Air cleaners and respiratory infections in schools: A modeling study using epidemiological, environmental, and molecular data

Nicolas Banholzer,Philipp Jent,Pascal Bittel,Kathrin Zürcher,Lavinia Furrer,Simon Bertschinger,Ernest Weingartner,Alban Ramette,Matthias Egger,Tina Hascher,Lukas Fenner
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofae169
2024-03-21
Open Forum Infectious Diseases
Abstract:Abstract Background Using a multiple-measurement approach, we examined the real-world effectiveness of portable HEPA-air filtration devices (air cleaners) in a school setting. Methods We collected environmental (CO2, particle concentrations), epidemiological (absences related to respiratory infections), audio (coughing), and molecular data (bioaerosol and saliva samples) over seven weeks during winter 2022/2023 in two Swiss secondary school classes. Using a cross-over study design, we compared particle concentrations, coughing, and the risk of infection with versus without air cleaners. Results All 38 students (age 13−15 years) participated. With air cleaners, mean particle con- centration decreased by 77% (95% credible interval 63%−86%). There were no differences in CO2 levels. Absences related to respiratory infections were 22 without vs 13 with air cleaners. Bayesian modeling suggested a reduced risk of infection, with a posterior probability of 91% and a relative risk of 0.73 (95% credible interval 0.44−1.18). Coughing also tended to be less frequent (posterior probability 93%), indicating that fewer symptomatic students were in class. Molecular analysis detected mainly non-SARS-CoV-2 viruses in saliva (50/448 positive), but not in bioaerosols (2/105) or HEPA-filters (4/160). The detection rate was similar with vs without air cleaners. Spatiotemporal analysis of positive saliva samples identified several likely transmissions. Conclusions Air cleaners improved air quality and showed potential benefits in reducing respiratory infections. Airborne detection of non-SARS-CoV-2 viruses was rare, suggesting that these viruses may be more difficult to detect in the air. Future studies should examine the importance of close contact and long-range transmission, and the cost-effectiveness of using air cleaners.
immunology,infectious diseases,microbiology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?