Abstract:Abstract Background The methods with which prediction models are usually developed mean that neither the parameters nor the predictions should be interpreted causally. For many applications, this is perfectly acceptable. However, when prediction models are used to support decision making, there is often a need for predicting outcomes under hypothetical interventions. Aims We aimed to identify published methods for developing and validating prediction models that enable risk estimation of outcomes under hypothetical interventions, utilizing causal inference. We aimed to identify the main methodological approaches, their underlying assumptions, targeted estimands, and potential pitfalls and challenges with using the method. Finally, we aimed to highlight unresolved methodological challenges. Methods We systematically reviewed literature published by December 2019, considering papers in the health domain that used causal considerations to enable prediction models to be used for predictions under hypothetical interventions. We included both methodologies proposed in statistical/machine learning literature and methodologies used in applied studies. Results We identified 4919 papers through database searches and a further 115 papers through manual searches. Of these, 87 papers were retained for full-text screening, of which 13 were selected for inclusion. We found papers from both the statistical and the machine learning literature. Most of the identified methods for causal inference from observational data were based on marginal structural models and g-estimation. Conclusions There exist two broad methodological approaches for allowing prediction under hypothetical intervention into clinical prediction models: (1) enriching prediction models derived from observational studies with estimated causal effects from clinical trials and meta-analyses and (2) estimating prediction models and causal effects directly from observational data. These methods require extending to dynamic treatment regimes, and consideration of multiple interventions to operationalise a clinical decision support system. Techniques for validating ‘causal prediction models’ are still in their infancy.

A Review and Synthesis of Multi-level Models for Causal Inference with Individual Level Exposures

Bridging the Divide: Tackling Tensions Between Life-Course Epidemiology and Causal Inference

Multilevel Modeling: A Review of Methodological Issues and Applications

A Review of Causal Inference Methods for Estimating the Effects of Exposure Change when Incident Exposure Is Unobservable

A review of some recent advances in causal inference

A new approach to hierarchical data analysis: Targeted maximum likelihood estimation for the causal effect of a cluster-level exposure

Formulating causal questions and principled statistical answers

Learning Causal Effects From Observational Data in Healthcare: A Review and Summary

From classical mendelian randomization to causal networks for systematic integration of multi-omics

Statistical Approaches for Causal Inference

Causal inference under over-simplified longitudinal causal models

A scoping review of causal methods enabling predictions under hypothetical interventions

The Effect of Small Sample Size on Two-Level Model Estimates: A Review and Illustration

Discussion of 'Causal inference with misspecified exposure mappings: separating definitions and assumptions'

Review of Causal Discovery Methods Based on Graphical Models

Conceptualising causal pathways in systematic reviews of international development interventions through adopting a causal chain analysis approach

Enhancing inferences and conclusions in body image focused non-experimental research via a causal modelling approach: A tutorial

Remarks on the analysis of causal relationships in population research

Bayesian causal inference: a critical review

Causally interpretable meta-analysis combining aggregate and individual participant data

Causal Inference with Complex Treatments: A Survey