styles in Shaping Conversational Experience

The Value of Being Precise

Costly "Greetings" from AI: Effects of Product Recommenders and Self-Disclosure Levels on Transaction Costs

When do consumers prefer AI-enabled customer service? The interaction effect of brand personality and service provision type on brand attitudes and purchase intentions

Uncertainty of Artificial Intelligence Assistant: The Effect of Assistant Type on Variety Seeking

The impact of differential pricing subject on consumer behavior

When Consumers Need More Interpretability of Artificial Intelligence (AI) Recommendations? the Effect of Decision-Making Domains

Consumer reactions to AI design: Exploring consumer willingness to pay for AI‐designed products

When E-Commerce Personalization Systems Show and Tell: Investigating the Relative Persuasive Appeal of Content-Based versus Collaborative Filtering

Artificial intelligence and moral dilemmas: Perception of ethical decision-making in AI

The impact of human-AI collaboration types on consumer evaluation and usage intention: a perspective of responsibility attribution

When Post Hoc Explanation Knocks: Consumer Responses to Explainable AI Recommendations

Knowing When to Pass: The Effect of AI Reliability in Risky Decision Contexts