Variation in phrase frame structure and function in argumentative writing by EFL learners across different L1 backgrounds
Yingming Song,Jiajin Xu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ijal.12625
2024-09-29
International Journal of Applied Linguistics
Abstract:Within the context of multilingualism, there has been burgeoning research interest in interlanguage varieties. This corpus‐based study investigated structural and functional variations in phrase frames (p‐frames) in argumentative writing by English as a Foreign Language (EFL) learners from Arabic, German, Hindi, and Chinese language backgrounds. P‐frames, recurrent non‐contiguous co‐selection units within texts, were automatically extracted, manually filtered, and analyzed for variability, predictability, and discourse function. The results revealed learners' shared reliance on prompt‐related p‐frames as well as potential L1 influence on specific p‐frames. German learners displayed the lowest degree of flexibility and creativity, while Hindi learners exhibited the highest. Chinese and Arabic learners demonstrated moderate levels, falling between the two extremes. Statistically significant differences in p‐frame tokens across functional categories were observed in all groups. This study contributes to a nuanced understanding of phraseological competence in EFL learners from different L1 backgrounds and holds pedagogical implications for the globalized educational landscape. 摘要 在多语制背景下, 学界对不同中介语变体的研究兴趣日益增长。本研究采用基于语料库的方法, 探讨了来自阿拉伯语、德语、印地语和汉语母语背景的英语学习者在议论文中使用短语框架 (phrase frames) 的结构和功能变异情况。短语框架是文本中重复出现的非连续型共选单位。在自动提取并手动筛选后, 本研究对所得短语框架作了变异性、可预测性和话语功能分析。结果表明, 学习者普遍依赖与写作题目相关的短语框架, 同时在特定短语框架的使用上还受到母语的潜在影响。德语学习者使用的短语框架表现出最低的灵活性和创造性, 印地语学习者在这两方面则最高;汉语和阿拉伯语学习者则介于两者之间。不同功能类别的短语框架的使用频次在学习者群体间存在统计学上的显著差异。本研究有助于更精细化地理解不同母语背景英语学习者的短语能力, 在全球化的教育背景下具有教学启示。
education & educational research,linguistics