Efficiency and Mergers and Acquisitions of Electric Utility Companies

Mika Goto,Tadaaki Tomikawa,Toshiyuki Sueyoshi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en17081972
IF: 3.2
2024-04-23
Energies
Abstract:Since the 1990s, market liberalization of the electricity industry has advanced all around the world. To survive in the drastically changing business environment, incumbent electric utility companies have conducted operational reforms, including Mergers and Acquisitions (M&As), to enhance and/or complement existing business capabilities. The purpose of this study was to measure the operational efficiencies of 31 of the world's largest electric utility companies using data from 2010 to 2020 and examine regional differences in and the impacts of M&As on the efficiencies. For this purpose, we applied a new type of Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) and Tobit model regression. We provide findings from the empirical analyses and discuss the business implications of M&As for electric utility companies. The operational efficiency measures were different among regions, but did not show statistically significant changes over the study period from 2010 to 2020. Furthermore, the results of regression analyses indicate that the increasing number of M&A buying transactions and M&A total transactions has a negative marginal impact on the operational efficiency or leads to a lower operational efficiency for utility companies. Since electricity utility companies have not received gains in operational efficiency from increasing the number of M&A transactions, they need to be more cautious about whether M&A transactions can provide value to the operation and technology management.
energy & fuels
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the impact of mergers and acquisitions (M&As) on the operational efficiency of electric utility companies. Specifically, the research aims to measure the operational efficiency of the 31 largest electric utility companies in the world between 2010 and 2020, and analyze the differences between different regions and the impact of M&A activities on the efficiency of these companies. ### Main problems: 1. **Evaluating the impact of M&As on operational efficiency**: Although M&As are important means for electric utility companies to obtain growth opportunities and enhance innovation capabilities in a competitive environment, previous studies have not yet explored in detail their quantitative impact on operational efficiency. 2. **Regional differences**: The research also attempts to understand whether there are differences in operational efficiency among electric utility companies in different regions. 3. **Temporal change trends**: The research focuses on whether the operational efficiency of these companies has changed significantly during the observation period (2010 - 2020). ### Research methods: To achieve the above - mentioned goals, the author adopts the following methods: - **Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA)**: It is used to measure the operational efficiency of each company. DEA is a comprehensive efficiency evaluation method based on mathematical programming, which can consider input and output factors simultaneously. - **Tobit regression model**: It is used to analyze the impact of M&A activities on operational efficiency. By converting the efficiency index into an inefficiency index (OI), and using the Tobit model with zero - censoring for regression analysis. - **Non - parametric statistical tests**: Such as the Mann - Whitney U test, are used to compare the efficiency differences between different regions and years. ### Key findings: - There are differences in operational efficiency among different regions, but no statistically significant changes were shown during the research period from 2010 to 2020. - The results of regression analysis show that an increase in the number of M&A transactions has a negative marginal impact on operational efficiency, that is, more M&A activities may lead to lower operational efficiency. ### Conclusions: Since electric utility companies have not obtained an improvement in operational efficiency from the increased M&A transactions, they need to more carefully evaluate whether M&A transactions can bring value to operational and technical management. ### Formula presentation: - **DEA model**: \[ OEv_{kt}=1 - \left(\frac{1}{m + s}\left(\sum_{i = 1}^{m}\xi^*_{ikt}+\sum_{r = 1}^{s}\xi^*_{rkt}\right)+\epsilon_n\left(\sum_{i = 1}^{m}R_{x_i}d^*_{x_{ikt}}+\sum_{r = 1}^{s}R_{g_r}d^*_{g_{rkt}}\right)\right) \] where: - \(OEv_{kt}\) is the operational efficiency of the \(k\) - th company under variable returns to scale in the \(t\) - th period. - \(\xi^*_{ikt}\) and \(\xi^*_{rkt}\) are inefficiency scores. - \(d^*_{x_{ikt}}\) and \(d^*_{g_{rkt}}\) are slack variables. - \(\epsilon_n\) is a very small predetermined number. - **Tobit regression model**: \[ OI_{at}=f(\text{regional dummy variables}_j, M\&A_{a(t - 1)})+u_{at} \] where: - \(OI_{at}\) is the operational inefficiency of the \(a\) - th company in the \(t\) - th period. - \(M\&A_{a(t - 1)}\) is the one - period lag variable of M&A activities. - \(u_{at}\) is a random error term. Through these methods and formulas, the research provides new insights into the impact of M&A behavior of electric utility companies on their operational efficiency.