Critique in Religious Education
Yonah Hisbon Matemba
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01416200.2023.2244798
2023-08-12
British Journal of Religious Education
Abstract:As Religious Education (RE) in public schools repositions to remain educationally relevant for children in an increasingly secularised and post-truth world, the need to engage critically with complex issues (agreeable and the disagreeable) cannot be greater, even in non-public faith-based contexts such as Sunday School or Madrassa. The juxtaposition of different (at times conflicting) knowledge in the material content of contemporary RE, variety of pedagogical approaches and, crucially, how classroom discourse (involving students and teachers) at times de/legitimises certain knowledge, calls for critique (not criticism) as the basis for doing RE. While criticism focuses on fault-finding, disapproval, and 'othering', on the other hand, critique relates to skilful conceptualisation, considered judgement, detailed analysis, and reflective assessment of issues, whether religious or not. Critique draws from Critical Theory, involving dialectical thinking and is helpful because it facilitates a critical assessment of and challenge to hegemony, dominant culture, and ideology of the curriculum.
education & educational research