Abstract:Large-scale seaweed and shellfish aquaculture are increasingly being considered by policymakers as a source of food, animal feed and bioproducts for Europe. These aquacultures are generally thought to be low impact or even beneficial for marine ecosystems as they are ‘extractive’ – i.e., growing passively on foodstuff already available in seawater, and with potential habitat provision, fisheries, climate mitigation and eutrophication mitigation benefits. At some scale however, over-extraction of nutrients or chlorophyll could potentially have a negative effect on natural systems. Understanding the likely impacts of aquaculture production at scale is important to identify when safe limits are being approached. Taking seaweed aquaculture as the primary focus, this work uses operational oceanographic model outputs to drive prognostic growth models to predict the likely optimal distribution of seaweed farms across European waters to meet different production scenarios. A novel nutrient transport scheme is then used to model the interacting ‘footprints’ of nutrient drawdown from aquaculture facilities to demonstrate the likely spatial impact of large-scale aquaculture. Evaluation of both seaweed and shellfish contributions to CO 2 balance under large scale production, and the potential impact on fisheries are also considered. The study finds that the impact of intensive seaweed aquaculture on nutrient availability could be significant where many farms are placed close together; but at the regional/basin scale even the highest level of production considered does not significantly impact total nutrient budgets. Seaweed aquaculture has the potential to extract large amounts of carbon dioxide, but the impact on carbon budgets depends on the end-use of the extracted seaweed. Shellfish aquaculture is a net source of CO 2 due to the impact of calcification of shells on the carbonate system (i.e., alkalinity removal). However, gram-for-gram the CO 2 impact of shellfish production is likely to be less than the impact of land-based meat production. Whilst operational oceanographic models are useful for taking a ‘broad brush’ approach to likely placement and impacts of aquaculture, reliable yield predictions for individual locations across European waters would require models integrating more physical and biogeochemical factors (wave environment, local currents, riverine inputs) at a finer scale than currently achievable.

A Norwegian seaweed utopia? Governmental narratives of coastal communities, upscaling, and the industrial conquering of ocean spaces

Algae and their potential for a future bioeconomy, landless food production, and the socio-economic impact of an algae industry

Seaweed: A bioindustrial game-changer for the green revolution

Mass Cultivation of Microalgae III: A Philosophical and Economic Exploration of Carbon Capture and Utilization

Maine seaweed benchmarking: Economically assessing the growth of an emerging sector

Technical challenges for offshore cultivation of kelp species: lessons learned and future directions

Spatiotemporal dynamics and resource use efficiency in mariculture production: A case study in Southeastern China

The seaweed hydrocolloid industry: 2016 updates, requirements, and outlook

Having our kelp and eating it too: Minimizing trade-offs from seaweed farming

Potential nutrient, carbon and fisheries impacts of large-scale seaweed and shellfish aquaculture in Europe evaluated using operational oceanographic model outputs

Dramatic Mariculture Expansion and Associated Driving Factors in Southeastern China

Current Status of the Algae Production Industry in Europe: An Emerging Sector of the Blue Bioeconomy

The Evolution Road of Seaweed Aquaculture: Cultivation Technologies and the Industry 4.0

Enabling transition thinking on complex issues (wicked problems): A framework for future circular economic transitions of plastic management in the Norwegian fisheries and aquaculture sectors.

Contested Coastal Commons and Blue Spatial Justice: Enclosures, Rescaling, and Resistance in Northern Norway

Navigating offshore aquaculture: Efficient strategies for policymakers in transition

The potential of seaweed for carbon capture.

Opportunities, challenges and future directions of open-water seaweed aquaculture in the United States

Blue Economy, Blue Growth, Social Equity and Small-scale Fisheries: A Global and National Level Review

The social science of offshore aquaculture: uncertainties, challenges and solution-oriented governance needs

Recent Advances in Seaweed Biorefineries and Assessment of Their Potential for Carbon Capture and Storage