Protected areas have a mixed impact on waterbirds, but management helps

Hannah S Wauchope, Julia PG Jones, Jonas Geldmann, Benno I Simmons, Tatsuya Amano, Daniel E Blanco, Richard A Fuller, Alison Johnston, Tom Langendoen, Taej Mundkur, Szabolcs Nagy, William J Sutherland
2022-05-05
Abstract:International policy is focused on increasing the proportion of the Earth’s surface that is protected for nature,. Although studies show that protected areas prevent habitat loss, , –, there is a lack of evidence for their effect on species’ populations: existing studies are at local scale or use simple designs that lack appropriate controls, , , , , –. Here we explore how 1,506 protected areas have affected the trajectories of 27,055 waterbird populations across the globe using a robust before–after control–intervention study design, which compares protected and unprotected populations in the years before and after protection. We show that the simpler study designs typically used to assess protected area effectiveness (before–after or control–intervention) incorrectly estimate effects for 37–50% of populations—for instance misclassifying positively impacted populations as negatively impacted, and vice versa. Using our robust …
What problem does this paper attempt to address?