The Surprising Effect of Priming on SNOT-22 Results

Ibtisam Mohammad,Taylor Stack,Meghan Norris,Sulgi Kim,Meredith Lamb,Brian D. Thorp,Christine Klatt-Cromwell,Charles S. Ebert,Adam J. Kimple,Brent A. Senior
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/19458924241229160
2024-02-11
American Journal of Rhinology and Allergy
Abstract:American Journal of Rhinology &Allergy, Ahead of Print. BackgroundPriming is a psychological phenomenon where subconscious cues in the environment impact our behavioral responses in certain situations. Well studied in the worlds of business, marketing, and even politics, it is unclear how the priming phenomenon impacts patient perception of their own disease state nor how they report that perception using tools like the Sinonasal Outcomes Test (SNOT-22), used to measure that perception in chronic rhinosinusitis.ObjectiveTo determine the impact of positive or negative priming on self-reported patient perception of their chronic rhinosinusitis disease using the SNOT-22 disease-specific quality of life instrument.MethodsSingle-blind, randomized, prospective cohort pilot study of 206 consecutive adult patients with a clinical diagnosis of chronic rhinosinusitis presenting to a university rhinology clinic. Patients were randomized to receive "positive priming" (103) or "negative priming" (103) by reading a passage about the positive or negative aspects of chronic sinusitis and its treatment respectively. Patients were then asked to fill out the SNOT-22 and results between the two groups were compared.ResultsThe negative priming group had a higher median SNOT-22 score of 49 [IQR = 39] compared to the positive priming groups' score of 22 [IQR = 27], p < 0.0001), a difference of nearly three times the minimal clinical impactful difference (MCID). This effect was consistent regardless of age or sex of the patient. Subgroup analysis revealed a greater impact when priming was performed by the senior male attending regardless of patient age or sex (p 59 years, p = 0.001) and female patients (p = 0.003).ConclusionsPriming impacts how patient's perceive their chronic rhinosinusitis as determined by the SNOT-22. It is imperative that the rhinologist understand this when using this instrument in research applications and in clinical decision-making for patients.
otorhinolaryngology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?